rlv567 wrote:
Interesting! The picture follows the "rule" of not having the "subject" of the picture centered - and the action or intent - should be toward the open space, rather than out of the near side. When I compose or view a picture, I don't think at all about intent, point of entry, eye movement, stressful or relaxing, flow – or anything else. Basically, the ONLY thing I think about is what LOOKS BEST to me!!!
For me, the first picture is by far the better. I generally prefer the open space to be on the right side, but it does depend on the specific picture.
Those things being said – and who knows how much effect it might have – I was born left-handed, but switched over by my parents, such that those things which are natural, I do left, while those which are learned, I do right. And for some, I’m ambidextrous – such as switch hitting or basketball dribbling and shooting. (I could hit for a better average, left, but with more power, right.)
I long have wondered about something else, also. On a motorcycle, it always has been more comfortable laying the bike over hard into a left turn than right.
Again, interesting!!!
Loren – in Beautiful Baguio City
Interesting! The picture follows the "rule&q... (
show quote)
rlv567 wrote:
Those things being said – and who knows how much effect it might have – I was born left-handed, but switched over by my parents, such that those things which are natural, I do left, while those which are learned, I do right. And for some, I’m ambidextrous – such as switch hitting or basketball dribbling and shooting. (I could hit for a better average, left, but with more power, right.)
It could be difficult to gauge how much effect those things may have on the way photos are viewed and comprehended -- how to gauge if there is a direct correlation.
Probably for a well-trained, experienced scientific researcher/investigator there are specific tests and criteria which can be utilized to gain insight into the answer to that.
There are other factors which likely influence swinging the ball bat, using a shovel, axe, hammer, shooting the basketball, etc. Things related to dominant / non-dominant eye, strength balance or imbalance between left side -- right side, and other inherent natural variations which make us individually more comfortable doing certain things right-sided or left-sided. Does that affect how general population (not scientific experts) people
naturally view photos??? Hmmmm......
(As a complete brief diversion down a different path:
-- having worked with different livestock herding dogs, it is quite apparent some are much more naturally comfortable circling stock in a counterclockwise direction, others naturally in a clockwise direction, and some don't exhibit a natural preference for either one over the other -- circling right or circling left seems all the same to them. [Some horses exhibit right side / left side preferences, too.]
Of course, any dog which is going to be highly useful in a range of situations needs to be trained to work in each direction. It takes a lot more repetition and practice in the direction which does not come naturally to the dog, and it may never reach the same level of proficiency in each direction....the natural inclination direction may always be obviously done more fluidly and skillfully.
I contend it's not only humans who have individual right-handed / left-handed / ambidexterous tendencies.)
------------------
rlv567 wrote:
I long have wondered about something else, also. On a motorcycle, it always has been more comfortable laying the bike over hard into a left turn than right.
Doesn't a lot of that have to do with location of throttle (mostly) and rear brake pedal?
The physiological alignment factors of having the throttle wrist down and under as compared to up and on top seems to affect my comfort/discomfort in the turning comparisons both in pavement- and dirt- riding.
I rode an early sixties Triumph bike (made before left shift - right brake standardization) for a couple or three weeks. All my previous motorcycle riding had been on Japanese bikes, and the right foot shift - left foot brake on the Triumph was a little learning curve, but not terrible, but, in that amount of time, I never did get as comfortable with left hand turns on that bike as compared to left turns on Japanese bikes.
In dirt-riding, it is more comfortable to keep my right foot near the brake pedal in a left turn than it is to drop the right foot down for posting a right turn.
In some things we just have to train and practice and train and practice and train and practice in order to do them with any degree of acceptability, if there is a natural tendency to be uncomfortable / awkward / inept / klutz-prone in the doing.
Is the way we view photos influenced by repetitive training for those who've had extensive instructions in photography compared against those of us who just muddle along by seat-of-the-pants "this way seems natural"?