larryepage wrote:
It is easy to determine whether the problem is AF or VR. If AF, you will be able to see the distance scale moving in its window. If VR, there should be no movement of that scale. Knowing which will allow a much more definitive discussion with Nikon service.
Also...when evaluating repair vs. replace, you may want to keep in mind that very nice used copies of that lens are readily available for around $450.
I believe that is a good piece of advice. Eventually after being unable to buy a new or used lens from my local camera shop, I found one on eBay and have it on order. At least I can have one to use and then decide later what to do with the one that is not operational.