Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Black Rapid sling Straps and other simillar.. is it safe?
Page <<first <prev 3 of 5 next> last>>
Jun 3, 2012 11:52:04   #
kmohr3 Loc: Rockford, IL
 
Just wondering......

Has anyone here, with an SLR, ever had the tripod socket come loose in the camera? Or have the threads damaged or stripped, for any reason?

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 12:00:14   #
Mashubi1 Loc: Salem, Oregon
 
I have been using a Black Rapid on my Pentax K7 w/Grip and 540 Flash four about four or five years now and have nor had a problem with any mechanical issues. Having used the around the neck straps supplied by the manufacture for over 30 years I found the Black Rapid easier to work the camera, balance the camera in crowds as well as when positioning people for photos at weddings and other events. Another plus, the Black Rapid takes the weight off of your neck and distributes it evenly across your shoulder similar to a backpack strap. The strap also allows for you to carry 3-4 memory cards having quick access tto a zipper pouch in the strap making changing cards easier and faster while on the move. I sold....!!!

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 12:12:38   #
Mashubi1 Loc: Salem, Oregon
 
In response to Kmohr3... I have not had one come loose. As to the connection I have carried my camera fastened to the top of a tripod or monopod for years with no issues.

Reply
 
 
Jun 3, 2012 12:19:40   #
sbesaw Loc: Boston
 
TimS wrote:
Check out the BOS strap. I am happy with mine. It doesn't attach to the tripod mount - it attaches to the camera strap pin. I called canon to see if hanging the camera with a 70-200 2.8 from just one of the pins would be ok and the tech I spoke with said they have no concerns.


Agreed, Have a few Black Rapid and OpTech. Really like comfort and function of BOS Strap

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 12:29:36   #
Scoutman Loc: Orlando, FL
 
Mdw612 wrote:
I have no issue with my Black-Rapid strap! On the other hand I would not use it for a heavy lens, and I haven't had any issues banging cameras.


Many heavy lenses seem to have their own tripod collar, so then what are the issues. Would balance be ok? I suspect the strength of a tripod collar would exceed that of the camera body.

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 12:55:58   #
sbesaw Loc: Boston
 
Mashubi1 wrote:
In response to Kmohr3... I have not had one come loose. As to the connection I have carried my camera fastened to the top of a tripod or monopod for years with no issues.


Agreed, used BR strap for while with FX body and heavy lenses. No issue. The question here is not about tripod where the tripod supports the weight of the camera but rather if the thread insert on the bottom of the camera can support the hanging weight of the camera and lens without separating from the camera body. I have seen this conversation on various forums and always with the same comments. Manufacturers will never say it's designed to support hanging weight while at the same time I've never seen a comment where the thread insert has come loose.

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 13:14:16   #
AK Dreamer Loc: Alaska & Nevada
 
Karel wrote:
AK Dreamer
look into this, it my be just for your needs, no more neck strain....

http://buy.cottoncarrier.com/cotton-carrier-camera-system-p/124rtl-d.htm
Karel


Thanks for the info! I currently use a camera backpack which works but is just not as convenient when at sporting events.. I'll look into the carrier you mentioned.

Reply
 
 
Jun 3, 2012 13:15:53   #
Mashubi1 Loc: Salem, Oregon
 
I agree sbesaw.....!!!!

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 13:17:44   #
jeep_daddy Loc: Prescott AZ
 
Karel,

The longer lenses like the 70-200mm have a foot on them and the Black Rapid works fine attached to the foot of this heavier combination. I use the Black Rapid on my EF 500mm f4L IS lens with my 1.4x extender and the 7D body and it works fine. I use it on all my lenses with feet and on both bodies when I use lenses that are smaller with no foot. Probably the heaviest is the 24-70mm f2.8L that doesn't have a foot. It works fine on this too.

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 13:29:48   #
Sweet Willie Loc: Texas
 
Having spent the last 52 yrs. employed as a tool/die/mold maker I would have
no worries about a 1/4-20 thread failing, providing all parts are made to spec.
I would be concerned about the male member coming loose because you can't
get it very tight. Overtightened your fastener and you are inviting stripped threads. Murphy's Law: THREADS WILL STRIP IN THE MOST EXPENSIVE PART
That will be the camera, not the strap.
Sweet Willie

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 13:31:23   #
Mashubi1 Loc: Salem, Oregon
 
Jeep Daddy...I have a Sigma 24-70 DG HSM without a foot that is pretty heavy without a lens foot where everything is hanging from the tripod mount when using the Black Rapid with no issues....

