idaholover wrote:
In regard to "government licensing". The government takes away your rights so they can sell them back to you.
I would say government taxes your rights.
They also regulate your rights.
I tend to believe the "General Welfare" clause should more closely follow Madison than Hamilton.
Hamilton basically argued for the unlimited monetary funding for the General Welfare.
Madison believed that General Welfare should be limited to ensure only Constitutional rights.
Because of the way things were, Resource pollution was not considered during the founding. It was a flaw.
However, The EPA has gone way to far in many areas. The "Tragedy of the Commons", which I often quote showed the downfall of commonly own land. The founders at the time were well aware of this.
I am glad we had the EPA to help ensure clean air and water. I also believe the regulations when they are no longer needed should be stricken.
Libertarianism has a fundamental flaw in one area and that deals with the environment.
A second flaw would probably be the view on the Military funding.
Because we have Nukes now. You have to have a centralized military. That was not the case at the founding.
The arguments against laissez faire capitalism by the left is weak. The libertarians and conservatives are right in that area.... In my opinions.
I have never felt threatened because someone has more than someone else. No matter how much more they have. I have no qualms about how they got it unless it was taken by force or fraud(aka Bernie Madoff) In the really big picture Wealth after it is collected never last longer than a generation or two. It gets redistributed to a new people in a new time that innovate.
AKA
Larry Ellison, Bill Gates, Michael Dell, Stephen Jobs...
It would be no different without Government regulation and taxation.
I support the rights of voluntary collectives. The Church, Feminist, Hollywood(LOL), AMA(both of them).........
Where I have a problem is with collectives promote by using government coercion to remove one persons or other groups liberty.
You tax A to support B. One of the governments job is to prevent force of voluntary collectives. Taxation is force.
Business do this too. Big companies lobby congress to initiate force(regulate) small business development.
I think I'll take a break now....I've been posting here to practice my writing skills mainly. Time to create a little wealth now.