Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register ☰
Main Photography Discussion
Is photo manipulation a deception?
Page 1 of 14 next> last>>
Mar 9, 2013 05:36:46   #
Atchy Loc: Essex England
 
What are my fellow Ugly Hedgehog members' opinions on this Photoshop or general manipulation of the image, debate.
Do you agree that Photoshop is ruining landscape photography.


http://digital-photography-school.com/opinion-why-photoshop-is-ruining-landscape-photography

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 05:40:45   #
VincentVG Loc: Venice (Currently)
 
Atchy wrote:
What are my fellow Ugly Hedgehog members' opinions on this Photoshop or general manipulation of the image, debate


http://digital-photography-school.com/opinion-why-photoshop-is-ruining-landscape-photography


It's been done to absolute death. Not again please!!!!

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 07:39:35   #
Singing Swan
 
Maybe you [Atchy] should just spend some time reading threads that have already beat this dead horse into cubed steak.

Reply
 
 
Mar 9, 2013 08:14:57   #
JR1 Loc: Tavistock, Devon, UK
 
VincentVG wrote:
Atchy wrote:
What are my fellow Ugly Hedgehog members' opinions on this Photoshop or general manipulation of the image, debate


http://digital-photography-school.com/opinion-why-photoshop-is-ruining-landscape-photography


It's been done to absolute death. Not again please!!!!


I agree 100% toooooooo many times, PLEASE use the search facility

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 08:19:02   #
JR1 Loc: Tavistock, Devon, UK
 
There appears to be many people who DO think like me, when I see the same old questions asked time and again I say just that, use the search function, then others have a go at me saying you should be nicer, you can not win.

Perhaps someone could (in admin) draw up a list of done to death topics

Or perhaps a general guide such as

"Before posting a question, please use the search facility to see if it has already been asked before"

OR

The "search" made easier to see with perhaps a title

"has the question you are about to ask been asked before, search here before posting"

NO disrespect intended, oh, I ALWAYS leave a link to previous questions though as it does help

http://www.uglyhedgehog.com/search.jsp?q=is+altering+an+image+right&u=&s=0

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 08:34:02   #
Lacey Girl Loc: Las Cruces, NM
 
JR1 wrote:
There appears to be many people who DO think like me, when I see the same old questions asked time and again I say just that, use the search function, then others have a go at me saying you should be nicer, you can not win.

Perhaps someone could (in admin) draw up a list of done to death topics

Or perhaps a general guide such as

"Before posting a question, please use the search facility to see if it has already been asked before"

OR

The "search" made easier to see with perhaps a title

"has the question you are about to ask been asked before, search here before posting"

NO disrespect intended, oh, I ALWAYS leave a link to previous questions though as it does help

http://www.uglyhedgehog.com/search.jsp?q=is+altering+an+image+right&u=&s=0
There appears to be many people who DO think like ... (show quote)


I am not challenging you on your thoughts, just want to pose a question regarding repetitive questions. Do you think maybe they would rather have present conversation on the topic because maybe there could be others to offer new updated information? Just wondering.

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 08:42:12   #
Atchy Loc: Essex England
 
Sounds reasonable to me Lacey Girl. I was beginning to feel a bit unloved!

Reply
 
 
Mar 9, 2013 08:48:04   #
Lacey Girl Loc: Las Cruces, NM
 
Atchy wrote:
Sounds reasonable to me Lacey Girl. I was beginning to feel a bit unloved!


Some don't like to discuss topics that are repeated but those that don't mind will chime in so hang in there, you will get some responses from those that don't mind or maybe from those that are new to the forum. Not from me though cause I don't manipulate other than cropping in my camera. :lol:

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 09:07:45   #
Atchy Loc: Essex England
 
VincentVG wrote:
Atchy wrote:
What are my fellow Ugly Hedgehog members' opinions on this Photoshop or general manipulation of the image, debate


http://digital-photography-school.com/opinion-why-photoshop-is-ruining-landscape-photography


It's been done to absolute death. Not again please!!!!


With new members, like you, it could be that they could add something to an, admittedly much discussed topic. Not so it appears !!!

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 09:11:55   #
JR1 Loc: Tavistock, Devon, UK
 
Lacey Girl wrote:
JR1 wrote:
There appears to be many people who DO think like me, when I see the same old questions asked time and again I say just that, use the search function, then others have a go at me saying you should be nicer, you can not win.

Perhaps someone could (in admin) draw up a list of done to death topics

Or perhaps a general guide such as

"Before posting a question, please use the search facility to see if it has already been asked before"

OR

The "search" made easier to see with perhaps a title

"has the question you are about to ask been asked before, search here before posting"

NO disrespect intended, oh, I ALWAYS leave a link to previous questions though as it does help

http://www.uglyhedgehog.com/search.jsp?q=is+altering+an+image+right&u=&s=0
There appears to be many people who DO think like ... (show quote)


I am not challenging you on your thoughts, just want to pose a question regarding repetitive questions. Do you think maybe they would rather have present conversation on the topic because maybe there could be others to offer new updated information? Just wondering.
quote=JR1 There appears to be many people who DO ... (show quote)


100% fully agree with you, however it would be nice if people searched first, perhaps saying "I have looked through previous posts but still wondered if..........."

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 09:13:17   #
JR1 Loc: Tavistock, Devon, UK
 
Atchy wrote:
VincentVG wrote:
Atchy wrote:
What are my fellow Ugly Hedgehog members' opinions on this Photoshop or general manipulation of the image, debate


http://digital-photography-school.com/opinion-why-photoshop-is-ruining-landscape-photography


It's been done to absolute death. Not again please!!!!


