CHG_CANON wrote:
for Manglesphoto and wsa111: it's not what the LCD shows, it's what the histogram tells you. You might have your LCD set on bright and / or auto. But, the LCD image display is to help you decide sharpness and framing. The histogram tells you the distribution of light and dark. You likely should change your display to show the histogram rather than the image on the LCD display. You don't have to keep the display one way or another. When shooting flip between the two to assure a good looking image looks 'good' on the histogram too. If the images from the cruise are still on the two cameras, scroll through their histograms and see that the underexposed were exposed to the left when viewed in the histogram.
There's a 99% surety that sending the camera off to Nikon will just be a waste of time and money.
BTW - what do you mean by "had to Lightroom 90% of my shots"? I've updated my technique to ETTR (Expose to the Right). But, if I hit the <auto> button in LR5, the software consistently wants to add another +0.50 to the exposure. I like ideas LR will give from Auto, particularly adjusting whites, and blacks and shadows, but I always need to adjust an auto adjustment to exposure. I use the <previous> and copy settings / paste settings to "sync" a number of images after the initial adjustments to an image in a sequence in the same conditions.
Regarding histogram: http://luminous-landscape.com/understanding-histograms/
for Manglesphoto and wsa111: it's u not /u what ... (
show quote)
L/R can't see our screens and it interprets the histogram a little differently than I do. It does tend to make the brightness level most appropriate for prints. If your screen is a little off it may appear to adjust more. The apparent brightness levels of computer screens and especially camera screens vary significantly according to environmental light and calibration so there isn't a universal hardware solution. You'll probably never get 100% perfect exposures from your camera, but you can make satisfactory adjustments if they are close. Controlled testing and evaluation in various situations is the best way to hone in on a shooting paradigm that works best for you. Bottom line is that it's easier and cheaper for you to adjust.