Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Which lens would you recommend for soccer?
Page <<first <prev 3 of 6 next> last>>
Jul 5, 2021 11:13:23   #
SkyKing Loc: Thompson Ridge, NY
 
…on the D7500 I would choose the 80-400…especially if you will be sitting in the stands…both lenses can be hand held but they are heavy so you need to take that into consideration as well…

StLouie1970 wrote:
My
daughter plays 11v11 soccer and I'll be traveling to CO for a tournament.
Games over 5 days could be anywhere from 8am-7pm
I'm using BorrowLens.com to rent a telephoto lens.
I already own a Nikkor 70-200 2.8, but I'm contemplating renting something with more reach (not knowing the field/parent restrictions)
I am torn between these two....any suggestions?
1. Nikon 80-400mm f/4.5-5.6G AF-S ED VR Lens - about $130
2. Nikon 200-500mm f/5.6E AF-S ED VR Lens - about $80

My thought was #1 is kind of doubling up on the focal length I already have, but may save me from switching lens.
Then again, #2 can get me across the field more (as I dont know what seating will be like)

Thoughts?
My br daughter plays 11v11 soccer and I'll be tra... (show quote)

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 11:27:52   #
lbrande
 
no12mo wrote:
Was the lens you used meant to be used on a cropped sensor?


Yes. I talked with an advisor at B&H prior to purchasing it some time ago.

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 11:30:50   #
JDefebaugh
 
200-500. I shoot soccer and lacrosse with a Canon RF 100-500. Over 95% of my shots are between 200-500mm, with about 50% in the 400-500mm range. So, assuming you have a full frame body, I think the Nikon 200-500mm is your best option.

Reply
 
 
Jul 5, 2021 12:20:56   #
Kenmull
 
I have been shooting my grandson who plays lacrosse but the issues should be the same. The first game I brought my 500pf, 300pf and 70-200 F2.8 on my Nikon Z7 II. After the first half having used all three lenses I ended up with the 70-200 as being the best. Yes, I had to crop some of the shots but the shorter 200 gave me a better way of tracking my grandson. I will admit that the Z7 does offer 45mega pixels which allows for reasonable cropping.

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 13:01:58   #
patriciawest Loc: Lorain, Ohio
 
StLouie1970 wrote:
My daughter plays 11v11 soccer and I'll be traveling to CO for a tournament.
Games over 5 days could be anywhere from 8am-7pm
I'm using BorrowLens.com to rent a telephoto lens.
I already own a Nikkor 70-200 2.8, but I'm contemplating renting something with more reach (not knowing the field/parent restrictions)
I am torn between these two....any suggestions?
1. Nikon 80-400mm f/4.5-5.6G AF-S ED VR Lens - about $130
2. Nikon 200-500mm f/5.6E AF-S ED VR Lens - about $80

My thought was #1 is kind of doubling up on the focal length I already have, but may save me from switching lens.
Then again, #2 can get me across the field more (as I dont know what seating will be like)

Thoughts?
My daughter plays 11v11 soccer and I'll be traveli... (show quote)


For Football I used a 150-600 on a DX crop mode camera Nikon D750, on a tripod. That DX mode gave me an additional 1.5 times more reach. Then I had a second camera around my neck with my 28-300. I'd quickly switch to that when the players came towards me, too close for the 150. You have to kind of know what moves might be coming next to know when to switch. For only one camera, use the widest range. I liked my 28-300 fine. There is a Tamron 18-400 that my hubby uses and it is DX cropped.

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 14:09:24   #
dbrugger25 Loc: Raleigh, NC
 
I have used a 20-200 f:2.8 for basketball. My camera has a 30mp full frame sensor. I was able to stand on the sidelines, as close as possible without being on the field. It worked very well. I shot in 5 frames per second mode and ended up with hundreds of images. We just selected the best ones.

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 14:27:49   #
mundy-F2 Loc: Chicago suburban area
 
StLouie1970 wrote:
My daughter plays 11v11 soccer and I'll be traveling to CO for a tournament.
Games over 5 days could be anywhere from 8am-7pm
I'm using BorrowLens.com to rent a telephoto lens.
I already own a Nikkor 70-200 2.8, but I'm contemplating renting something with more reach (not knowing the field/parent restrictions)
I am torn between these two....any suggestions?
1. Nikon 80-400mm f/4.5-5.6G AF-S ED VR Lens - about $130
2. Nikon 200-500mm f/5.6E AF-S ED VR Lens - about $80

My thought was #1 is kind of doubling up on the focal length I already have, but may save me from switching lens.
Then again, #2 can get me across the field more (as I dont know what seating will be like)

Thoughts?
My daughter plays 11v11 soccer and I'll be traveli... (show quote)


There are several good reviews, on different sites, on the 200-500. Many reviewers noted it is very sharp. Be sure to take a small wide angle prime for team pictures and of your daughter and team mates. Both of my boys played soccer and I used a 300mm f/4.5 Nikkor in the 1980's.
Enjoy!
Mundy

Reply
 
 
Jul 5, 2021 14:46:34   #
RolandDieter
 
Get a 2x converter. You f/2.8 will become a 140-400 f/5.6. I also recommend shooting either in shutter priority or wide open. You want some bokeh but also want to stop the action, so which will work best depends a bit on time of day and how bright vs cloudy it is. If your images are sharp you can also do some cropping in post which can work better than trying to nail the crop on set. Nailing the crop on set is difficult; the pros develop this skill and because they are doing it so much they are in constant practice.

