MDI Mainer wrote:
"I'm ready to ditch Photoshop and Lightroom."
Glad the OP's issue got resolved, but it was raised under a ridiculously poor and piqued title, and could only be actually identified after some "cross examination," which was the point of my comment. But I am happy to see the UHH community look behind the title and be so patient and caring.
Every one has strengths and weaknesses. Some weaknesses are not being able to explain things, as in this case. I'm sure you have a weakness, or maybe more than one. The cross examination got his problem fixed and he might even have learned something.