With new members, like you, it could be that they could add something to an, admittedly much discussed topic. Not so it appears !!!


I agree again, but you aske a question you did not propose a new idea, along the lines of


I have read previous posts or I know it has been discussed before because I have looked but what do you think of this.....

Reply
 
 
Mar 9, 2013 09:16:10   #
Atchy Loc: Essex England
 
JR1 wrote:
Lacey Girl wrote:
JR1 wrote:
There appears to be many people who DO think like me, when I see the same old questions asked time and again I say just that, use the search function, then others have a go at me saying you should be nicer, you can not win.

Perhaps someone could (in admin) draw up a list of done to death topics

Or perhaps a general guide such as

"Before posting a question, please use the search facility to see if it has already been asked before"



OR

The "search" made easier to see with perhaps a title

"has the question you are about to ask been asked before, search here before posting"

NO disrespect intended, oh, I ALWAYS leave a link to previous questions though as it does help

http://www.uglyhedgehog.com/search.jsp?q=is+altering+an+image+right&u=&s=0
There appears to be many people who DO think like ... (show quote)


I am not challenging you on your thoughts, just want to pose a question regarding repetitive questions. Do you think maybe they would rather have present conversation on the topic because maybe there could be others to offer new updated information? Just wondering.
quote=JR1 There appears to be many people who DO ... (show quote)


100% fully agree with you, however it would be nice if people searched first, perhaps saying "I have looked through previous posts but still wondered if..........."
quote=Lacey Girl quote=JR1 There appears to be m... (show quote)



Why? If you don't like the topic move
on. There's lots of others

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 09:18:13   #
JR1 Loc: Tavistock, Devon, UK
 
Atchy wrote:
JR1 wrote:
Lacey Girl wrote:
JR1 wrote:
There appears to be many people who DO think like me, when I see the same old questions asked time and again I say just that, use the search function, then others have a go at me saying you should be nicer, you can not win.

Perhaps someone could (in admin) draw up a list of done to death topics

Or perhaps a general guide such as

"Before posting a question, please use the search facility to see if it has already been asked before"



OR

The "search" made easier to see with perhaps a title

"has the question you are about to ask been asked before, search here before posting"

NO disrespect intended, oh, I ALWAYS leave a link to previous questions though as it does help

http://www.uglyhedgehog.com/search.jsp?q=is+altering+an+image+right&u=&s=0
There appears to be many people who DO think like ... (show quote)


I am not challenging you on your thoughts, just want to pose a question regarding repetitive questions. Do you think maybe they would rather have present conversation on the topic because maybe there could be others to offer new updated information? Just wondering.
quote=JR1 There appears to be many people who DO ... (show quote)


100% fully agree with you, however it would be nice if people searched first, perhaps saying "I have looked through previous posts but still wondered if..........."
quote=Lacey Girl quote=JR1 There appears to be m... (show quote)



Why? If you don't like the topic move
on. There's lots of others
quote=JR1 quote=Lacey Girl quote=JR1 There appe... (show quote)


The idea of a forum is to discuss and offer advice which people have done, me and others, like it or not the question has been answered.

Just remember NO ONE HERE is having a go at anyone "here" just responding to a question

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 09:18:22   #
Pepper Loc: Planet Earth Country USA
 
Instead of bitching because of the topic or question someone posts why not just pass it by? JR1 you're smart enough to know by the title what this thread was about and you're obviously sick of the topic so why the hell did you click on it? Seems you may have the greater problem...JMHO of course.

As for the question, I think PP is fine and some do it with great taste and it cam make a good shot great or a great shot awesome. I also see some that are way overdone and can make a person or scene look plastic. In my opinion PP done well will compliment rather than dominate the content of the image.

Reply
Mar 9, 2013 09:23:38   #
Atchy Loc: Essex England
 
JR1 wrote:
Atchy wrote:
JR1 wrote:
Lacey Girl wrote:
JR1 wrote:
There appears to be many people who DO think like me, when I see the same old questions asked time and again I say just that, use the search function, then others have a go at me saying you should be nicer, you can not win.

Perhaps someone could (in admin) draw up a list of done to death topics

Or perhaps a general guide such as

"Before posting a question, please use the search facility to see if it has already been asked before"



OR

The "search" made easier to see with perhaps a title

"has the question you are about to ask been asked before, search here before posting"

NO disrespect intended, oh, I ALWAYS leave a link to previous questions though as it does help

http://www.uglyhedgehog.com/search.jsp?q=is+altering+an+image+right&u=&s=0
There appears to be many people who DO think like ... (show quote)


I am not challenging you on your thoughts, just want to pose a question regarding repetitive questions. Do you think maybe they would rather have present conversation on the topic because maybe there could be others to offer new updated information? Just wondering.
quote=JR1 There appears to be many people who DO ... (show quote)


100% fully agree with you, however it would be nice if people searched first, perhaps saying "I have looked through previous posts but still wondered if..........."
quote=Lacey Girl quote=JR1 There appears to be m... (show quote)



Why? If you don't like the topic move
on. There's lots of others
quote=JR1 quote=Lacey Girl quote=JR1 There appe... (show quote)


The idea of a forum is to discuss and offer advice which people have done, me and others, like it or not the question has been answered.

Just remember NO ONE HERE is having a go at anyone "here" just responding to a question
quote=Atchy quote=JR1 quote=Lacey Girl quote=J... (show quote)


It's not obligatory to make a comment on every post.

Reply
Page 1 of 14 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
Home | Latest Digest | Back to Top | All Sections
Contact us | Privacy policy | Terms of use | DMCA
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.