What are your thoughts concerning the door frame on the right? I wanted to include the light illumination on the wall as a sort of balance to the light illuminating the wall from behind the square fixtures. My sense is that the darkness of the frame may be a distraction.
BudsOwl
Loc: Upstate NY and New England
Chicflat wrote:
What are your thoughts concerning the door frame on the right? I wanted to include the light illumination on the wall as a sort of balance to the light illuminating the wall from behind the square fixtures. My sense is that the darkness of the frame may be a distraction.
It didn't distract me. I think it is needed to avoid having the light look like it is leaving the scene.
Bud
It distracted me, but everyone is going to have different thoughts on it.
Chicflat wrote:
What are your thoughts concerning the door frame on the right? I wanted to include the light illumination on the wall as a sort of balance to the light illuminating the wall from behind the square fixtures. My sense is that the darkness of the frame may be a distraction.
Crop it out. You still will get the flood of light on the wall, which is the effect you wanted.
I think it distracts from the overall graphic look of the shot.
...I want to see more of the door...the picture doesn’t pull me in...but what do I know...?
Without it, the shot is unbalanced, driving the eye to the right and right out of the photo with nothing to stop it. I think the strong geometry of the shot would be improved if you'd "warp" the corner and the frame to a perfect vertical.
AndyH
Loc: Massachusetts and New Hampshire
I’d crop it out, but that’s just me.
Andy
CPR
Loc: Nature Coast of Florida
I cropped it out and liked the picture better.
IMHO, you could crop out the door frame as well as the light fixture and still have the light from the fixture on the wall to balance out the light on the left.
IMHO, you could crop out just the frame, but this leaves you with the brightest element at the edge pulling your eye out of the frame. Option two might be to crop to the left of the shade leaving a simple but dynamic image of shapes and lines. Less is more!
Chicflat wrote:
What are your thoughts concerning the door frame on the right? I wanted to include the light illumination on the wall as a sort of balance to the light illuminating the wall from behind the square fixtures. My sense is that the darkness of the frame may be a distraction.
Pardon me if I respond to all at once; I hope I am not rude. So, this crop does not satisfy. What I need to thank you for are those suggestions which explain how i might better crop the image and the resulting benefits. thank you all. Self-confession: I think sometimes I am too controlled by my original thought on an image and so I don't see the places that I could go with it.
Thanks again to all for your insight. I have some question about this crop, but it does reflect a better direction I think. Thanks again to all.
If you want to reply, then
register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.