Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Best, Sturdy, lightweight, 4 Section Tripod?
Page <<first <prev 5 of 5
Apr 25, 2018 20:15:08   #
jcboy3
 
MikeBl wrote:
First let me say I appreciate you taking the time to comment.

My requirements are, lightweight, reasonably strong, and carry-on luggage compact. Oddly enough, I was under the misconception that carbon fiber was significantly lighter. After starting my tripod research I have found that's not always the case, and in some brands, carbon fiber can add considerably to the cost.

Which means I have eliminated any bias I had for carbon fiber and will consider only the three requirements listed, in addition to reasonably priced. Truthfully, tripods are of limited value to me because 80% of my wildlife shots are spontaneous hand-held shots. I do plan to do some night, low-light shooting in Paris and London though.

Thanks again!
First let me say I appreciate you taking the time ... (show quote)


I prefer carbon fiber for several reasons.

They are lighter, by about 25%. But twice as expensive.

They are much better in cold weather. Lower thermal conductivity, so they don't freeze your hands.

Quieter. Bang something against an aluminum tripod...it's loud.

Usually better vibration dampening.

Plus, they look cool.

Reply
Apr 25, 2018 20:25:32   #
MikeBl Loc: USA
 
Jeff Clark wrote:
Hi Mike,
I have been reviewing some of the comments about your tripod concerns for your trip. I noticed that you mentioned you were taking a Canon 7D MK II. and that you were planning to take you CanonL 100-400 mm IS II USM with a 1.4 tele-extender. That confused me some. The 7D MK II has a APS-C sensor that magnifies your image by 1.6 all by itself. That makes that 400 mm equal to the reach of a 640 mm full frame sensor camera. When you add the 1.4 ext. it bumps you to a reach of almost 900 mm. Your 16-35 mm gives you a reach of 26-56 or wide to normal focal length. The 7D MK II is a great camera. I think I would lighten my load some. Take a CanonL 70-200 mm lens instead. The L series will still accept your 1.4 extender. This gives you an overall reach of 320-480 mm and is no where near as heavy! Buy something like a Benro mono pod with the fold down tri-feet base. You can still shoot at night and low light and lower ISO settings without all the extra weight.
Hi Mike, br I have been reviewing some of the comm... (show quote)



Thanks Jeff. I completely understand your comment. I guess I shouldn't tell you about my 2x Extender? LOL I've done the math on my APS-C camera and the lens combination and use every bit of it daily. Almost all of my bird photos are done with that combination (See posts). I do plan, during the third week of our trip. to do some birding in the Cotswolds of rural England. That will be mostly hand-held shots. The tripod will be for the night shots in Paris and London with a wide angle 2.8 lens. Your suggestion about the Benro tri-feet mono pod is intriguing though. Something to consider. I appreciate your suggestions! PS .. I do own a 70-200 ... one more consideration.

Reply
Apr 26, 2018 00:36:05   #
tims.ak Loc: Butte, Alaska
 
MikeBl wrote:
I know this subject has probably been debated ad nauseam before my time here, but here goes.

I leave for a vacation in France and England in June, with expectations to have an opportunity for both night photos in Paris and London, as well as bird
photography. Like most people, I already have two tripods that simply don't do the job, both in stability and overall weight.

Looking for suggestions for the best tripod that fits the bill listed?

Thanks!



I use Sirui T-2205X and L10 tilt head, also use head with monopod. The L20 might be better choice for tripod. I find them very light and compact but still tall enough to use comfortablly. I travel with them every week and can fit them in my carry on bag along with other gear. I thought they were reasonably priced at the lower end of usable gear. I don't think you'd break them unless they were ran over or crushed in some way. So far I have no complaints and like using the gear for travel and plan to use for a long time. Used it last week in Mohave desert at night in the wind and stable enough for MW captures.

Reply
Check out Close Up Photography section of our forum.
Apr 26, 2018 03:51:58   #
wdross Loc: Castle Rock, Colorado
 
MikeBl wrote:
I know this subject has probably been debated ad nauseam before my time here, but here goes.

I leave for a vacation in France and England in June, with expectations to have an opportunity for both night photos in Paris and London, as well as bird
photography. Like most people, I already have two tripods that simply don't do the job, both in stability and overall weight.

Looking for suggestions for the best tripod that fits the bill listed?

Thanks!


I recently bought the Slik CF-522. It is designed as a relatively sturdy travel tripod. It is ~14" collapsed. The other stats are max height - 58in., min height - 7.0in., max load - 6.6lbs., weight - 2.3lbs., and material - carbon fiber. It lists for ~$300, but can be found on sale for ~$150/170 from time to time. It works perfect for my 4/3rds system. And the system plus tripod will meet most airline's smaller personal carry-on size let alone the bigger baggage carry-on size. There is another Slik tripod, CF-422, that is similar but longer collapsed. It won a prestigious innovation award last year for design. Both are worth consideration.

Reply
Apr 26, 2018 05:56:00   #
MikeBl Loc: USA
 
tims.ak wrote:
I use Sirui T-2205X and L10 tilt head, also use head with monopod. The L20 might be better choice for tripod. I find them very light and compact but still tall enough to use comfortablly. I travel with them every week and can fit them in my carry on bag along with other gear. I thought they were reasonably priced at the lower end of usable gear. I don't think you'd break them unless they were ran over or crushed in some way. So far I have no complaints and like using the gear for travel and plan to use for a long time. Used it last week in Mohave desert at night in the wind and stable enough for MW captures.
I use Sirui T-2205X and L10 tilt head, also use he... (show quote)


Thanks tims! I am definitely considering this model.


Reply
Apr 26, 2018 05:57:30   #
MikeBl Loc: USA
 
wdross wrote:
I recently bought the Slik CF-522. It is designed as a relatively sturdy travel tripod. It is ~14" collapsed. The other stats are max height - 58in., min height - 7.0in., max load - 6.6lbs., weight - 2.3lbs., and material - carbon fiber. It lists for ~$300, but can be found on sale for ~$150/170 from time to time. It works perfect for my 4/3rds system. And the system plus tripod will meet most airline's smaller personal carry-on size let alone the bigger baggage carry-on size. There is another Slik tripod, CF-422, that is similar but longer collapsed. It won a prestigious innovation award last year for design. Both are worth consideration.
I recently bought the Slik CF-522. It is designed ... (show quote)


Thanks wdross!

I already own a Slik table top model thats several yrs old. I'll check this one out too!




Reply
Jun 3, 2018 17:46:26   #
Kuzano
 
Remember this. The more center post you must use to get to eye level the less you can call your stabilizing tool a Tripod. It's a monopod from where the three legs come together and from that point up...... a monopod!

Mayhaps no center column is best!

Reply
Check out True Macro-Photography Forum section of our forum.
Jun 3, 2018 19:03:53   #
imagemeister Loc: mid east Florida
 
Kuzano wrote:
Remember this. The more center post you must use to get to eye level the less you can call your stabilizing tool a Tripod. It's a monopod from where the three legs come together and from that point up...... a monopod!

Mayhaps no center column is best!


Yes I agree, Or, use a LONG one that is braced to the legs at the bottom ......as in the Manfro 475

Trying to go high without a center column makes the legs SPREAD further out and becoming more dangerous to navigate.

..

Reply
Page <<first <prev 5 of 5
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Check out Traditional Street and Architectural Photography section of our forum.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.