Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Check out Street Photography section of our forum.
For Your Consideration
Do You Ever Blow the Highlights on Purpose - for "art's sake"?
Page <<first <prev 3 of 3
Mar 5, 2016 18:30:12   #
Uuglypher Loc: South Dakota (East River)
 
minniev wrote:
Inviting discussion, as well as posting of images where you may have done this yourself.

This particular image was shot into the sun and also into a clearing storm over Medicine Lake, where it is forbidden now even to stop due to danger of avalanche since the Excelsior fire that raged in the weeks before I got there. The road was opened only the day before, so you can still see the mix of atmospherics. I have shots where I preserved detail but this one was my favorite though I have no idea of its potential appeal to another human soul. It is a color shot, pretty much SOC after raw conversion. A bit is cropped from top and bottom.
Inviting discussion, as well as posting of images ... (show quote)


To answer your question:
Rarely, and only to exceptional effect!

Dave

Reply
Mar 5, 2016 19:22:58   #
Billyspad Loc: The Philippines
 
Uuglypher wrote:
To answer your question:
Rarely, and only to exceptional effect!

Dave


Amidst the plethora of mistakes lurking in the "artistic" corner comes Dave with the truth of the matter.

Great comment buddy. Will keep me chucking all day!
Do you have English blood? That comment is just so Anglo Saxon. Funny true and devoid of bull.

Reply
Mar 5, 2016 20:09:53   #
Chuck_893 Loc: Lincoln, Nebraska, USA
 
Frank2013 wrote:
So straighten me out here minniev. I took this into LR and found hardly any clipping....... a mere -6 on the highlight slider removed what little was there. Can't say I have intentionally blown highlights in the camera for art's sake but have for detail in the some shadows I wanted.
Minnie, I have not read all the way through, but my immediate reaction on seeing the shot was, What Blown Highlights? Just eyeballing it, it looks absolutely fine, and incidentally wonderful, a beautiful, entrancing picture.

I have glanced at a few of the other submissions and I still don't see highlights I would consider "blown." That to me is different from a specular highlight, like off the chrome handlebar of a motorcycle in the sun.

I can't say that I have ever deliberately blown a highlight, especially not since I switched to raw, but I've shot into the sun lots of times, like this for example, on the Oregon Coast. This was a jpeg as I hadn't switched to raw, but I doubt it would have made any difference.
Cape Lookout Sunset, Oregon Coast by Chuck Haacker, on Flickr
In this case I was waiting for the sun to get further down. I was fearful of blowing my sensor since so far as I know my camera has no actual shutter, but this couple came walking and I had to get them crossing the reflection. It was too early, the sun's too big, but I still love the shot for a memory if nothing else.

Reply
Check out AI Artistry and Creation section of our forum.
Mar 5, 2016 21:01:40   #
minniev Loc: MIssissippi
 
RichardTaylor wrote:
This is one of the few I have deliberately over exposed.
Shot on a cloudless day looking straight up. Took a correct exposure and this one.


That's pretty interesting. I am always experimenting, and most of the time those experiments don't amount to a darned thing. Every once in a while I end up with something I like and then I ask questions. Glad you shared your experiment! All the detail in the plant looks pretty nice against the "nothing" sky.

Reply
Mar 5, 2016 21:11:54   #
minniev Loc: MIssissippi
 
Billyspad wrote:
Are you talking of blowing them in camera or just not pulling back all the detail one can in PP?
I suspect the very good ones such as Jim the Photographer were a choice made in PP. He may indeed expose to the right purposely as per the recent tutorial on here. If you do that most of what you take looks "blown" when you open it in Camera Raw or similar.
Blowing in camera is generally a mistake and if one can drag an image out of it and satisfies the snappers idea of "art" then that's fine. Would not be the first mistake on these pages disguised as art and some even make pleasant viewing.
But nothing compares with the work of someone who knows how to use it and when. Jim's photograph has "blown" me away. Best example I have seen of controlled blown highlights in an awful long time. Worthy of study by anyone wishing to do it correctly.
Are you talking of blowing them in camera or just ... (show quote)


Zombie Thread Rises From The Dead!!

