Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
No good deed goes unpunished
Page <prev 2 of 5 next> last>>
Jun 10, 2019 08:09:25   #
sr71 Loc: In Col. Juan Seguin Land
 
Nancysc wrote:
I would not have done the trade, not even for the 20 pounds. Just say, No, I can't help you. The guy was stupid for leaving his back up battery in his hotel room. A skilled (and honest) photographer always carries the backup in his kit.


Stuff happens mate live with it......

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 08:10:57   #
ikaush Loc: Medford, MA
 
Maybe this tip can be helpful: When a Nikon battery on my Nikon D5300 started going bad it became thicker and sliding it in and out of its compartment required some tangible effort. Perhaps if you had put his battery in your camera right at that point that would've given you a hint of suspicion.

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 08:29:28   #
aschweik Loc: NE Ohio
 
Did you check to see if the money was real and not counterfeit? Good to know that there are nice people like you who truly want to help someone. Hard to say if the guy was scamming you or not. But you tried to help and sometimes that works, and sometimes it doesn't. There should be more nice people in the world.

Reply
 
 
Jun 10, 2019 08:30:28   #
SoftLights Loc: New Orleans, LA
 
Strangely a similar situation happened to me several years ago. I was shooting a model in one of the old cemeteries here in New Orleans and a guy from N.Y. approached me with the same situation, he plugged his battery into the charger the night before but forgot to plug the business end of the cord into the wall outlet, I'm guessing too many Hurricanes at Pat O's. We were both shooting D200's but he offered to swap a dead OEM battery for an aftermarket I got with the camera. We actually became pretty good friends.

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 08:31:53   #
Scruples Loc: Brooklyn, New York
 
LouV wrote:
Funny story. I was in England 2 weeks ago and my wife and I, along with some friends from Bristol, were visiting the beautiful seaside town of Lyme Regis. Of course I was taking pictures. A Canadian tourist walked up to me and asked what camera I was using. I told him it was a Nikon d810. He then explained that he has the same camera and his battery had died and the spare was back at his hotel hours away. He asked if I had a charged spare and if I would swap it for his dead one. I thought how I’d feel if I were in such a beautiful place and unable to take pictures so I said I would. He needed to go to his car to get the battery so I told him where we’d be so he could meet us later.

While we were waiting for him my friends and I were joking that this was some kind of battery scam and this guy was just waiting to find someone with the same camera or, alternatively, he had a large supply of many different dead batteries and prowled tourist areas to unload them. In a little while he showed up with his battery. I noticed it was an after market brand and pointed out mine was a genuine Nikon battery. He agreed that wasn’t a fair trade and immediately handed me £20. I almost didn’t take it but he was insistent.

So that evening when we got back to our Bristol hosts’ home, I plugged it in to charge. It seemed to charge normally and I didn’t give it any further thought. However, days later when I put it in my camera it showed about 3/4 and almost immediately dropped to half. I charged it fully again with the same result. So he got a virtually brand new Nikon battery worth $55 and I got a useless piece of crap plus £20 (about $26). I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt that he didn’t realize his battery was shot and I imagine I’d probably do the same thing in the very unlikely event something like that ever happens again. Better yet, maybe I’ll try the same thing he did when I happen to run into someone else with a d810 ; ).
Funny story. I was in England 2 weeks ago and my ... (show quote)


Well, I'm a Canon kid so I can only share my experiences. One, I NEVER, EVER let anyone touch my "baby." My wife is afraid she'll mess up my settings. Anyone who attempts to and reaches for my Canon 5D Mark IV, will be sent to Photography Prison. Two, I keep four additional OEM fully charged batteries and one in my bag. Sure, they weigh down a little bit but I would hate to have a shot and no working camera. Third, before I go on any trip, I scout out a photography store nearby. Just in case!
With that being written, my heart goes out to any photographer who runs out of battery juice or even a cracked lens. Heaven Forbid!
I have An old scuba diver trick that I learned. When you are running low on Nitrox you should share your rebreather with your buddy until you get back to the surface.
I would swap out my battery to someone else and we would share it for some mutually good shots. The down side of doing this is that the battery will drain slightly faster.
I recently returned from Barcelona, Spain. I never had been there before. Before hand, I found out there was a department store, Le Cortes Ingles near our hotel.

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 08:42:19   #
Scruples Loc: Brooklyn, New York
 
Dannj wrote:
If this was a scam I think the “scammer” must have been at the bottom of his class. All this for a camera battery? And it cost him cash as well? I think his story was true and you helped him out. He likely didn’t know the difference in the batteries.
IMO, of course.


