jonsommer wrote:
I think your black and white photos are exceptionally well done!
Just a quick comment on the male vs female model, as an artist, painter and illustrator I have spent hundreds if not thousands of hours learning to draw (the preferred term is 'undraped' not 'nude' at least at the Los Angeles Art Directors Guild) the human figure. It is also one of the most difficult things to learn to draw and paint convincingly because we are all so very familiar with the human body, that we all easily recognize the smallest flaw in the finished piece. I have drawn both male and female undraped figures, and I think that I'm learning to see the beauty in each, but it's been harder for me to see the beauty in the male body. I thought it very interesting to note that at a membership vote at the Guild a couple of months ago, with the membership being just about 50/50 male and female, the question was asked if we preferred male or female models, and the result was that 76% preferred female models, 18% preferred male models and the remaining 6% said they had no preference in gender, as long as the model knew what they were doing, they just wanted to draw. Although I have done a lot of drawing, I have only photographed one undraped female, and I was actually surprised at how difficult finding a good pose and complimentary lighting setup was. Consider that we use term 'handsome' for men and the word 'beautiful' to describe women, if someone talks about a beautiful man it's hard to imagine what that would look like, and if someone says that a woman is handsome, well, that's isn't usually considered a compliment. So here's my bottom line, because I find the female form amazingly beautiful, with curves, and breasts, and softness and gentleness, I can see the beauty easily, with a male model it's much more difficult . . . but it's there, we just have to learn to see it.
I think your black and white photos are exceptiona... (
show quote)
Great comments Jon and thank you for verbalizing that. I am most definitely in the 76% but there are also some good looking males who are great models (clothed or otherwise) The beauty of a woman cannot be matched and as photographers it is our job to honour her beauty to the very best of our ability.
However you also make another very good point. As photographers when we photograph women (generally speaking) we have beauty in our minds, when we photograph men (generally speaking) we have masculinity in our minds but we have to bring the best out in our subject whether we are thinking beauty or masculine, we need to recognize the beauty in a man and the masculinity in a woman if either is in their demeanour. Cheers, Mark