Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Tripod Recommended
Page <<first <prev 6 of 8 next> last>>
Feb 21, 2022 14:43:04   #
tgreenhaw
 
Gene51 wrote:
Pure nonsense. Load capacity has very little to do with stability unless you are comparing different tripods by the same manufacturer - stability does involve bulking things up, which usually adds some weight. But as I wrote earlier my 15.6 lb Bogen aluminum couldn't touch my 5.5 lb Feisol carbon, especially with long and very long lenses and heavy loads. Nearly every tripod in production will support his D500 and his Tamron 150-600 that together weigh about 6.25 lbs. The cheapest ones are inadequate for most photography, unless one can be creative with blur.

https://thecentercolumn.com is an excellent source of testing and analysis on tripods and heads.
Pure nonsense. Load capacity has very little to do... (show quote)


Thanks for the link, this is very enlightening. At least now I know why I'm not very happy with my new tripod.

Reply
Feb 21, 2022 15:27:11   #
JKaye Loc: Chicago
 
Take a look at Benro (an offshoot of Manfrotto) less expensive and available in carbon fiber with clamps. They also have great head Model #PU70. Easy to place on your tripod and both are available from BandH.

Reply
Feb 21, 2022 18:46:23   #
OldSchool-WI Loc: Brandon, Wisconsin 53919
 
This is a followup on my earlier post on my experience of 66 years of tripods for different purposes.

I have just checked the many tripod configurations and prices at B&H---and find the "classic duraluminum" TILTALL at 6lb to be the best for the money at $190. As I said earlier---I bought mine already used in 1967 and it is like new still. It has a wonderful two way head with screw handles and metal threaded clamps on the tubular legs. The new one shown in B&H looks identical to mine. If you have the money--there are "traveling" carbon fiber lighter built for less than 44lb and weigh in at half the weight of the Tiltall. (But here are also carbon fiber--heavy duty tripods weighing in at over 6lb--without a head and costing twice the price of the classic Tiltall and then you must buy a head costing as much as the entire Tilall! But then you might not need the rock solid while on the go with a backpack. Unless you are needing minutes long exposures for a dark night city scape? Bring what you need---buy only what you need. The lightest of all are the folding wooden Graflex tripods made for large heavy format cameras like a Speed Graphic, Crown or Graphic View. They breakdown into three small parts plus the platform. But are the lightest of all mentioned thus far and certainly the oldest. I carry one folded up in my Graphic View case.-------

Reply
 
 
Feb 21, 2022 22:04:37   #
SuperflyTNT Loc: Manassas VA
 
For hiking, if it’s wildlife I shoot handheld. For long exposure shots I use a Platypod with a ball head. I have an L bracket on my Z7 and can mount it in either orientation in seconds. If I’m shooting a waterfall it sits nicely on a rock. With adjustable legs that have a rubber tip on one side and a spike on the other it’s easy to adjust to sit solidly in many spots. If there’s no good spot for it to sit I can strap it to a tree or a post. It’s very light for hiking and very versatile.

Reply
Feb 22, 2022 05:52:52   #
picsman Loc: Scotland
 
I shoot lots of amateur sports and with my D750 and 100-400 lens and have used my carbon tripod with a gimbal from https://www.lensmaster.co.uk/index.htm. I bought the travel version but I dont think that is available now. They also offer a monopod head which I will buy in future once the new season starts. The gimbal doesnt always work in a sporting environment because of the extreme angles I sometimes need thats why I agree with others that a monopod might be more flexible.

Reply
Feb 22, 2022 11:00:11   #
Barbonbrown
 
Try a bean bag. With a solid support (wall, tree, stationary car etc.) they can provide stable support to the longest lens, supporting along the length of the barrel. and they do not cost $100's, nor weigh too much. Much easier to carry any distance.

Of course there are many situations where a tripod does work better, or even is the only solution, but similarly there are times when a tripod cannot be used, or slows you down too much, or is just too inconvenient.

If you must have a tripod the advice above is sound, I'd suggest you go to a retailer and give a few models a try. Within reason the head is more important than the legs imo, Manfrotto, Gitzo, and a number of others make excellent models.

