Mariposa Coffee Company
Aug 27, 2017 08:46:23 #
If I post an image here, and request comments, I would expect 32% of the comments to say my pictures absolutely suck, Maybe half of those would tell me why the pictures suck and half of that group will offer suggestions to improve. Far too many comments complement the photographer even if the images are marginal or worse. Post a photo of an eagle and the accolades are automatic. If we are seeking that type of response to our photos, Facebook may provide a better forum. If we are serious about improving our photography, then - within this group - we are looking for the negative comments. We will never improve our photography based on positive comments.
Some attributes of photos depend on where they will be used.
I can see photo #1 above being very comfortable as a photographic illustration in a magazine article about coffee, but I am not sure I would hang it in my kitchen;
Photos 2,3, and 5 would look nice hanging in a kitchen or a coffee nook.
The texture of #1 would not interfere with the image and may actually enhance the image in the proper setting. I agree that the yellow and red on the cart is distracting and would probably crop the image just below the bottom of the pan.
Photo #2, I think I would drop the brightness of the bottle labels, I would feel more comfortable if they were approximately the brightness of the preprinted labels. - I like the vignette of this photo.
Photo #3 I would not change, and #5 I might remove what looks like a light artifact on the red striped coffee bag.
Photos #4 and#6 may be nice photos, but I felt no 2X4 in the forehead on either of these photos.
Over all, I think you did a very good job.
Some attributes of photos depend on where they will be used.
I can see photo #1 above being very comfortable as a photographic illustration in a magazine article about coffee, but I am not sure I would hang it in my kitchen;
Photos 2,3, and 5 would look nice hanging in a kitchen or a coffee nook.
The texture of #1 would not interfere with the image and may actually enhance the image in the proper setting. I agree that the yellow and red on the cart is distracting and would probably crop the image just below the bottom of the pan.
Photo #2, I think I would drop the brightness of the bottle labels, I would feel more comfortable if they were approximately the brightness of the preprinted labels. - I like the vignette of this photo.
Photo #3 I would not change, and #5 I might remove what looks like a light artifact on the red striped coffee bag.
Photos #4 and#6 may be nice photos, but I felt no 2X4 in the forehead on either of these photos.
Over all, I think you did a very good job.
Aug 27, 2017 08:48:46 #
markie1425 wrote:
Great images, especially the first one.
There will always be a division between purists who dislike post-processing and people like me who seek to make an image more interesting, regardless of its "reality".
You followed your muse, not the finger-wagging of the flat image reality crowd. Well played.
There will always be a division between purists who dislike post-processing and people like me who seek to make an image more interesting, regardless of its "reality".
You followed your muse, not the finger-wagging of the flat image reality crowd. Well played.
Markie, thank you very much! I knew this one would bring out the hounds... it's amazing how much alike these guys are; all talk and no show! And when you see their photos, few if any, you can see why they never post! It cracks me up!
Aug 27, 2017 08:50:35 #
fourg1b2006 wrote:
That looks like some operation. Nice set.
Thanks for commenting Marty! It's a great place for a great cup of coffee!
Aug 27, 2017 08:55:32 #
rlaugh wrote:
How neat...good job!!
Thanks Bob! Looks like I got another one on the hook!
Aug 27, 2017 09:04:43 #
rafikiphoto wrote:
Comments were invited. I didn't see berchman's comment about an unappealing filter as 'finger wagging' it was an opinion, as valid as anyone else's and quite helpful. As it happens I agree the filter makes the guy's skin look very unappealing and, if you look at much of my work, I'm definitely not a flat image reality type of person!
Brian, your not the type of critic I'm talking about.... you share your photos and good ones they are! I knew this photo would draw out the idiots who love to complain and would be better served critiquing their own photos!
They always offer up the negative and never the positive! I'm an armature point and shoot type of guy who loves playing with the software! I push as far as I can but never seek perfection!
Aug 27, 2017 09:06:08 #
I just realized that I need to post "comments welcome" on my pic entries. I appreciate all the constructive criticism - how else will I grow and learn? I think there is a fine line between "criticism" and "sniping" and I didn't see that here personally. I tend to look at all my pics as "fails" in some way lol but I also know that there might be some tender egos and you have to kind of look at who is posting and whether or not it is appropriate to comment - at least that is how I look at it. I don't feel knowledgeable enough to critique anyone here but hope enough people feel confident enough to critique me - I appreciate it!
Aug 27, 2017 09:08:24 #
dpullum wrote:
A group of photos that are tied to our addiction f... (show quote)
Thanks Don! Your comments are always welcomed my friend!
Aug 27, 2017 09:10:50 #
Aug 27, 2017 09:11:03 #
Snap Shot wrote:
Berchman, I knew someone would call this one out! And you are the typical type of person who does this! Never shows a photo on UHH, except for one time, and is quick to scorn at ever chance!
I could care less what you and those like you think! Get a life!
I could care less what you and those like you think! Get a life!
A totally uncalled for comment. Were you only asking for compliments?
Aug 27, 2017 09:15:37 #
deer2ker wrote:
Love these! Playing around with some effects myself and having fun. Love the subject matter too - been in that business far longer than holding a camera - need to try some pics like that myself. (would kill to find out where they got those glass jars!)
Deer2ker, thanks for taking a look! I fully agree having fun with effects is what it's all about! Always nice to see a new visitor!
Aug 27, 2017 09:16:08 #
deer2ker wrote:
Absolutely D - If anyone wants a truly wonderful coffee experience, make sure that you visit a local roaster and try the coffee- the coffee sitting in most coffee shops is "old" more than 3 weeks old (therefore the oily black residue you see in containers) Optimum coffee? 1 day to a week old - perfect!
Aug 27, 2017 09:24:18 #
deer2ker wrote:
I just realized that I need to post "comments... (show quote)
I've been on UHH for years and can handle and invite constructive criticism! It's the Snipers and Purists I can't stand!
Aug 27, 2017 09:28:28 #
A fun set, Bill! Coffee is good and it looks like they have it under control. ☕️
Aug 27, 2017 09:29:36 #
rafikiphoto wrote:
A totally uncalled for comment. Were you only asking for compliments?
Sorry you feel that way! But snipers and purists I detest with a passion! I've had a ton of constructive criticism that I welcome! His was not and the fact he only posted one photo should say it all!
Aug 27, 2017 09:31:29 #
Cwilson341 wrote:
A fun set, Bill! Coffee is good and it looks like they have it under control. ☕️
Thank you Carol! He does very well up here and world wide as well!
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.