donmikes wrote:
Many excellent photos are posted by UHH members, but this is not one of them.
Cinque Terre is a beautiful area -- five very picturesque towns situated at the base of mountains along the sea and linked by a hiking trail above them. Since you were hiking, I expected a series of photos with interesting perspectives. Instead you submitted a seascape that one could see in thousands of places throughout the world and which hardly reflects the unique characteristics of Cinque Terre. The photo is also not particularly interesting from a light or composition standpoint -- a third of the image is out-of-focus, uninteresting foliage, and there is nothing exceptional about the sky or the sea.
You received a few of the usual "nice capture" responses, but how many people do you think clicked on the link and then immediately clicked off in disappointment? I don't want to be mean, and I understand the idea, "if you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all". I also understand that there is a wide range of talent and experience among the members, and I don't want to discourage anyone from contributing, but I think some blunt, honest critique is warranted.
You are not the first one to have difficulty with the basic question, "will viewers find this interesting?."
Many excellent photos are posted by UHH members, b... (
show quote)
That's a bit harsh from someone that has never posted a picture in over four years. Personally, I am glad for any photo that isin't another squirrel or bird-on stick.