Reply
Feb 22, 2022 14:44:05   #
MJPerini
 
Re Photo Gene51
The picture is quite amazing, there is a subtlety to it that you rarely see. Just wonderful.
It is dead sharp, but the sharpness is not in your face, you see a great picture with perfect gesture well before you notice it is also sharp.
great work

Reply
 
 
Feb 22, 2022 17:30:40   #
Sidwalkastronomy Loc: New Jersey Shore
 
If possible go to the store. I took the trip to B AND H salesman Mike was excellent. Need to see them in person. I bought Manfrotto 190 carbon fiber with seperate gimble head. I like this combo so much I wound up leaving it together and buying a second tripod, Benro TMA37AL with a ball head, this one is aluminium

Reply
Feb 22, 2022 19:02:52   #
TimHGuitar Loc: San Francisco, CA
 
gvarner wrote:
I’ve read that the only "good" tripod is an expensive tripod. Carbon fiber tripods are light and strong but being lightweight means they're less stable than heavier ones and need extra weight hung from them to reduce vibration.


Agree. I have a Gitzo that I've used for years. Was light but is now heavy cause I'm 70 years old. I had a light (expensive) tripod with a Gitzo ball head but when I used 1/60 second exposures on my Mimiya 645 the shutter shook the camera on that tripod. No problem with the heavier Gitzo.

Reply
Feb 22, 2022 19:45:10   #
OldSchool-WI Loc: Brandon, Wisconsin 53919
 
TimHGuitar wrote:
Agree. I have a Gitzo that I've used for years. Was light but is now heavy cause I'm 70 years old. I had a light (expensive) tripod with a Gitzo ball head but when I used 1/60 second exposures on my Mimiya 645 the shutter shook the camera on that tripod. No problem with the heavier Gitzo.


_____________________________
You should use the support best suited for the job as I have said a number of times. But for 56 years I have used a Tiltall (classic--duraluminum) tripod as pictured and still available--and mine was used at my purchase in 1966. Good for even large format--an I use it for my 5x7 as well as Sigma FoveonX3s. Six pounds--but has a great 3way smooth running head--large handles and all metal. This tripod is not likely to blow in the wind or get tripped over at a wedding. I notice someone is offering a modified one on UHH sales.----------(attachment and description--B&H) P.S. Tiltall also makes carbon fiber tripods)The silver TE Original Series Tripod with 3-Way Head from Tiltall has a load capacity of 44 lb, which can support cameras from DSLR and 35mm up to large format. The tripod can extend to a maximum height of 74" and go as low as 28.5".

The 3-section tripod has twist locks for leg extension and adjustable stainless-steel spiked feet for a more secure grip on uneven terrain. One of the legs is detachable and can be converted into a monopod. Both head and legs are constructed from aluminum and have been anodized. The 3-way pan and tilt head has three separate independent locks and has a 1/4"-20 camera fitting.
Twist locks
Rubber feet with adjustable stainless-steel spikes
Removable leg converts into a monopod
Anodized silver finish
Carry case included



Reply
Feb 22, 2022 20:04:32   #
OldSchool-WI Loc: Brandon, Wisconsin 53919
 
OldSchool-WI wrote:
_____________________________
You should use the support best suited for the job as I have said a number of times. But for 56 years I have used a Tiltall (classic--duraluminum) tripod as pictured and still available--and mine was used at my purchase in 1966. Good for even large format--an I use it for my 5x7 as well as Sigma FoveonX3s. Six pounds--but has a great 3way smooth running head--large handles and all metal. This tripod is not likely to blow in the wind or get tripped over at a wedding. I notice someone is offering a modified one on UHH sales.----------(attachment and description--B&H) P.S. Tiltall also makes carbon fiber tripods)The silver TE Original Series Tripod with 3-Way Head from Tiltall has a load capacity of 44 lb, which can support cameras from DSLR and 35mm up to large format. The tripod can extend to a maximum height of 74" and go as low as 28.5".

