Gene51 wrote:
Blackest, TN is not completely wrong in suggesting that you need to take into consideration the Fstop of the lens when making comparisons for "light gathering" between L and crop lenses, but not with regards to brightness at the sensor. For the most part it is safe to assume that placing an L lens set to F2.8 on a full frame camera, then remove the camera and place a crop sensor camera, the crop sensor will not see "less light" which would mean you'd have to adjust the fstop to change the amount of light hitting the sensor. But, if you want to make an overall comparison, taking into consideration the depth of field, then it would make sense if you are comparing lenses with equivalent angles of view. If you have a full frame camera fitted with a 150mm lens the angle of view is similar to a 1.5 crop camera fitted with a 100mm lens. But the 100mm lens being a shorter focal length, at the same distance (point of view), will have a greater depth of field. The 150mm at F4.2 would have a similar depth of field to the 100mm lens at F2.8. Obviously you would have to change the exposure value (increase either the ISO or the open shutter time) to make up for the smaller aperture.
TN and others try to wrap their non-technical heads around these concepts and need to make stuff up, and make dubious at best assumptions like this one where somehow DoF is somehow related to image quality, and that is somehow related to sensor size and light falling/not falling on a sensor somehow affecting the image quality. It's not that hard to figure this out, and even easier if you put away the slide rule for a moment (am I showing my age? did I really write slide rule?). I agree, with regards to light and sensor size, he is 100% wrong when he states that the cropped sensor lens is somehow better than the L lens. But his depth of field comparison does make sense but only for depth of field of two different lenses with equivalent fields of view.
Blackest, TN is not completely wrong in suggesting... (
show quote)
Yes if you have a 100mm lens giving the field of view of a 150mm lens if you don't change the aperture it will not look the same, i accept that.
Funny really the smaller the sensor it seems the better iq you want from your lens. Still the biggest issue in my case anyway is the photographer if that bits not working properly the camera iq hardly matters.