Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
792 CREDIT SCORE REJECTED BY PAYBOO
Page <<first <prev 6 of 6
Apr 12, 2023 11:43:45   #
bobforman Loc: Anacortes, Washington State
 
That's something I haven't thought about. I live in Washington where the sales tax is approaching 10%. Payboo could be black-lining people in states that have these high rates, otherwise they'd be taking a big hit on each sale.

Reply
Apr 12, 2023 16:06:13   #
billnikon Loc: Pennsylvania/Ohio/Florida/Maui/Oregon/Vermont
 
Bill_de wrote:
B&H needs to take on some responsibility. They promote the card right on the first page when you go to their site. They are enticing /steering customers to an apparently bad player. B&H has an excellent, well deserved, reputation. They should be more careful who they jump into bed with.

Looking back, B&H grew their business by attracting customers who wanted to avoid their own states sales tax. If those same folks had to pay that tax today they just might decide to shop at home. B&H provides great service, but $$$ speak loud.

---
B&H needs to take on some responsibility. They... (show quote)


I truly believe that folks are putting in incorrect information on their application, not a deliberate act, but an accidental one. The computer program kicks them out for a minor thing they did not fill out properly.
It happened to me and many others on this site, and they, like me, called the bank and together we figured it out, the bank went over my information and we found where I made a mistake, the individual I talked to said everything was now OK and I got my card withing two weeks.
All I am saying is that the OP could have done the same thing that a lot of us did.
Not allowing folks from certain states to get a card is counter productive on the part of B&H. I believe they want customers to use the card, it means more business for them. If they exclude states they would be missing out on a lot of business. I do not believe B&H would want that.

Reply
Apr 12, 2023 16:08:19   #
billnikon Loc: Pennsylvania/Ohio/Florida/Maui/Oregon/Vermont
 
bobforman wrote:
That's something I haven't thought about. I live in Washington where the sales tax is approaching 10%. Payboo could be black-lining people in states that have these high rates, otherwise they'd be taking a big hit on each sale.


Not allowing folks from certain states to get a card is counter productive on the part of B&H. I believe they want customers to use the card, it means more business for them. If they exclude states they would be missing out on a lot of business. I do not believe B&H would want that.
Trust me, I was in retail, B&H is making enough on products that even with a 10% reduction they are making good money.

Reply
 
 
Apr 12, 2023 16:08:27   #
MrPhotog
 
Robertl594 wrote:

. . .
Just out of curiosity, what are the benefits of a B&H Payboo credit card? . . .


You either get a discount equal to the sales tax ( about 7%) , or low monthly interest over a year.

If you are financing a large equipment purchase then the low monthly payments will have a lower interest rate than most bank loans, and not tie up any existing lines of credit your company might have.

If you are buying equipment which is normally not discounted anywhere, they are in effect giving you a 7% discount off the item’s price. If you pay off the purchase in full inside a month ( roughly) you’ll have a considerable savings.

For example:
Try buying a $9000 Leica anywhere in the US and the price will be $9000 plus tax. Through B&H and payboo you pay an even $9000. They pay the $630 to NY out of their markup, and still make a profit without advertising a discounted price. I save that amount because I’m not charged sales tax. Actually, I save more ($855) than buying locally, because sales tax in my state is 9.5%, and the shipping is fast and free.

You are not really eliminating the tax. The state still gets its cut. But, by phrasing the purchase details in this manner, It may be the only way to save on buying Leica and other equipment from manufacturers who control the retail prices.

Reply
Apr 12, 2023 19:00:39   #
larryepage Loc: North Texas area
 
MrPhotog wrote:
You either get a discount equal to the sales tax ( about 7%) , or low monthly interest over a year.

If you are financing a large equipment purchase then the low monthly payments will have a lower interest rate than most bank loans, and not tie up any existing lines of credit your company might have.

If you are buying equipment which is normally not discounted anywhere, they are in effect giving you a 7% discount off the item’s price. If you pay off the purchase in full inside a month ( roughly) you’ll have a considerable savings.

For example:
Try buying a $9000 Leica anywhere in the US and the price will be $9000 plus tax. Through B&H and payboo you pay an even $9000. They pay the $630 to NY out of their markup, and still make a profit without advertising a discounted price. I save that amount because I’m not charged sales tax. Actually, I save more ($855) than buying locally, because sales tax in my state is 9.5%, and the shipping is fast and free.

You are not really eliminating the tax. The state still gets its cut. But, by phrasing the purchase details in this manner, It may be the only way to save on buying Leica and other equipment from manufacturers who control the retail prices.
You either get a discount equal to the sales tax (... (show quote)


I don't believe it works this way at all, at least not completely. The retailer gets the full amount of the sale as invoiced (including the tax), and the retailer will submit the tax to the state, as required. The difference is absorbed by the credit card issuer as promotional or immediate "cash back" to the buyer. The refunds are funded by the exorbitant 30% interest charged on unpaid balances. That's 2.5% of each monthly unpaid balance. So anything not paid off within about three months gives the issuer his money back, and everything after that is profit. Major purchases probably maintain a balance for several months (or even years), so it's really good money for the bank issuing the card. The retailer remits the sales tax as required and shows invoices to the seller showing that he sold undiscounted product to the customer. All gains or losses accrue to the card company.

It is certainly possible that the agreement calls for the retailer to receive what I'd call royalties on the actual realized profits, but that would be a separate transaction down the road.

Bottom line...there is no way that this can be a good deal for both the buyer and the seller. It's more like gambling. The buyer is betting that he is going to pay off the purchase. The card company is betting that he won't. If there are too many buyer wins, the house will change the game.

