Gene51 wrote:
I think you are still missing my point. You make a statement that you won't pass judgement on an image, and before you reach the period in the same sentence you do exactly what you said you wouldn't do, you state that - "in [your] opinion [it] is a poorly captured image presented in black and white" this is confusing. If it is your opinion that it was a poorly captured image, is that not a passing judgement?
I maintain that what he did was not an accident and a tour de force of his processing skills was able to "salvage" a poor image. I believe him when he described, in his anecdote - which I hope you read - that he used his previous experience with lunar exposures to set the camera for this shot. He did give it some thought. And he was the type of photographer so comfortable with his pre-visualization skills that he could already imagine the final product even before he triggered the shutter. His whole Zone System is based on that pre-visualization and understanding of light. I don't agree that it was a poorly executed image. I do know, from the 1000s of B&W prints I have made over the years, that, particularly with natural subjects, the contact print is rarely good enough to show, but it is a great place to start when deciding how you are going to execute the final product.
I take it you have never processed your own photos. I have a lot of respect for you - but in this case, your lack of experience and misconceptions are clearly preventing you from seeing the bigger picture. Not to be disparaging, but it reminds me of when I tried to get my kids to eat zucchini - the three of them joined in a chorus of "but we don't like ZUCCHINI!!!" To which I responded, "how do you know, you've never eaten it" to which they responded, "we just know, we dont' like it!!!" It was served, they complained then they ate it and didn't die. All three love zucchini these days - moral to the story - try the things that don't make sense to you before you try them - you may be surprised. Or remain stuck in your poorly informed opinion. Your choice. You've got nothing to lose in trying, and you may actually end up learning and using the new skill-set to make better pictures.
I think you are still missing my point. You make a... (
show quote)
Look at the image and tell me it is well captured. Are you drifting into self-denial? I would be concerned if tdekany agrees with me. I'm done.