Interesting article on sRGB vs. Adobe RGB
Mar 20, 2024 18:19:30 #
Mar 21, 2024 00:12:04 #
I thought the article was overly simplistic, there are other more comprehensive articles available on the subject.
I think the entire article could be summarized from the following excerpt:
"Manea's advice is simple and based upon the end use of an image: "if it's online, shoot sRGB, if it's for print, shoot Adobe RGB."
I think the entire article could be summarized from the following excerpt:
"Manea's advice is simple and based upon the end use of an image: "if it's online, shoot sRGB, if it's for print, shoot Adobe RGB."
Mar 21, 2024 07:59:34 #
Simple is good.
And isn't that what he stated?
It just happened to be an article that appeared in my Facebook feed, I didn't go looking for it.
Since so many here argue about A vs. B, I thought it might help make things simpler. But there will always be those who won't let that happen........ Gotta be long, involved, and detailed, with their reasons to justify their decision.
I've long ago made my decision on which to use.
And isn't that what he stated?
It just happened to be an article that appeared in my Facebook feed, I didn't go looking for it.
Since so many here argue about A vs. B, I thought it might help make things simpler. But there will always be those who won't let that happen........ Gotta be long, involved, and detailed, with their reasons to justify their decision.
I've long ago made my decision on which to use.
Mar 21, 2024 08:48:21 #
tcthome
Loc: NJ
Longshadow wrote:
Simple is good.
And isn't that what he stated?
It just happened to be an article that appeared in my Facebook feed, I didn't go looking for it.
Since so many here argue about A vs. B, I thought it might help make things simpler. But there will always be those who won't let that happen........ Gotta be long, involved, and detailed, with their reasons to justify their decision.
I've long ago made my decision on which to use.
And isn't that what he stated?
It just happened to be an article that appeared in my Facebook feed, I didn't go looking for it.
Since so many here argue about A vs. B, I thought it might help make things simpler. But there will always be those who won't let that happen........ Gotta be long, involved, and detailed, with their reasons to justify their decision.
I've long ago made my decision on which to use.
I watched a vid on You Tube of coarse just a couple of days ago. It was on the Fotospeed *(printing type channel). They had Alex Nail, a landscape photographer on who also has his own channel on you tube, sells books, workshops, etc. He uses the srgb color space from in camera on thru printing. I was actually a little surprised. Happy shooting/ printing!
Mar 21, 2024 08:56:14 #
tcthome wrote:
I watched a vid on You Tube of coarse just a couple of days ago. It was on the Fotospeed *(printing type channel). They had Alex Nail, a landscape photographer on who also has his own channel on you tube, sells books, workshops, etc. He uses the srgb color space from in camera on thru printing. I was actually a little surprised. Happy shooting/ printing!
Yea, I wouldn't want to keep flipping or worry about "saving as" all the time. Two copies? Nope.
I just use one, and it is what it is.....
Mar 21, 2024 11:31:28 #
JD750 wrote:
I thought the article was overly simplistic, there are other more comprehensive articles available on the subject.
I think the entire article could be summarized from the following excerpt:
"Manea's advice is simple and based upon the end use of an image: "if it's online, shoot sRGB, if it's for print, shoot Adobe RGB."
I think the entire article could be summarized from the following excerpt:
"Manea's advice is simple and based upon the end use of an image: "if it's online, shoot sRGB, if it's for print, shoot Adobe RGB."
If you shoot RAW, it makes no difference.
Mar 21, 2024 12:20:17 #
rcarol wrote:
If you shoot RAW, it makes no difference.
Only with the JPEG if one also saves that.
Mar 21, 2024 12:35:05 #
Longshadow wrote:
🤔Simple is good.
And isn't that what he stated?
It just happened to be an article that appeared in my Facebook feed, I didn't go looking for it.
Since so many here argue about A vs. B, I thought it might help make things simpler. But there will always be those who won't let that happen........ Gotta be long, involved, and detailed, with their reasons to justify their decision.
I've long ago made my decision on which to use.
And isn't that what he stated?
It just happened to be an article that appeared in my Facebook feed, I didn't go looking for it.
Since so many here argue about A vs. B, I thought it might help make things simpler. But there will always be those who won't let that happen........ Gotta be long, involved, and detailed, with their reasons to justify their decision.
I've long ago made my decision on which to use.
And then there are those who accept what is said on the internet without question and without understanding the reasons behind it.
I know you and I know you do understand the reasoning. FYI I would be inclined to believe what you said but some random guy writing an article? I need to know more before I blindly accept it.
And I didn’t say it was wrong or that I disagreed. Rather what he said could have been said in one sentence or if he was going to expand on it then he could have added more detail.
Mar 21, 2024 13:45:29 #
JD750 wrote:
🤔 br br And then there are those who accept what... (show quote)
Sometimes in a nutshell works well.....
Mar 21, 2024 13:54:13 #
I just us Adobe as my standard and convert in the editing software for posting. I don't always know which will be printed and the image quality most people get on their computer or tablet 90% can't tell any difference from in camera sRGB and software conversion.
Mar 21, 2024 13:57:41 #
JD750 wrote:
🤔 br br And then there are those who accept what... (show quote)
The article was aimed at people who want a bit of "why" but are not techies and don't need a comprehensive explanation.
Except for high end user tech publications almost all tech articles are aimed at that audience.
Mar 21, 2024 14:12:12 #
robertjerl wrote:
I just us Adobe as my standard and convert in the editing software for posting. I don't always know which will be printed and the image quality most people get on their computer or tablet 90% can't tell any difference from in camera sRGB and software conversion.
Nor prints made with sRGB and AdobeRGB unless they have the other print to compare.
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.