Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
"Snapshooters" that was the pejorative
Page <prev 2 of 2
Jan 22, 2012 17:04:02   #
photogrl57 Loc: Tennessee
 
notnoBuddha wrote:
photogrl57 wrote:
notnoBuddha wrote:
A very quick read through this thread has me convinced I should either be offened or I have offended others. Can someone help me get in touch with my emotions - I am adrift.


I would but then I'd have to care ... that takes effort .. so I'll just get out the camera and take action shots of you as you drift :)


You learn well - Grasshopper.


I bow to the master

Reply
Jan 22, 2012 17:24:05   #
Pepper Loc: Planet Earth Country USA
 
MWAC wrote:
Pepper wrote:
I may have misunderstood the OP but as for myself I’d make it clear that I would never ridicule or “blast” anyone for taking their craft seriously. Secondly I have posted on many occasions an expression of gratitude for all those here who take their time to help those of us who seek their help. My objection is to those who ridicule and belittle those who ask what they perceive as “dumb questions”.
Beginners want to share in the conversation they want to participate but they must be allowed to participate at their level without being made fun of. It’s my understanding that this site is open to all who have an interest not just to those who have reached a specific level of competence. There are those, who are further along in their journey, that feel the beginner should learn in accordance to their standards. “I did this” or “I had to do that” or “they should do this”, why? who are they to cram their methodology down anyone else’s throat? If they don’t like the question or topic of discussion why not just move on to another thread? Why do they first feel the need to belittle the beginner before they move on? I hope I never get so good at anything that I feel justified in belittling others simply because they don’t measure up to my expectations.
I may have misunderstood the OP but as for myself ... (show quote)


I agree that beginners should never be belittled but in all honesty threads like this make those that are further along question if they should even share their knowledge. I know I will now question if the OP (or anyone that starts such a thread) is even open to C&C and if help is offered will the person trying to help end up getting blasted for being a snob? The chances of me offering the OP a helping hand just went down, there is more than enough people here on the UHH that are looking for help, I don't need to waste time on a poster that might come at me with guns a blazing because I had the balls to give him a few pointers or ideas on how to improve a picture (not that I think I am a better photographer than him nor do I think I am anywhere near to amazing but I do think I have something to offer newbies).

I cringe every time I see a thread calling out newbies for dumb or useless questions (if there even is such a thing) just as I cringe when I see a post calling more seasoned photographers snobs because they willing share knowledge that in some cases has taken them years to again. I am happy that there are some very talented photographers on this forum that are willing to share and help me along. I would never call any of them here snobs or "picture bigots", it's rude, insulting and will drive them to other forums were they will be more than welcome. Then what are we left with here at UHH? A bunch of newbies telling each other that their snapshots are wonderful and amazing? Is that what you really want in a photography forum? That's what Family and Facebook is for.
quote=Pepper I may have misunderstood the OP but ... (show quote)

I've read many of your posts and I don't think you are anywhere close to what the original poster is talking about, at least I hope not. To be quite frank I question my decision to jump into this because I really didn't want to get involved in a contrived pi**ing match if you know what I mean. My point is that everyone should feel welcome and feel free to participate without worrying about being ridiculed and again I've never seen you take that approach. I've found you to be very helpful and even more importantly very honest and sincere. Please note that if you found my remarks offensive in any way it was certainly not my intent.

Reply
Jan 22, 2012 17:56:21   #
PhotoArtsLA Loc: Boynton Beach
 
Mike629 wrote:
that made me mention "Snobs"...and you know who you are that used that term and then deny they are snobbish. I retract my apology, they are photo bigots. They think each time they depress the shuuter, God takes the shot. YOU ARE NOT ANSEL ADAMS, GET OVER YOUR BIG BAD AVERAGE SELF !!!


If I were Ansel Adams, I would take more time washing my prints. Friends of mine have printed by Ansel copies of shots like "Moonrise, Hernandez," which cost many thousands of dollars. Yet, you look a bit at the very expensive silver gelatin print and you see the fixer staining from lack of sufficient wash time. Even the great photographers are not always perfect, amplifying the notion every photographer never ceases to learn.

There is nothing wrong with snapshooting, nor in being an amateur. Any photo, regardless of technical or artistic merit, can have an immense depth of meaning for the photographer and their social circle. Conjuring memories of vast detail and depth of emotion, if even from a somewhat blurry image, is all it takes for a photo to be successful. Photography is audience-centric. The snapshooter's audience is his or her circle of friends and family. The fact about amateur photography: there are "happy accidents" when a professional level photograph appears in their work. Seeing success may spur the amateur to get better at the art.

Professional Photographers strive to shoot for the masses, meaning using born with or learned skills to achieve a level of aesthetic quality which bridges the distance between snapshot and photograph. Lighting, camera placement, lens choice, composition, props, posing, flare control, technical mastery, and timing, amongst many other variables, all gained through a lifetime of experience, attempt to create images which sell to a general audience outside of their personal sphere. Professional photography has a commercial element to it, and the professional's audience pays for getting it right.

However, even the most masterful efforts of the best professional photographers pale in every way to a snapshot of a new grandson in the eyes of his grandparents.

Art remains subjective.

Reply
 
 
Jan 23, 2012 10:36:03   #
MWAC Loc: Somewhere East Of Crazy
 
Pepper wrote:
I've read many of your posts and I don't think you are anywhere close to what the original poster is talking about, at least I hope not. To be quite frank I question my decision to jump into this because I really didn't want to get involved in a contrived pi**ing match if you know what I mean. My point is that everyone should feel welcome and feel free to participate without worrying about being ridiculed and again I've never seen you take that approach. I've found you to be very helpful and even more importantly very honest and sincere. Please note that if you found my remarks offensive in any way it was certainly not my intent.
I've read many of your posts and I don't think you... (show quote)


Oh Pepper, I hope you didn't think my reply was directed at you because I promise it wasn't 8-)

Threads like this calling out people who have knowledge as snobby because they offer help to newbies get's my knickers in a knot. Just as it does when I see a post calling out newbies for asking to many questions, I mean we all were newbies, I actually still consider myself a newbie, I mean shooting for one year does NOT make me a pro.

I actually don't think I have ever seen anyone be a photography snob here on the UHH. I think some are just over sensative and see people offering advise and not the glowing feedback they think they deserve as being snobs. When in reality they are offering very helpful advise that has taken their time and effort to learn and they are sharing it here FREELY and WILLINGLY.

Reply
Jan 23, 2012 12:01:24   #
Pepper Loc: Planet Earth Country USA
 
Whew! Thanks for the post MWAC, I feel much better now.

Reply
Jan 23, 2012 20:13:12   #
MWAC Loc: Somewhere East Of Crazy
 
Pepper wrote:
Whew! Thanks for the post MWAC, I feel much better now.


:thumbup:

Reply
Jan 23, 2012 21:44:14   #
picturedude Loc: Yosemite natl. park, Ca.
 
photogrl57 wrote:
I don't mind being called a snapshooter ... I've been called worse. I just consider myself a person that enjoys photography. I may never become the next Ansel Adams but the man is my hero. All I can do is my best, and never stop learning.


About the only thing I don't like being called is late for a meal.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 2
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.