letmedance wrote:
Informed opinion is still just opinion and pablum for those that suffer confirmation bias like you.
Well, what you offer is just an opinion, isn't it? And yet you assume your opinion, without any basis whatsoever, no particular experience behind it, no logic, no facts or insight, is superior to professional writer's opinion with their great experience, personal contact with the people involved, education, and vast view of the world.
We can't all experience everything, so we listen to someone who has experienced something, Of course, who we choose to listen to is very important. For example, I never listen to you. You bring no insight, only rudeness and hostility; you bring no logic, only reiteration of emotional and inaccurate stories passed to you by others with no more knowledge than you; you pass along tribal hatred, with no original contribution, no new way to look at things, no ideas that are new, unusual, informative--you add no new insight.
I pass along the opinions I respect, opinions of lawyers, of politicians I respect, of people with new ideas or more experience than I have, professional authors who've been everywhere, done much, learned themselves what I don't know, and who want to pass this insight on. And I want to receive that insight, learn from it, try on those ideas to see if they help me understand the world better, or make me a better person.
When I learn something like that, I like to pass it along for you to try on, evaluate, and perhaps learn from.
In return for this, I get insults, lies denying what I and others say, and inaccurate stories passed from person to person to protect their provincial world view. I get people who can't figure their golf score debating economic theory of professional economists; people with merely a high school education, who often haven't been much of a success in their lives, arguing political theory, even those who don't know the meaning of the words they speak, and the history behind their ideas. These people
need some opinions, some informed intelligent opinions from people who know, who have experienced the world, wrestled with ideas, seen good things and some very bad things, have seen more than you or I have, people who might have something to teach us, something for us to evaluate and measure, try on, ruminate upon, and finally reach our best
informed opinion about, our best idea of how the world really works, what some things mean, examples of just how bad some people are and how good others are, what a nasty civil war looks lie from the inside, what torture really looks like, how the Pope lives and philosophers think, how the rich got that way and how science, greed, dishonesty and lies and idealism rule the world, and what we can do about some of them.
Interesting stuff.
And sometimes, valuable, too.
I like a lot of opinions, good meaty, informed, vivid, real, challenging opinions that I can chew on, grapple with, test and try out. Opinions I can argue with in my mind, laugh at sometimes, and learn from.
You'd soak up every word you could from a professional bass fisherman, or a professional hunting guide. You'd listen to evey thought of an NFL coach if you could, or any top craftsman with a skill you admire, someone who claimed Everest, or wrestled a bear, flew a fighter, or escaped from ISIS.
Their experience is a rich thing to experience, to share and admire, to learn from. But in life, in real life, In Your Own Life, you seek evasion and small-formed ideas, you seek reinforcement of bad ideas you already have, that have already let you down...you seek not to grow, not to learn, not to imagine, not to see what other are trying to tell you--for free!
You deserve more.
You deprive yourself when you accept less.