Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Color Space Choice Nikon D7000 & D800
Apr 3, 2013 21:52:07   #
wsa111 Loc: Goose Creek, South Carolina
 
You have two choices sRGB & Adobe RGB.
The manual says the Adobe RGB has a wider range of colors than the sRGB.
I have an epson printer which will handle the Adobe choice, but a local photo shop says they can get better results with the sRGB selection???
Need help on the correct choice.

Reply
Apr 3, 2013 21:57:39   #
Photographer Jim Loc: Rio Vista, CA
 
wsa111 wrote:
You have two choices sRGB & Adobe RGB.
The manual says the Adobe RGB has a wider range of colors than the sRGB.
I have an epson printer which will handle the Adobe choice, but a local photo shop says they can get better results with the sRGB selection???
Need help on the correct choice.


I'd go with the Adobe RGB. You can print it, so go with the larger color gamut. You can always assign sRGB and adjust for out of gamut color if you need to send images out to a lab that requires it.

Reply
Apr 3, 2013 22:11:23   #
jeep_daddy Loc: Prescott AZ
 
wsa111 wrote:
You have two choices sRGB & Adobe RGB.
The manual says the Adobe RGB has a wider range of colors than the sRGB.
I have an epson printer which will handle the Adobe choice, but a local photo shop says they can get better results with the sRGB selection???
Need help on the correct choice.


Shoot in AdobeRGB and if you take your images to a lab for printing you can convert to sRGB.

Reply
 
 
Apr 3, 2013 23:38:04   #
charles brown Loc: Tennesse
 
I too have an epson printer and do all my shooting using Adobe RGB. Have the printer calibrated for RGB (I think - not always sure what I have done). It is my understanding that most pros use Adobe RGB, but yet the magazines want their submissions in sRGB, at least that is what I have been told. Always puzzled me as to why this is. Just another mystery of life, I guess.

Reply
Apr 4, 2013 00:25:10   #
Photographer Jim Loc: Rio Vista, CA
 
charles brown wrote:
I too have an epson printer and do all my shooting using Adobe RGB. Have the printer calibrated for RGB (I think - not always sure what I have done). It is my understanding that most pros use Adobe RGB, but yet the magazines want their submissions in sRGB, at least that is what I have been told. Always puzzled me as to why this is. Just another mystery of life, I guess.


Most desktop inkjet printers, and many wide format inkjet printers, are optimized to print the aRGB color space. If you are a pro who uses such a printer to make your own prints, shooting in aRGB is to your advantage. Most labs and commercial printers that use light to expose photo paper are meant to use sRGB. Because Adobe RGB gamut is larger, the sRGB machine will take the "out of gamut" colors and substitute a color that fits within the sRGB space. That often results in the final image reproducing with "flattened" color. So, it is generally better to send labs a file already in sRGB. Internet publishing also requires sRGB files for best display.

I'm puzzled by the comment that most magazines want sRGB files. Magazines use mechanical printers which require converting to CMYK. My understanding is that it is better to convert to CMYK from Adobe RGB, but not being in the publishing business that may be my error.

Reply
Apr 4, 2013 08:19:26   #
jerryc41 Loc: Catskill Mts of NY
 
wsa111 wrote:
You have two choices sRGB & Adobe RGB.
The manual says the Adobe RGB has a wider range of colors than the sRGB.
I have an epson printer which will handle the Adobe choice, but a local photo shop says they can get better results with the sRGB selection???
Need help on the correct choice.

This was covered in a class on the D600 from CreativeLive I saw yesterday. Unfortunately, since I had also bought the video, I wasn't paying much attention to it. From what I recall, the guy said you can use sRGB for most shooting, but if you're...???, then use RGB. He added that there is so little difference that it would be hard to tell them apart.

From page 274 of the D800 manual, :The color space determines the gamut of colors available for color
reproduction. Choose sRGB for photographs that will be printed
or used “as is,” with no further modification. Adobe RGB has a
wider color gamut and is recommended for images that will be
extensively processed or retouched after leaving the camera."

I have no personal experience with this. Just passing along some info.

Reply
Apr 4, 2013 09:31:29   #
warrior Loc: Paso Robles CA
 
jerryc41 wrote:
This was covered in a class on the D600 from CreativeLive I saw yesterday. Unfortunately, since I had also bought the video, I wasn't paying much attention to it. From what I recall, the guy said you can use sRGB for most shooting, but if you're...???, then use RGB. He added that there is so little difference that it would be hard to tell them apart.

From page 274 of the D800 manual, :The color space determines the gamut of colors available for color
reproduction. Choose sRGB for photographs that will be printed
or used “as is,” with no further modification. Adobe RGB has a
wider color gamut and is recommended for images that will be
extensively processed or retouched after leaving the camera."

I have no personal experience with this. Just passing along some info.
This was covered in a class on the D600 from Creat... (show quote)


The videos are up and running 0631 hrs. Pacific

Reply
 
 
Apr 4, 2013 09:37:46   #
jerryc41 Loc: Catskill Mts of NY
 
warrior wrote:
The videos are up and running 0631 hrs. Pacific

This link shows it starting at 9:00 AM Pacific Time. Or maybe that's when it was broadcast originally.

http://www.creativelive.com/courses/nikon-d600-dslr-fast-start-john-greengo

Reply
Apr 4, 2013 12:11:11   #
rollop Loc: little rock, arkansas
 
wsa111 wrote:
You have two choices sRGB & Adobe RGB.
The manual says the Adobe RGB has a wider range of colors than the sRGB.
I have an epson printer which will handle the Adobe choice, but a local photo shop says they can get better results with the sRGB selection???
Need help on the correct choice.


Jeff Revell has a section in his book on the D800, it's on page 13. He states that sRGB was developed by Hewlett-Packard and Microsoft to define colors for the internet and it has something to do with the way computer monitors display images using red,green and blue (RGB), since there are no black pixels in a monitor, sRGB uses these three colors to display all the colors of an image.
Adobe RGB was developed in 1998 as a way to enable a wider range of colors by using cyan,magenta,yellow and black (CMYK) to intepret the primary colors: red, green and blue. This produces better looking prints because of the wider color palette.

Reply
Apr 4, 2013 14:47:55   #
Weaselsplace Loc: Ider, AL
 
Jerryc41, Do you think the video is worth $49?

Reply
Apr 4, 2013 15:15:08   #
jerryc41 Loc: Catskill Mts of NY
 
Weaselsplace wrote:
Jerryc41, Do you think the video is worth $49?

If I hadn't bought it for $29, I would have paid $49. It's roughly five hours of detailed instruction on the D600. In the beginning, he spends a few minutes on photography and camera use in general, but it's loaded with D600 info. In addition, you get seven pages of PDF info about settings -charts, etc.

For me, $49 would be worth it. You download it in seven sections, so you have it immediately, and you can save it to a DVD and use it on other computers.

Go to their site and see if John Greengro is doing other classes. If so, you can watch for free while they are on and decide if that type of presentation is what you want.

http://johngreengo.com/

Reply
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.