2nd one looks washed out. If a pic of the moon is what you're looking for take #1 and crop it down to enlarge the moon. I shot this with a 18-270 zoom, fully extended, 250 ISO, 1/250s, f6.3, hand held.......
They are nice shots since the mid-west has been hazey the last few nights.....it finally started to clear up. I have a 55-300mm and they are similiar to yours. Not all of us can afford a 300 prime! What body are you using?
Well I know I cant afford one right now, And my body is a Canon Rebel t3i. Thanks DonB