elliott937 wrote:
For years, in using my Canon DSLRs, I've always turned off the gazillion focusing squares and elected for just one in the center. I suppose if photographing a moving subject, moving either toward or away from the camera would be a perfect time to have the gazillion squares turned on. For me, I prefer to have just one focusing square and have total control. Am I missing something? Or, do many of you turn off all but one of the focusing squares?
I use single point the majority of the time. The advantage to it is that you control exactly where the camera and lens focus.
However, sometimes with faster and more erratically moving subjects it's necessary to use a multi-point method of focusing. The disadvantage to this is that it leaves it up to the camera to decide where to focus and there's some risk that it won't be precisely where you'd prefer it to do so. You have to weigh this risk against the difficulty keeping a single point on the moving subject. And there are other factors... For example, if you are using a smaller lens aperture you can tolerate some slightly missed focus and may be more able to use a multi-point method.
Some cameras have choice of multi-point focus "patterns" too... Such as Zone Focus or Expansion Points. These limit the number of points the camera can opt to use and can reduce risk of missed focus to some extent, when used properly. The difference between them are that Zone allows the camera to start focusing using any of the active AF points, while Expansion leaves it to the photographer to choose a single point where AF will start, but allows the camera to switch to an adjacent point if "needed" because the starting point isn't kept on the subject by the photographer.
The Zone patterns and All Points will usually start focusing on whatever is closest to the photographer and covered by one (or more) of the active AF points. For example, if you are tracking a large bird flying past, the camera is likely to focus on the closest wing tip, rather than on the bird's head and body.
Depending upon camera model, there are may be two different sizes of Zones available (in addition there's "All Point/Auto Selection"... which in effect is one great big Zone too). Also depending upon the camera model, there may be multiple Expansion patterns available: 4-point and 8-point. The difference is that 4-point allows the points directly above and below, left and right of the starting point to be used. 8-point allows those plus the diagonally located points.... all 8 points surrounding the starting point... to be used, if needed. When I use multiple points, I usually use Expansion instead of Zone... and with either of those I generally use the smallest pattern that will do the job.
But, for me those are all "specialty" focus modes that I use in certain circumstances. I tend to use Single Point the vast majority of the time. I prefer it, whenever possible, even though it's more work for me keeping the AF point right on the subject. (Note: I also use Back Button Focusing almost exclusively, along with AI Servo mode... Most of what I shoot is action/sports/wildlife).
I also tend to use the center point the most. Yes, this ends up centering subjects in the image quite often. To have option to position subjects off-center, I try to compose my images slightly loosely, to allow a little cropping if needed. Emphasis on "slightly" here... I still try to "fill the viewfinder" as much as possible too, in order to avoid over-cropping.
BTW, Canon pioneered multi-point AF... I think the EOS 10/10S cameras of 1990 were the first, with 3-point AF. In 1992 the EOS A2/A2E upped that to 5-point AF and the "E" version also had "Eye Control", which is supposed to detect the users eye movement to know where they are looking and switch AF points automatically. The premium/pro EOS 1N (1994) also had 5-point AF, but without Eye Control.
The EOS-3 (1998) introduced 45-point AF with Eye Control, while the EOS-1V (2000) was intro'd with similar 45-point AF without Eye Control. The 45-point system (without Eye Control) continued to be used in the 1D and 1Ds-series pro cameras for a number of years... Eventually replaced with the 61-point AF used in the 1DX and later 5D-series models today.
In 2000 the EOS 33/Elan 7, EOS 30/Elan 7E 30E models introduced 7-point AF The EOS 30/Elan 7E had "Eye Control", while the EOS 33/Elan 7 didn't.
Later "V" and "N" versions of the EOS 33/30, Elan 7/7E models intro'd in 2004 were minor upgrades... and among the very last film SLRs Canon introduced. (Later the same year, the Rebel T2/EOS 100X was the last model intro'd. The EOS-1V was the last film SLR to remain in production... until May 2018.)