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 14:54:23   #
GoldenInCO Loc: Colorado
 
I live in the Denver area and am beginning to think I have visited every soccer field in the area. Most important is the altitude - we have really intense light if the sun is out, so that shouldn't be a great concern. I shoot with a Tamron 18-400 f/3.5-6.3 with my Nikon D7500, and get great shots from football field length to up close park and rec fields. Have fun, bring lots of sunscreen, a large brimmed hat and drink lots and lots of water. Have fun.

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 14:55:18   #
imagemeister Loc: mid east Florida
 
A 2X SLOWS down the AF .....

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 15:00:23   #
cascom Loc: Redmond
 
I use a D500 and a 70-200mm with a 1.7 extender and am very happy with the results. At night I might use a 300mm 2.8. I have a backup D7200 with a 28-300mm. I tend to stand behind the goal of the weaker team but I am focused on the officials rather than the players. I prefer to shoot into the sun and overexpose if the players are wearing white uniforms.



Reply
 
 
Jul 5, 2021 15:17:08   #
StLouie1970
 
Thank you to everyone for the comments. I went with my gut, and a recommendation from a pro photographer, and rented the 200-500.

Here are some of the reasons/questions you asked:
I'm shooting with a D7500 body

So, this is a facility that we've never been to before, so I have no idea as to where we are allowed to sit. On our fields I literally shoot from the touch line. Last tournament forced us to sit in stands 50yds from the pitch. This is a National Tournament (a huge deal for our kids) so I just want as many options as possible.

Not many lens rental places near the hotel, and I didnt want to pay for days that we'll be driving...so BorrowLens.com gave me a great price. I'll give feedback on that after.

I typically sit on the 18yd box and in. I like the angles that gives me for attackin gplayers, Defense and the Keeper. I'll focus on a few positions each half and then mix it up. I dont often shoot from half field. Game times and lighting are the unknown, so I feel that I'm covered with my 2.8/70-200 and this 200-500.

Should be a lot of fun. These are 12yo girls and becoming quite the athletes. I look forward to sharing after its over. Thanks again!

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 15:19:38   #
StLouie1970
 
That's great info. Sounds like we have similar equipment.
We are playing at Dicks Sporting Goods Park in Commerce City.
Can you tell me what it's like? Will I be able to get right down on the pitch?
From what I see, those are all grass fields, correct?

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 15:20:41   #
StLouie1970
 
GoldenInCO wrote:
I live in the Denver area and am beginning to think I have visited every soccer field in the area. Most important is the altitude - we have really intense light if the sun is out, so that shouldn't be a great concern. I shoot with a Tamron 18-400 f/3.5-6.3 with my Nikon D7500, and get great shots from football field length to up close park and rec fields. Have fun, bring lots of sunscreen, a large brimmed hat and drink lots and lots of water. Have fun.




That's great info. Sounds like we have similar equipment.
We are playing at Dicks Sporting Goods Park in Commerce City.
Can you tell me what it's like? Will I be able to get right down on the pitch?
From what I see, those are all grass fields, correct?

Reply
Jul 5, 2021 15:23:56   #
StLouie1970
 
david vt wrote:
Hi

1). Contact Thomas902 and Jules Kearney, two of the preeminent photographers we have for soccer. Both do amazing work. I do believe Thomas shoots a prime lens like the 400 or 500, but don’t remember if he is shooting on a FX or DX body. That crop factor would make a big difference. The prime gives him tack sharp images. Jules primarily shoots a D500 and switches between two zoom lens depending on the field setup

You may also want to search for their work in the sports section. Both are very generous in that they almost always post the equipment and settings they use. Will give you an idea

2) where and how close you will be may make your decision, and you may not know that and/or it may change pitch to pitch. Be prepared to be flexible. Like the idea of a monopod as (especially with the longer lenses) it will get heavy as the day wears on. Tripod is a definite no-go

3) as you are considering renting a lens for this big trip, consider renting a 2nd body as well. I would say rent a D500, but if different than current, you don’t want something whose controls you don’t know well, so more inclined to say rent whatever you have and put the 70-200 on it. If you do, would more likely go for the longer lens (see DX/fx comment earlier). Not only will you then have a longer lens but it gives you a closer-in lens that can be set for non-action shots (again, see Jules work - he has a remarkable eye for capturing those “human” moments).

Finally, don’t try to shot every minute of every game. Across the tourney, you will get enough shots to get some good ones, but you will also be able to just watch her play

Have fun, and post some of your work when back. Good luck
Hi br br 1). Contact Thomas902 and Jules Kearney... (show quote)


Great info......thank you

Reply
Page <<first <prev 3 of 6 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.