SCChop wrote:
Almost always use spot focusing unless I'm shooting BIF, then it's the focusing grid that looks like 4 squares in a diamond pattern in the viewfinder. The only other lens I use is the Nikkor 16-85mm and 85mm macro. Both of them focus fast and no issues. As for the flower image, I took it with the 200-500mm because that's all I had with me that day. I didn't get the photo data on each when I downloaded--typically I shoot at a high shutter speed, with ISO compensating.
I downloaded all of your images and you are not exaggerating the problem. I cannot find a single point in any images that is tack sharp. The question then becomes is it the camera or the lens. I think you said that you do not have the problem with other lenses which would lead you to the lens. However, Nikon has a history of focusing problems with some of their cameras. When I bought my d800, they were having some problems with various areas in the focus screen. I seem to remember them having some problems with the d300. I have not experienced that problem, but I think you need to isolate the camera or the lens. I would suggest setting up a shot that you can take with your 16-85 and your 200-500, both hand held and tripod and compare the results. Try not to use the absolute low or high end of each lens. Use an ISO of 100-400 for both so you will need a well lit subject and the same shutter speed of say 1/500 sec. Crop the 16-85mm, but not the 200-500 and compare the results. Post them here. If there is significant difference is focus sharpness, I would submit that the lens need to be checked out by Nikon. If they are close, meaning that both appear not to be sharp, then chances are its the camera. From the images you provided, it does not appear to be camera shake. One of the other posters suggested optimizing your 200-500 with your camera. I agree that might help, but if the test shows a marked difference between the 16-85 and the 200-500 then it is probably the lens and you should go back to the seller and see if he would allow you to use another 200-500 and see if there is a difference. They you will know that it is the lens and can provide Nikon with the evidence. Nikon can be a little contrary some times, so be persistent.