Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Weight limit for carry on
Page <prev 2 of 5 next> last>>
Sep 26, 2017 06:43:22   #
jerryc41 Loc: Catskill Mts of NY
 
Jenobandito wrote:
I am flying on Emirate Airlines to South Africa for 12 days, two of which will be in an open vehicle on safari, and they have a strict one bag rule in the cabin. One, not a carry-on and a personal item, only one bag on board with a weight limit of 15#. I am stressing about putting bubble wrapped items in the belly of the plane, even with additional insurance on them. My list contains two bodies, two 28-135mm lenses, one 100-400mm lens, a 100-300mm lens, an a 20mm lens, plus batteries, chargers, etc. In addition I will have my Mac for transferring images nightly. In the bag it weighs about 25#, and to get the things I need on the long flight, Kindle, inflatable pillow, eye covers, sani-wipes, ect. I cannot take it all on board. I will be wearing a photo vest, and could put some lenses in the pocket, but I cannot get all equipment in the vest and camera backpack. After boarding the plane it will be necessary to move items from the pockets into the backpack, and there will not be room along with my other things. Should I cut out one 28-135 lens? Should I opt for the lighter 100-300mm lens? Shall I eliminate the 20mm lens? I need advice from others who have encountered a similar situation. I have called Emirate to double check and see if they have special rules for photo equipment, and the answer has been no twice. There is always a chance they will not weigh it, but it they did I would be in trouble. Please advice.
I am flying on Emirate Airlines to South Africa fo... (show quote)


On my last few flights, I had a backpack and a small camera on my belt. No more checked baggage for me.

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 06:55:08   #
LoneRangeFinder Loc: Left field
 
jerryc41 wrote:
On my last few flights, I had a backpack and a small camera on my belt. No more checked baggage for me.

Agree. We take too much. My travel bag is 21"x14"x9", which can double as a backpack. Along with that, I take a small day pack, which can fit in the bag. No checked baggage. The small day pack has my iPad, one ASPC mirrorless and one lens, passport....

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 06:59:25   #
mborn Loc: Massachusetts
 
Jenobandito wrote:
I am flying on Emirate Airlines to South Africa for 12 days, two of which will be in an open vehicle on safari, and they have a strict one bag rule in the cabin. One, not a carry-on and a personal item, only one bag on board with a weight limit of 15#. I am stressing about putting bubble wrapped items in the belly of the plane, even with additional insurance on them. My list contains two bodies, two 28-135mm lenses, one 100-400mm lens, a 100-300mm lens, an a 20mm lens, plus batteries, chargers, etc. In addition I will have my Mac for transferring images nightly. In the bag it weighs about 25#, and to get the things I need on the long flight, Kindle, inflatable pillow, eye covers, sani-wipes, ect. I cannot take it all on board. I will be wearing a photo vest, and could put some lenses in the pocket, but I cannot get all equipment in the vest and camera backpack. After boarding the plane it will be necessary to move items from the pockets into the backpack, and there will not be room along with my other things. Should I cut out one 28-135 lens? Should I opt for the lighter 100-300mm lens? Shall I eliminate the 20mm lens? I need advice from others who have encountered a similar situation. I have called Emirate to double check and see if they have special rules for photo equipment, and the answer has been no twice. There is always a chance they will not weigh it, but it they did I would be in trouble. Please advice.
I am flying on Emirate Airlines to South Africa fo... (show quote)


South African Air more liberal weight Had no problems JFK to Johannesburg

Reply
 
 
Sep 26, 2017 07:54:03   #
cthahn
 
They have rules. If you want to fly with them, you have to follow the rules. You are the photographer, your decision as to what to take.

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 07:56:45   #
jccash Loc: Longwood, Florida
 
dave_roe wrote:
Upgrade to business class or first. Bag limits change and they are to be a lot more willing to be helpful.


That upgrade would cost $5,000 business classs and $16,000 first class each way. I looked into that option last June.

I traveled Orlando JFK, Dubai, Johannesburg on Air Emeritus a380a. Fantastic flights.