Reply
 
 
Jun 3, 2012 14:35:49   #
mtnredhed Loc: The part of NorCal that doesn't move
 
Oddly enough I use BOTH an Optech and a Blackrapid. The Blackrapid is nice for studio use, but I don't like it for field use, where as the opposite is true for the field. Seems like the Blackrapid hangs the camera too close to things that want to hit it.

this is for a 20D and a 7D.

My feeling is that if a camera (or lens) can't be held upside down by it's tripod socket, you bought the wrong one.

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 15:14:50   #
Mickey Oberman Loc: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
 
If you have to climb a long row of stairs or a stepladder or steep rock face or ride a bicycle or tie your shoe lace or pick up a fair maiden's lace handkerchief what do you do?

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 15:20:25   #
RichardSM Loc: Back in Texas
 
Hello Karel

I use the Black Rapid R7 sling and like very very much I hike with it mountains hear in So. Calif and have no problems or damage to my Canon 7D its a great product.


Karel wrote:
I was considering buy this kind of camera strap and after some reaserch i find this article
Karel
Interesting article about Camera Sling straps

Question to Canon.
There is an inquiry request for : EOS (SLR) Camera Systems , EOS
Digital SLR Cameras, EOS 7D
User Question : Hello, I recently purchased a shoulder strap for my 7D.
It is the type which can have a 1/4-20 stainless screw attached to it
... which can thread into the 1/4-20 thread on the bottom of the camera.
My concern is not the Stainless Steel screw..., but the solidness of the
thread insert in the camera itself, which (I believe) was primarily designed
to hold a camera, right side up, on top of a tripod. Is the screw insert solid
enough and secure enough inside the camera body so that it won't pull
out when the camera (and lens /70-200mm)is hanging upside down at my
hip as I walk around with it. Is there a maximum pull load rating on the
screw insert? Or,if you could confirm that it is more than solid enough
to handle all your pro DSLR's (hanging upside down with a 70-200mm
lens) it would prompt me to carry it upside down near my hip with the
shoulder strap. Thank you in advance for all your help. Sincerely. XXX

Response from Canon Technical Support

Dear xxx
Thank you for your inquiry. We value you as a Canon customer and
appreciate the opportunity to assist you. With regards to this
accessory there is no guarantee from Canon that it will properly hold
the camera in the position you mention.
Your notions regarding the 1/4" 20 thread on the bottom are correct,
this is for connection to a tripod for holding the camera right side up.
In this regard it is very strong and should have no problem holding the
camera. There is no published maximum load for this mount though and
for this reason I can't guarantee the cameras safety when mounted with
such a heavy lens being held down on your hip. The mount wasn't really
designed for this and damage may occur if this were to fall in this
position. We apologize for any inconvenience that this may cause you at
this time.
I hope this information is helpful to you. Please let us know if we can
be of any further assistance with your EOS 7D.
Thank you for choosing Canon.
Sincerely,
Technical Support Representative

Here is the response to same question from Nikon

Nikons response
"HI
Thanks for the question and sorry for the delay in responding.
The camera tripod mount is designed to support the weight of the
camera and lens but is not designed for potential shocks that this sort of
strap [using the tripod socket] may impart on it. In normal usage of this
sort of strap (sliding the camera up or down) it should be fine but we
would not recommend swinging or dropping the camera and having the
strap catch it. We don't publish any particular test data, though....
-David"
New Information (July 19, 2011):
At the recent New England Camera Club Council Conference in Amherst,
MA, Nikon staff were asked about attaching a sling style strap to the tripod socket.
We were told that the tripod socket is not designed to hang the
weight of a camera from it, and there would be serious concerns about the internal camera seals being loaded in a way they were not designed for.
I was considering buy this kind of camera strap an... (show quote)

Reply
Jun 3, 2012 15:22:30   #
BigD Loc: The LEFT Coast
 
You work it out. Stairs, ladders and things like that are no problem the cameras just sit there. If you have to bend over you turn to the side a bit so the camera does not swing forward. If your wearing two cameras you turn to keep one from swinging and use your hand or arm to stop the other one.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 3 of 5 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.