I have been experimenting and following various postings on UHH for black and white photography, This conversion seems to me to meet requirements of shape, contrast, and tonal values. Since I am not sure yet that I have this sort of photographic vision, I would appreciate your input. Incidentally or maybe more to the point, when I see something that might work in black and white it is because any given itself pulls me towards that treatment; it is not that I see a subject that I would intend as a black and white image. I just don't see that way yet. So, I go as I can. And thanks for looking.
AndyH
Loc: Massachusetts and New Hampshire
Take a look at some of the excellent videos on YouTube on b/w photography. And some of the excellent images here. You’ll know you’re getting it when you begin to see which images might look good in black and white.
This particular image is a little less contrasts than I prefer, but that’s all a matter of personal preference.
It’s a lot of fun when you get into it.
Andy
Thanks for looking and for your suggestions.
Great range of tones. As noted, without strong darks. That gives the image a "soft" look, which is fine if that's what you want.
AndyH
Loc: Massachusetts and New Hampshire
What post processing software do you use? Black and white from a color digital image offers lots of choices but needs good pp today.
Andy
I agree with the comment that my preference on your photo would be more contrast. I must say that I don't do a lot of black and white but over the years some of my favorites have been of people. I will post a couple in a new thread.
AndyH
Loc: Massachusetts and New Hampshire
By the way, the suggestion for more contrast was not about the photo or processing, just the scene itself, which I really love otherwise. You’ve achieved a full range of zones, from darkest to whitest. I love the ghostly ambience and stacked rectangles.
But why is the GEICO Gecko 🦎 standing in front of the gas pumps? 😉
Andy
thanks. I don't know what I want. The reason your's and other's comments are helpful. I'm trying to delop a vision or a mode of perception.
I use Elements 15, and it has helped a great deal.
Thanks. I will look for it.
Andy. I did not see that since I was looking at the object as a cou-off electrical connection.
AndyH
Loc: Massachusetts and New Hampshire
Chicflat wrote:
Andy. I did not see that since I was looking at the object as a cou-off electrical connection.
When I enlarged it, it was clear, and fit the scene. Just laughing at myself because my first thought was the Gecko!
Andy
Chicflat wrote:
I have been experimenting and following various postings on UHH for black and white photography, This conversion seems to me to meet requirements of shape, contrast, and tonal values. Since I am not sure yet that I have this sort of photographic vision, I would appreciate your input. Incidentally or maybe more to the point, when I see something that might work in black and white it is because any given itself pulls me towards that treatment; it is not that I see a subject that I would intend as a black and white image. I just don't see that way yet. So, I go as I can. And thanks for looking.
I have been experimenting and following various po... (
show quote)
Needs more contrast. Where we stay away from excessive contrast in color, in grayscale it makes for a more dramatic image.
Chicflat wrote:
I have been experimenting and following various postings on UHH for black and white photography, This conversion seems to me to meet requirements of shape, contrast, and tonal values. Since I am not sure yet that I have this sort of photographic vision, I would appreciate your input. Incidentally or maybe more to the point, when I see something that might work in black and white it is because any given itself pulls me towards that treatment; it is not that I see a subject that I would intend as a black and white image. I just don't see that way yet. So, I go as I can. And thanks for looking.
I have been experimenting and following various po... (
show quote)
Needs more Contrast. While we stay away from excessive contrast in color, with grayscale, it adds drama.
It looks to me like you’re on the right track. Something I always look for when shooting for b&w are images that will give the complete tonal range of black blacks and white whites.
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.