I don't think you were scammed because the stranger offered a twenty pound note. If he was trying to scam you, you wouldn't have gotten that much. In general, we photographers are a caring bunch, I think. Helping someone less fortunate shows that you are a good person like myself. I happen to care for a few people and in such an instance I will give out a business card. Hopefully, this stranger may well become a new friend.

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 08:58:22   #
lev29 Loc: Born and living in MA.
 
Nancysc wrote:
I would not have done the trade, not even for the 20 pounds. Just say, No, I can't help you. The guy was stupid for leaving his back up battery in his hotel room. A skilled (and honest) photographer always carries the backup in his kit.
Even though Nancysc's comment is, by definition, in retrospect, particularly given the use of the term "stupid" rather than, say, "foolish", I admit that, prospectively, I wouldn’t have been so generous with lending a battery to a total stranger (w/o any collateral,) that cost me that much to replace.

While Sony’s mirrorless camera batteries are similar in cost to Nikon's, some 3rd party brands, e.g. Patona, make replacement batteries that are as good or better in quality than the original Sony's for about half the price! Even more so than Nikon, based on what I’ve read when Sony’s mirrorless battery capacity has been compared to those by other major camera manufacturers, one shouldn’t venture outside for long without carrying a spare.

Reply
 
 
Jun 10, 2019 09:02:17   #
al13
 
I would have done the same thing. Worse case scenario you got scammed and for a small loss. Best case you helped someone in need and that’s worth taking the chance. I hope the money was not counterfeit. Forgot to add, I shoot Fuji. Not many Fuji shooters so probably will never face your situation. 👍

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 09:17:35   #
Stephan G
 
LouV wrote:
Funny story. I was in England 2 weeks ago and my wife and I, along with some friends from Bristol, were visiting the beautiful seaside town of Lyme Regis. Of course I was taking pictures. A Canadian tourist walked up to me and asked what camera I was using. I told him it was a Nikon d810. He then explained that he has the same camera and his battery had died and the spare was back at his hotel hours away. He asked if I had a charged spare and if I would swap it for his dead one. I thought how I’d feel if I were in such a beautiful place and unable to take pictures so I said I would. He needed to go to his car to get the battery so I told him where we’d be so he could meet us later.

While we were waiting for him my friends and I were joking that this was some kind of battery scam and this guy was just waiting to find someone with the same camera or, alternatively, he had a large supply of many different dead batteries and prowled tourist areas to unload them. In a little while he showed up with his battery. I noticed it was an after market brand and pointed out mine was a genuine Nikon battery. He agreed that wasn’t a fair trade and immediately handed me £20. I almost didn’t take it but he was insistent.

So that evening when we got back to our Bristol hosts’ home, I plugged it in to charge. It seemed to charge normally and I didn’t give it any further thought. However, days later when I put it in my camera it showed about 3/4 and almost immediately dropped to half. I charged it fully again with the same result. So he got a virtually brand new Nikon battery worth $55 and I got a useless piece of crap plus £20 (about $26). I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt that he didn’t realize his battery was shot and I imagine I’d probably do the same thing in the very unlikely event something like that ever happens again. Better yet, maybe I’ll try the same thing he did when I happen to run into someone else with a d810 ; ).
Funny story. I was in England 2 weeks ago and my ... (show quote)


A good reason to have a car charger for the battery.

Personally, I have a set limit in my mind as to "lending" someone anything. I have kept to it over the decades. Though, I have been creative in helping those folks out.

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 09:18:11   #
Toment Loc: FL, IL
 
I use non OEM all the time but I’d never ask someone to trade for the real thing. Not a scam, just a guy who’s not really with it...

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 09:19:32   #
retiredsgt Loc: Red Lion Pa.
 
Mark Twain once said, " If you expect the Worst of everyone, You will never be disappointed!"

Reply
 
 
Jun 10, 2019 09:31:17   #
Fleet
 
I often here people who have been robbed say “they could have asked I would have given it to them “ well he did ask. So I would take satisfaction in any good Karma coming your for a good deed!

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 09:59:27   #
sbohne
 
Dannj wrote:
If this was a scam I think the “scammer” must have been at the bottom of his class. All this for a camera battery? And it cost him cash as well? I think his story was true and you helped him out. He likely didn’t know the difference in the batteries.
IMO, of course.


I'm with you. If this is a scam, the guy went through a helluva lotta trouble to get what...$20? No scammer would part with $20. Some of you folks have gotten very cynical! I think he honestly didn't know the batt was bad. And so what? You helped another human being. Rewards in heaven.

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 10:10:24   #
jayluber Loc: Phoenix, AZ
 
I had same thing happen to me in May in Arches NP. Except he had Nikon and I had Canon. So I didn't loose a battery.

Reply
Jun 10, 2019 10:13:43   #
maxlieberman Loc: 19027
 
No good deed goes unpunished.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 5 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.