Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
Automotive Electrics Question
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
Feb 25, 2022 08:10:50   #
aphelps Loc: Central Ohio
 
TriX wrote:
Right answer.


Never replace a smaller fuse with a larger one. You could have a wiring fire if the downstream wires (designed for 15 A max) are subjected to currents of 20 to 30 A.

Reply
Feb 25, 2022 08:39:44   #
agillot
 
It all depend of the size / diameter of the pre fuse wires . It may be safer to go to the battery , if you are going to connect a device that use a certain amount of power .Basically , dont melt the car fuse box .

Reply
Feb 25, 2022 08:58:40   #
Longshadow Loc: Audubon, PA, United States
 
Najataagihe wrote:
Actually, the other fuse will blow, too, because the load will be more than 15 amps and will try to draw all of it from that second circuit.

Also, don’t EVER replace a 15 amp fuse with a 30 amp fuse!

Those fuses are rated for the WIRE, not the LOAD.


?? The 20 amps, for example, will be split between the two fuses in parallel, ≈10amps each. Either 15 amp fuse will not blow until the total draw is over 30 amps, being over 15 for each leg, then the second will blow because it cannot handle the load alone.

While SO true about never replacing a smaller fuse with a larger one, the question asked was for a NEW circuit.

Reply
 
 
Feb 25, 2022 09:00:39   #
Sirsnapalot Loc: Hammond, Louisiana
 
Najataagihe wrote:
Actually, the other fuse will blow, too, because the load will be more than 15 amps and will try to draw all of it from that second circuit.

Also, don’t EVER replace a 15 amp fuse with a 30 amp fuse!

Those fuses are rated for the WIRE, not the LOAD.



Reply
Feb 25, 2022 09:11:46   #
Longshadow Loc: Audubon, PA, United States
 
Najataagihe wrote:
...
...

Those fuses are rated for the WIRE, not the LOAD.


Last I knew fuse ratings were selected for the load.
But hey, I'm just an electronics engineer.

Reply
Feb 25, 2022 09:58:10   #
n4jee Loc: New Bern, NC
 
If you are installing something that could draw 30 amps run minimum of 10 gauge wire (8 would be better) directly from the battery. Put a fuse in both the positive and negative leads. This is how I wired my 100 watt ham radio transceiver in my truck.

Reply
Feb 25, 2022 09:58:19   #
TriX Loc: Raleigh, NC
 
Longshadow wrote:
Last I knew fuse ratings were selected for the load.
But hey, I'm just an electronics engineer.


I think the some of the disagreement here is based on understanding of the proposed change and some on the background of the person answering. An electronic engineer or an electrical engineer working in electronics thanks of fuses as protecting the load device, and of course, he’s correct, while an electrician is thinking of the National electrical Code and house wiring where the breaker or fuse is designed primarily to protect the wire feeding the load from overheating from too heavy a load or a direct short. It may also protect the load from over current, but that’s not the primary reason for it’s existence. The load in a home may or may not be separately fused to protect the device.

As far is paralleling the fuses or changing the size, my assumption was that a new wire would be run from the fuse block to the load, so no worries there. and yes, you could parallel two 15 amp fuses although I’ve never done it. The fuse is just a piece of metal (with a specific resistance) that heats and finally melts somewhere close to its rating. Think of it as paralleling resistors. Both see the same voltage, and since they are both the same, or nearly the same resistance, both see the same current and the same power dissipated. And since each fuse sees 1/2 the current and dissipates 1/2 half the power, each shares half of the 30A load.

And while changing to a larger fuse in most cases is verboten - the wire in a house would no longer be properly protected and if it were a fused device, the device could draw too much current and perhaps be damaged before the fuse blows. But here, assuming new wire to the load, neither of those things are true, and the fuse block in a modern car is supplied with enough amperage for it not to be an issue. But, fuse blocks may be protected with a fusible link upstream, so you might exceed that capacity, and of course if the alternator output is marginal, tha5 could be an issue, but in general, in this case no worries.

Net-net Longshadow is correct assuming a new wire (or wires) is run to the load.

Reply
 
 
Feb 25, 2022 10:07:28   #
jerryc41 Loc: Catskill Mts of NY
 
Just to add a comment. I added two fuse panels to my car. One runs directly off the battery, and the other is connected to the car's fuse panel. I have switches to turn the always-on circuits on and off. They power two or three 12v outlets. The on-with-car-power panel powers the dash cams, GPS, and a string of LED lights. No accessories are tapped into the car's wiring.

Reply
Feb 25, 2022 10:09:28   #
Longshadow Loc: Audubon, PA, United States
 
TriX wrote:
I think the some of the disagreement here is based on understanding of the proposed change and some on the background of the person answering. An electronic engineer or an electrical engineer working in electronics thanks of fuses as protecting the load device, and of course, he’s correct, while an electrician is thinking of the National electrical Code and house wiring where the breaker or fuse is designed primarily to protect the wire feeding the load from overheating from too heavy a load or a direct short. It may also protect the load from over current, but that’s not the primary reason for it’s existence. The load in a home may or may not be separately fused to protect the device.

