JR1 wrote:
The first is a great shot of a workman, and I believe in colour it just would never work, tone, lighting, focus is spot on, the wood shavings are in 100% just the right place to in fill and the light is in the perfect place.
The second, if the first is 100% is 70%, the front of the bench is lit and distracts by about 30% from the chap, not enough shavings and the looks posed. Also the chair to the left is over lit
Hope you don't mind the comments, the top one is soooooo good
Thanks for the compliment.
I don't mind you commenting at all, rating the second image at 70% of the first is doing it more credit than it deserves. I posted it so that viewers might get a better idea of what is going on, not as a work of art.