Nice.

Nice stuff.

5

Beautiful.

For the first time in my life, I like the B&W better.

It's a beauty.

Nice.

I do like it. Better than most B&W's posted here.

I note that sometimes a photo is posted asking for feedback. The photo is really nice so I have very little feedback, if any, other that to say it is good. But, the feed back that comes from advanced photographers is profound and plentiful. All kinds of little things are pointed out, stuff I did not even see. But it's good feedback especially if one is entering a competition. So, to your question, should we all be analyzing photos this way?

Absolutely not. But when a photo is obviously bad and it is followed by many posts saying how wonderful it is, then we all should all chime in and correct that obviously incorrect impression.

A beauty.

I loved those waterfalls and the last image as well!

When looking at these images one after another, #2 seems over done. However, If I just looked at #2 without ever seeing #1, I wonder what my opinion would be?

Charming.

I like these.

I often post disparaging remarks about poor photos when all the others are giving kudos. It makes me wonder if these folks know anything about photography.