As far is paralleling the fuses or changing the size, my assumption was that a new wire would be run from the fuse block to the load, so no worries there. and yes, you could parallel two 15 amp fuses although I’ve never done it. The fuse is just a piece of metal (with a specific resistance) that heats and finally melts somewhere close to its rating. Think of it as paralleling resistors. Both see the same voltage, and since they are both the same, or nearly the same resistance, both see the same current and the same power dissipated. And since each fuse sees 1/2 the current and dissipates 1/2 half the power, each shares half of the 30A load.

Net-net Longshadow is correct assuming a new wire (or wires) is run to the load.
I think the some of the disagreement here is based... (show quote)


I believe his question did say theoretically and reference unused fuse locations, implying no existing wire(s).
And yes, one would have to use wire of a sufficient gauge to accommodate the load.

Reply
Feb 25, 2022 10:28:00   #
fetzler Loc: North West PA
 
jerryc41 wrote:
This is strictly theoretical, having popped into my mind a couple of days ago.

If you want to add an electrical accessory to your car, you can connect it into an empty space in the fuse box. If there are no empty spaces, you can use one of those adapter wires, although that has two things running off the same fuse. Here's the question. Let's say I have two empty spaces in my car's fuse box. I connect the device to one empty 15 amp space. Then I run a wire from another unused 15 amp space and tie that wire into the power for the device. Does that mean the device has 30 amps of protection? That would seem to be the case, but I suspect I'm missing something.
This is strictly theoretical, having popped into m... (show quote)


You like playing with fire. Remember the wires themselves are rated up to a certain current. Drawing too much current though a too small wire can cause a fire. If you have an unused fuse space then you can use the slot up to its rated current. If there are two things that WILL NOT AND CANNOT be used at the same time you can double up. Many car accessories are very low current. Lighter plugs are usually good to 10 amps.

Reply
Feb 25, 2022 10:31:44   #
TriX Loc: Raleigh, NC
 
n4jee wrote:
If you are installing something that could draw 30 amps run minimum of 10 gauge wire (8 would be better) directly from the battery. Put a fuse in both the positive and negative leads. This is how I wired my 100 watt ham radio transceiver in my truck.


It’s exactly how my VHF transceiver in my car is wired as well - good practice.

73
DE K4CKB

Reply
 
 
Feb 25, 2022 10:44:09   #
JBRIII
 
Longshadow wrote:
This will happen if the fuses are in series.

If the fuses are in parallel, theoretically you can have 30 amps, 15 through each fuse.
The current splits between each fuse in parallel. But they probably won't be precisely equal.
(Provided each fuse can actually handle 15 amps.)

From your description, I'm inferring that you mean in parallel.


Agree, I actually did this to solve USB power issues with a telescope. This is also how dummy batteries running on USB power work, at least for Canon cameras, they come with a Y cable, two inputs to battery. Of course final combined output line needs to be able to handle the amperage.

Reply
Feb 25, 2022 20:46:48   #
Toby
 
Najataagihe wrote:
Actually, the other fuse will blow, too, because the load will be more than 15 amps and will try to draw all of it from that second circuit.

Also, don’t EVER replace a 15 amp fuse with a 30 amp fuse!

Those fuses are rated for the WIRE, not the LOAD.


Exactly right. Look at your house. The fuse size is determined by the wire gauge in the wall. The fuse is to shut off the power if the load is so great that it could burn the house wires.

Reply
Feb 25, 2022 20:56:03   #
rbourque2 Loc: Portland, Maine
 
Najataagihe wrote:
Actually, the other fuse will blow, too, because the load will be more than 15 amps and will try to draw all of it from that second circuit.

Also, don’t EVER replace a 15 amp fuse with a 30 amp fuse!

Those fuses are rated for the WIRE, not the LOAD.


I totally agree with Najataagihe as a fuse is in line to protect the wire and not the equipment tied on to the wire. To use a 30 amp fuse you would have to upsize the wire to the proper wire gauge.

Reply
Feb 25, 2022 21:19:33   #
Longshadow Loc: Audubon, PA, United States
 
rbourque2 wrote:
I totally agree with Najataagihe as a fuse is in line to protect the wire and not the equipment tied on to the wire. To use a 30 amp fuse you would have to upsize the wire to the proper wire gauge.

In a house because they don't know what will be plugged into it, so they set a general limit to 15 amps for general receptacles, usually 20 amps for kitchen. Normal runs for 15 amp breakers is usually 14 gauge wire in a house. if they need to run it a long distance they will use 12 gauge (to reduce the IR drop for heavy loads over the distance), but still a 15 amp breaker. Wire is selected to provide the required power with a zero or negligible IR drop for the projected devices.

Car accessory fuses are similar, but the total of the items (usually more than one) that are connected to the line. Fused (and wired for the summation of all device requirements. The A/C fuse for example is rated for the A/C system load. The A/C is usually the only thing on that fuse. There is a method to their madness, not a general "covers all" method.
It depends on what/how many items are being fed and their load ratings as to what wire and fuses are utilized.

Beware armchair electrical engineers. Yes, they do have opinions.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 3 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
General Chit-Chat (non-photography talk)
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.