The 3-section tripod has twist locks for leg extension and adjustable stainless-steel spiked feet for a more secure grip on uneven terrain. One of the legs is detachable and can be converted into a monopod. Both head and legs are constructed from aluminum and have been anodized. The 3-way pan and tilt head has three separate independent locks and has a 1/4"-20 camera fitting.
Twist locks
Rubber feet with adjustable stainless-steel spikes
Removable leg converts into a monopod
Anodized silver finish
Carry case included
_____________________________ br You should use th... (show quote)


________________________
P.S.----I use "quick release" plates and sockets on all my support devices and digital cameras.----ew

Reply
 
 
Feb 22, 2022 20:49:35   #
SuperflyTNT Loc: Manassas VA
 
OldSchool-WI wrote:
_____________________________
You should use the support best suited for the job as I have said a number of times. But for 56 years I have used a Tiltall (classic--duraluminum) tripod as pictured and still available--and mine was used at my purchase in 1966. Good for even large format--an I use it for my 5x7 as well as Sigma FoveonX3s. Six pounds--but has a great 3way smooth running head--large handles and all metal. This tripod is not likely to blow in the wind or get tripped over at a wedding. I notice someone is offering a modified one on UHH sales.----------(attachment and description--B&H) P.S. Tiltall also makes carbon fiber tripods)The silver TE Original Series Tripod with 3-Way Head from Tiltall has a load capacity of 44 lb, which can support cameras from DSLR and 35mm up to large format. The tripod can extend to a maximum height of 74" and go as low as 28.5".

The 3-section tripod has twist locks for leg extension and adjustable stainless-steel spiked feet for a more secure grip on uneven terrain. One of the legs is detachable and can be converted into a monopod. Both head and legs are constructed from aluminum and have been anodized. The 3-way pan and tilt head has three separate independent locks and has a 1/4"-20 camera fitting.
Twist locks
Rubber feet with adjustable stainless-steel spikes
Removable leg converts into a monopod
Anodized silver finish
Carry case included
_____________________________ br You should use th... (show quote)


How many times are you gonna post about the subpar Tiltall tripod? It’s pretty much the same as any under $200 tripod.

Reply
Feb 22, 2022 21:02:02   #
OldSchool-WI Loc: Brandon, Wisconsin 53919
 
SuperflyTNT wrote:
How many times are you gonna post about the subpar Tiltall tripod? It’s pretty much the same as any under $200 tripod.


____________________________
i EXPECT AS MUCH FROM YOU. You are always true to form---spouting out without the slightest knowledge about what you say. You merely want to post something snarly during your waking hours. How can a rock sold tripod and head be "subpar?" It holds 44lb. Do you want a lounge chair or maybe your old age recliner to sit on a tripod? And the head is three way and much easier to use than a floppy ball top. Get real---SUPERFLY-TNT. And keep quiet when you know nothing.-----ew

Reply
Feb 22, 2022 22:56:41   #
Retired CPO Loc: Travel full time in an RV
 
OldSchool-WI wrote:
____________________________
i EXPECT AS MUCH FROM YOU. You are always true to form---spouting out without the slightest knowledge about what you say. You merely want to post something snarly during your waking hours. How can a rock sold tripod and head be "subpar?" It holds 44lb. Do you want a lounge chair or maybe your old age recliner to sit on a tripod? And the head is three way and much easier to use than a floppy ball top. Get real---SUPERFLY-TNT. And keep quiet when you know nothing.-----ew
____________________________ br i EXPECT AS MUCH F... (show quote)


But, But...It's not carbon fiber!. But, But, it doesn't cost an impressive $750 plus dollars!. But, But, it doesn't impress my friends! How can I bring that out into the field where someone might see it?

Reply
Feb 22, 2022 23:05:16   #
imagemeister Loc: mid east Florida
 
Retired CPO wrote:
But, But...It's not carbon fiber!. But, But, it doesn't cost an impressive $750 plus dollars!. But, But, it doesn't impress my friends! How can I bring that out into the field where someone might see it?



Reply
Page <<first <prev 6 of 8 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.