It is always interesting when that happens. Yeah, I meant blown on purpose in the camera, though I'm sure it could be done in post as well. Like I said in my post, I had several with full detail in the highlights but ended up liking the experimental shot better and wondered if anyone else had done similar.

Reply
Mar 5, 2016 21:13:47   #
minniev Loc: MIssissippi
 
Uuglypher wrote:
To answer your question:
Rarely, and only to exceptional effect!

Dave


Me either, but since I did it once, and kept this image, I was curious.

Thank you for a second look, 6 months later, after I'd forgot all about it!

Reply
Mar 5, 2016 21:27:40   #
minniev Loc: MIssissippi
 
Chuck_893 wrote:
Minnie, I have not read all the way through, but my immediate reaction on seeing the shot was, What Blown Highlights? Just eyeballing it, it looks absolutely fine, and incidentally wonderful, a beautiful, entrancing picture.

I have glanced at a few of the other submissions and I still don't see highlights I would consider "blown." That to me is different from a specular highlight, like off the chrome handlebar of a motorcycle in the sun.

I can't say that I have ever deliberately blown a highlight, especially not since I switched to raw, but I've shot into the sun lots of times, like this for example, on the Oregon Coast. This was a jpeg as I hadn't switched to raw, but I doubt it would have made any difference.
Cape Lookout Sunset, Oregon Coast by Chuck Haacker, on Flickr
In this case I was waiting for the sun to get further down. I was fearful of blowing my sensor since so far as I know my camera has no actual shutter, but this couple came walking and I had to get them crossing the reflection. It was too early, the sun's too big, but I still love the shot for a memory if nothing else.
Minnie, I have not read all the way through, but m... (show quote)


Thanks for pitching in Chuck! In this case, it is technically more lack of detail than totally blown I guess. It's pretty easy NOT to lose detail with a mirrorless camera unless you're experimenting like I was here. I have several shots with plenty of detail but in the end I liked this one and was curious if anyone else had done that and when/why. Thanks for sharing your sun-shot. I am always doing sun shots, which are often discarded, but when I get a decent one, I'm kinda happy.

And ain't nothing wrong with memory shots. Big sun and all!

Reply
Check out Black and White Photography section of our forum.
Mar 5, 2016 21:49:26   #
Billyspad Loc: The Philippines
 
minniev wrote:

the experimental shot better and wondered if anyone else had done similar.


Very unlikely min and lets have an honesty campaign starting now!
Experimental shot my butt gal lol lol lol. Mistake me thinks.
Good things can happen after a mistake but it remains what it was.

Or maybe experimental is the new full of respect term for mistake!!!!

Luv ya min

Reply
Mar 5, 2016 22:24:39   #
minniev Loc: MIssissippi
 
Billyspad wrote:
Very unlikely min and lets have an honesty campaign starting now!
Experimental shot my butt gal lol lol lol. Mistake me thinks.
Good things can happen after a mistake but it remains what it was.

Or maybe experimental is the new full of respect term for mistake!!!!

Luv ya min


Think whatever you wish, fella, but it would be damned hard to blow highlights accidentally with an EM1 unless you were shooting with your eyes closed:) Try it sometime if you get the chance and let me know how it goes. I make a whole bunch of mistakes but that ain't one of em.

Reply
Mar 5, 2016 22:33:02   #
Uuglypher Loc: South Dakota (East River)
 
Billyspad wrote:
Amidst the plethora of mistakes lurking in the "artistic" corner comes Dave with the truth of the matter.

Great comment buddy. Will keep me chucking all day!
Do you have English blood? That comment is just so Anglo Saxon. Funny true and devoid of bull.


Thanks, Billy,
And here 'tiz:

"...and Still They Attend"
"...and Still They Attend"...

Reply
Mar 6, 2016 00:10:03   #
Billyspad Loc: The Philippines
 
Uuglypher wrote:
Thanks, Billy,
And here 'tiz:


You were correct " to exceptional effect indeed".

Reply
Check out Street Photography section of our forum.
Mar 6, 2016 00:16:55   #
mcveed Loc: Kelowna, British Columbia (between trips)
 
To answer the title question: No, I do it often enough by accident.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 3 of 3
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
For Your Consideration
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.