pendennis wrote:
At that time, there was no standard of discipline aboard Navy ships. Until 1950, when the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) was established, discipline was very much at the beck and call of the ship's captain, or senior officer at shore installations. The system then was known as "Rocks and Shoals", and the presumption made was guilt and not innocence.
Flogging was banned in 1850, and the maximum punishment allowed was confinement to the brig for a time determined at Captain's Mast, along with dietary restrictions. For more serious offenses, e.g. murder, prisoners were usually confined to the brig until the ship reached U.S. shores and a court martial could be convened.
Until the late 1960's, a lot of convicted Navy personnel were confined to the Portsmouth Naval Prison, Portsmouth, NH. Marine MP's operated the brigs, and they were sadistic, at times. A friend of mine, who's father was stationed at the prison as a Corpsman, was able to get us a tour. The place was like a dungeon, the last place I'd want to be.
When I was in boot camp at Great Lakes, there were prisoners who "enjoyed" the privilege of eating in the mess hall under the watchful eyes of Marine MP's. The prisoners were admonished about any talk. Once, when a prisoner recognized a boot from his hometown, he said "Hello", and that brought the MP's nightstick to his solar plexus.
At that time, there was no standard of discipline ... (
show quote)
I was in the Marine Corps 60-67. I knew about the Portsmouth Brig. It was not a vacation and was reserved for serious offenders. If it were easy what would be the deterrent?