My daughter and I checked on one bag but each carried on two bags. I had two camera back packs. No problem and they did not weigh our carry on bags.

Return flight JBurg, Dubai, Orlando. In Dubai I had to turn in all electronics before boarding. I could bring my cell phone. They packed my cameras in a sealed box which was returned to me in Orlando. I did keep my memory cards with me.

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 08:04:21   #
mainshipper Loc: Hernando, Florida
 
rjaywallace wrote:
Either don't take so much stuff or don't travel. Am not unsympathetic, but that is today's reality.


I've flown Emirates the last two years from Florida to SE Asia and have had issues with carry on limits but mainly on weight. I am traveling with them again in February and saw the one carry on limit when I booked the tickets. I will call them and clarify that it's really only one and not a personal item and a bag. When I went with them this year I had a small backpack and a shoulder bag with my camera gear and was allowed to carry it on on all legs. A lot depends on the gate agent.

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 08:17:19   #
muggins88 Loc: Inverness, Florida
 
twowindsbear wrote:
Ship the stuff to yourself at your destination address.

Don't thak so much other stuff, like clothes and stuff - buy a change of clothes at a second hand store when you get there then donate it back when you leave.

Use a better box to check your stuff to protect it.

Fly another carrier with more liberal limits.



Reply
 
 
Sep 26, 2017 08:21:25   #
mainshipper Loc: Hernando, Florida
 
muggins88 wrote:


Ship to Africa. Now that sounds like a winner.

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 08:28:05   #
Bultaco Loc: Aiken, SC
 
We've been to South Africa twice. The first trip I took a D7100 and 4 lens and only used 2, 28-300 and 150-600, took 2 on the second trip. My wife took her SX50. We never take anything for back up when flying, just several SD cards.

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 08:30:01   #
crazydaddio Loc: Toronto Ontario Canada
 
I take all my crap with me and have not yet considered putting it all into the luggage....I am in your camp.
The vest is a good idea. If you are travelling with others, have a distribution plan to even the weight if needed (vest, friends purse etc).


GET ON EARLY ...be first to line up for your zone. Worst case scenario is having to skycheck your luggage at the gate due to no overhead space (and the equip you are describing likely wont fit under the seat)....I would not get on the flight at that point (15k of equipment in my Lowepro Protastic450....great bag but long lenses will still get damaged as it is being tossed around by the baggage handlers.

You may want to consider a hybrid solution if you are not travelling with a friend.
Bubble pack your redundant body and lens (make sure they are seperated and packed individually otherwise you create a stress point at the mount).
Carry the rest.if you lose the redundant stuff...you will still have a great photography trip.
...and split the accessories between carryon and packed. Same reason.

I went to Hawaii and Jamaica this year and took most of my crap with me. 2/3 bodies 5 lenses. Flashes, tripod, laptop, backup HD, lots of accessories...lunatic :-)

All worked out as I travelled with my wife and a 2nd pack. I think I may have packed 1 lens in the end.

...and used them all :-)

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 09:10:50   #
windshoppe Loc: Arizona
 
jcboy3 wrote:
Take the critical stuff in carryon, check or leave behind the rest. So I would say one body, one 28-135 lens, the 100-400, batteries, one charger. As for the computer; it's more efficient to get a bunch of memory cards and a WD Wireless drive, use your phone to control it, and leave the computer behind.

And consider a different airline in the future.


Totally agree with this suggestion. No need for more than the two lenses. On safari I would use 2 bodies so no lens changes. On my last safari I used the 100-400 for 99% of my shots.

I have no experience with your airline, but encountered the same type of restrictions on 6 internal flights in South Africa using 5 different airlines. In one instance my solution was to strap the 100-400 lens in its case to my belt, thus removing it and its weight from my carry-on. As it turned out not once was my bag weighed and the majority of passengers on all of the airlines had far larger carry-ons than I did. Lots of worry and concern for nothing.

