tomfr wrote:
I will, no longer, pay to read ads. Has anyone ever read a review, in any of the photography magazines, that was real critical? Is it a coincidence that a big spread, ad wise, often appears in the same edition as a review.There is more ad space, than real content.
tomfr
Sort of, but not exactly. The ad is sold after the review. You're right that critical reviews seldom appear, but this is not just to keep the advertisers sweet: you'd be amazed at how many readers whine and howl if there's the faintest criticism of something they've bought (or even want) because it impugns their judgement.
There have been times, to be sure, when I have returned a product without reviewing it, saying something like, "I do not think I can review this favourably, because..." A list of faults/problems then follows. In other words, if you see a good review that I've written, it's sincere, and I try to point up the faults as well as the advantages of a product.
It's also true that something I'd not touch with a ten-foot pole, someone else will love, so it's worth bearing that in mind too.
R.