LennyP4868 wrote:
they are all nice but I think #5 stands out because you have the grass in the front which leads you into the leading line which brings to to the back and the sky. The sky has drama and the reflection is a plus. Nice job
Thanks for the detailed answer, good to know the why! Appreciate your looking.
Photolady2014 wrote:
Would love your opinion on which is most appealing to your eye.
Thanks! Beth
Nice shots Beth. I like #6 above all the rest. The composition is somewhat similar to #5 but the white clouds in #5 draw your eyes up and away from the lake. Your eyes will always be drawn to the brightest part of a picture. Number 6 also has great DOF. How big of a print are you planning to make and on what kind of surface will it be printed?
Photolady2014 wrote:
Would love your opinion on which is most appealing to your eye.
Thanks! Beth
I like the first one the most, the rich blue sky contrasting with the yellow leaves.
I like them all but 5 seems to stand out :D
I can't pick just one, I like 4 & 5 ;)
Photolady2014 wrote:
Would love your opinion on which is most appealing to your eye.
Thanks! Beth
I like the color best (especially the yellows and blues) in #2 but the composition best in #3.
Chet
Loc: Louisville, KY
#5 grabs my attention, but all are very good. :thumbup: :thumbup:
Photolady2014 wrote:
Would love your opinion on which is most appealing to your eye.
Thanks! Beth
They're all nice but I prefer #5 probably because of the foreground.
#5 then #1 for me... All have good elements depending on your intended use.
3 and 4 are grand slamm homeruns!!
FramerMCB
Loc: Northern, ID (formerly Portland, OR area)
All are very nice shots! But for my personal taste, in this order: #5, #4, then #1. The others shake out like this probably: #6, #2, then #3.
It's nice to have a foreground element to start the eye then a sweeping vista to draw you in... The pano framing while beautiful, with nice composition seem just a wee bit pinched/cramped for the scene/scenery (just my 2-cents here). Still, what a wonderful scene and "problem" to have...
Thanks for sharing these!
All are nice but really like the last one.
They are all very nice. Perhaps eye of the beholder but #5 tells a bigger story.
Normally, I like to enhance the color and this is strictly my opinion, but most of the photographs seem a bit "overcooked" - to much saturation.
Not way overdone, but I think they would (to my eye) look a bit better if the saturation were backed off a bit.
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.