Reply
 
 
Sep 26, 2017 09:56:21   #
Jenobandito
 
wrangler5 wrote:
You posited a scenario with very specific constraints which do not leave a lot of available options for people to suggest. There are NO options which would meet your obviously preferred solution - let me take it all in the cabin - within your original parameters of specific airline and seating class, with the limits those impose. Those options which WERE suggested are about all that's left, and after they were offered you then added ADDITIONAL constraints which make some of the options non-starters.

So one wonders - what "types of comments" DID you expect, given the decision box you set up in the first place? It looks like the ones you got pretty well exhaust the options.
You posited a scenario with very specific constrai... (show quote)


I did not expect to be told to stay home and watch National Geographic, fly a different airline, stop stressing. I was just expressing my concerns, I thought I would get more advice on how to pack in checked luggage for safety. Many articles, and a person who has been there, state again and again that flights to Africa frequently come up missing items or entire luggage never to be seen again.

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 10:04:09   #
Jenobandito
 
jccash wrote:
That upgrade would cost $5,000 business classs and $16,000 first class each way. I looked into that option last June.

I traveled Orlando JFK, Dubai, Johannesburg on Air Emeritus a380a. Fantastic flights.

My daughter and I checked on one bag but each carried on two bags. I had two camera back packs. No problem and they did not weigh our carry on bags.

Return flight JBurg, Dubai, Orlando. In Dubai I had to turn in all electronics before boarding. I could bring my cell phone. They packed my cameras in a sealed box which was returned to me in Orlando. I did keep my memory cards with me.
That upgrade would cost $5,000 business classs and... (show quote)


Actually, this upgrade to business class would cost a total of $11,858.25. I called. I have called Emirates three times to verify what I have been told. I do understand that my bag may not be weighed. I never have had that problem on other airlines, but.....

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 10:05:07   #
Jenobandito
 
crazydaddio wrote:
I take all my crap with me and have not yet considered putting it all into the luggage....I am in your camp.
The vest is a good idea. If you are travelling with others, have a distribution plan to even the weight if needed (vest, friends purse etc).


GET ON EARLY ...be first to line up for your zone. Worst case scenario is having to skycheck your luggage at the gate due to no overhead space (and the equip you are describing likely wont fit under the seat)....I would not get on the flight at that point (15k of equipment in my Lowepro Protastic450....great bag but long lenses will still get damaged as it is being tossed around by the baggage handlers.

You may want to consider a hybrid solution if you are not travelling with a friend.
Bubble pack your redundant body and lens (make sure they are seperated and packed individually otherwise you create a stress point at the mount).
Carry the rest.if you lose the redundant stuff...you will still have a great photography trip.
...and split the accessories between carryon and packed. Same reason.

I went to Hawaii and Jamaica this year and took most of my crap with me. 2/3 bodies 5 lenses. Flashes, tripod, laptop, backup HD, lots of accessories...lunatic :-)

All worked out as I travelled with my wife and a 2nd pack. I think I may have packed 1 lens in the end.

...and used them all :-)
I take all my crap with me and have not yet consid... (show quote)


Thank you.

Reply
Sep 26, 2017 10:09:24   #
Jenobandito
 
windshoppe wrote:
Totally agree with this suggestion. No need for more than the two lenses. On safari I would use 2 bodies so no lens changes. On my last safari I used the 100-400 for 99% of my shots.

I have no experience with your airline, but encountered the same type of restrictions on 6 internal flights in South Africa using 5 different airlines. In one instance my solution was to strap the 100-400 lens in its case to my belt, thus removing it and its weight from my carry-on. As it turned out not once was my bag weighed and the majority of passengers on all of the airlines had far larger carry-ons than I did. Lots of worry and concern for nothing.
Totally agree with this suggestion. No need for m... (show quote)


Yes, probably a lot of worrying for nothing. But, that is who I am, worrying is my nature and always has been. I never thought of strapping the big lend to my belt, keeping it safe. Hmmm. Not sure why I got negative reports of travel vests, I have been slowed down by people in the airport simply because they slowly do their thing. I have taken the vest off and put it on the conveyer belt and never have had a problem. I was patted down in the White House, but no big deal. I have TSA Precheck and Global Entry, and they help that scenario a lot.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 5 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.