Reply
Apr 13, 2023 05:17:53   #
BebuLamar
 
larryepage wrote:
I don't believe it works this way at all, at least not completely. The retailer gets the full amount of the sale as invoiced (including the tax), and the retailer will submit the tax to the state, as required. The difference is absorbed by the credit card issuer as promotional or immediate "cash back" to the buyer. The refunds are funded by the exorbitant 30% interest charged on unpaid balances. That's 2.5% of each monthly unpaid balance. So anything not paid off within about three months gives the issuer his money back, and everything after that is profit. Major purchases probably maintain a balance for several months (or even years), so it's really good money for the bank issuing the card. The retailer remits the sales tax as required and shows invoices to the seller showing that he sold undiscounted product to the customer. All gains or losses accrue to the card company.

It is certainly possible that the agreement calls for the retailer to receive what I'd call royalties on the actual realized profits, but that would be a separate transaction down the road.

Bottom line...there is no way that this can be a good deal for both the buyer and the seller. It's more like gambling. The buyer is betting that he is going to pay off the purchase. The card company is betting that he won't. If there are too many buyer wins, the house will change the game.
I don't believe it works this way at all, at least... (show quote)


And if they bet that way they won't bet on customers with history of paying off their credit card every month and those are the ones with high credit score.

Reply
Oct 12, 2023 00:35:46   #
Parfumeur Loc: Forest Hills, NY USA
 
> they also think that you will pay off the balance before the grace period is over and thus they will not make any money on you.

I too got rejected by Comenity. I previously had the Synchrony PayBoo card since July 2019, and turned on the monthly auto pay in full. My credit score is 811.

Comenity has to know this from my previous PayBoo card. Comenity has 29% revolving interest and a $41 fee if you miss a payment. The rejection is obvious. I now have a new vendor that gives me a discount for immediate check payment of about 5%.

Reply
 
 
Oct 12, 2023 01:03:33   #
Parfumeur Loc: Forest Hills, NY USA
 
$85 saved = ~17 gallons = ~408 miles. In order to save or have $85 in my pocket, I need to make $125 before taxes.

Reply
Oct 12, 2023 01:16:59   #
Parfumeur Loc: Forest Hills, NY USA
 
@billnikon

Methinks you live in a bubble. Check "Comenity class action", see just one of the actions:

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/attention-comenity-card-holders-labaton-120000496.html?guccounter=1

There is money to be made by selling and sharing information, and no recourse when they get hacked. It's a one way street. Comenity wanted after the rejection, the following: [1] Front & back of driver's license, [2] Front & back of social security card, [3] Current bank statement or 1099 form!?

FWIW, Comenity is part of Bread Financial. I'll let you check their founding & original state. It's not OH.

Reply
Oct 12, 2023 12:09:40   #
aphelps Loc: Central Ohio
 
geagle1313 wrote:
The letter I received, states the following:
"Based on information provided during our recent communication, we are unable to approve your application for a B&H Payboo Credit Card for the following reason(s):"

"We were unable to verify your identity" This is totally absurd! The first sentence of the following paragraph states, "Our credit decision was based in whole or in part on information obtained in a report from the consumer reporting agency (EQUIFAX) listed below". The rest of the paragraph goes on to state, "under the Fair Credit Reporting Act", I have the right to know the information contained in my Equifax credit file. It further goes on to state, "that the reporting agency, (EQUIFAX) played NO part in our decision and is unable to supply specific reasons why we have denied credit to you". WHAT???? If the credit agency played no part in your decision, WHAT DID YOU BASE YOUR DECISION ON?? I find this reason contradictory and totally ABSURD!!

It further states, I have a right to a free copy of my (EQUIFAX) credit report if I request it no later than 60 days after this notice and if I find any information in the report to be inaccurate or incomplete I have the right to dispute the matter with (EQUIFAX) the reporting agency. Again, If the credit agency played no part in your decision, WHAT DID YOU BASE YOUR DECISION ON?? They, Comenity Bank fails to ever state a (specific) reason for the rejection. I find both (1) that no reason is offered for this decision and (2) that they were unable to verify my identity, simply OUTRAGEOUS! This clearly doesn't bode well for B&H and their partnership with this very questionable bank.
The letter I received, states the following: br &q... (show quote)


It took me 5 months of back and forth with Community Bank. It turns out that you have to wait 30 days to reapply. If you reply within the 30 day period you get rejected again and the 30 day blackout begins again. This could go on FOREVER unless the cycle is broken. Community seems to be out of control.

Reply
Oct 12, 2023 12:29:35   #
Parfumeur Loc: Forest Hills, NY USA
 
> Community seems to be out of control

No, no, THAT is 'the' problem. Comenity is in control. There is no oversight. They are the wolf, we are the sheep.

Reply
 
 
Oct 13, 2023 11:55:07   #
Finn Man Loc: wisconsin
 
I would advise all to stay away from banks. Credit Unions are the way to go. I know nothing about Payboo. It just might be a scam to get your information. The other thing I don't understand is all the in fighting and name calling. I thought this was a forum on photography...K.A.N.

Reply
Oct 13, 2023 14:04:46   #
niteman3d Loc: South Central Pennsylvania, USA
 
Finn Man wrote:
I would advise all to stay away from banks. Credit Unions are the way to go. I know nothing about Payboo. It just might be a scam to get your information. The other thing I don't understand is all the in fighting and name calling. I thought this was a forum on photography...K.A.N.


You might find it enlightening to enter the term "credit union hacked" into your favorite search engine... and yes, this is a photography forum, but the section you're in now is called "General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)". I know only this for certain thus far, I put a purchase on my Payboo card and immediately save an amount equal to my state's sales tax on any B&H purchase. Most purchases ship free (I plan my purchase so that I spend enough to get free shipping). After about a week I pay off my Payboo balance. It works.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 6 of 6
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.