mwsilvers wrote:
Yes, but at the end of the day, you also have to have a salable product.
And I am sure you'll agree, that the best judge of the value of an image is the person paying for it. Often, we as photographers are critical of images in ways that are different from the consumer, and often much more so.
I have a friend that I occasionally work with when he can't find a second shooter to help. To my eye, his images are strikingly underwhelming. But he works about 45 weddings a year. He is a pro, and makes a good living at it. I don't consider his work salable, but in his geographic area, his clients love his work, and many of his clients are referrals from other happy clients. He does an amazing job at selling himself, and he goes out of his way to ensure his clients are happy. Clearly his clients are buying more than a bunch of pictures - and he delivers.
As I hinted earlier, event and portrait photographers are primarily in the business of selling the customer experience and value they provide. Their success can be attributed how great a job they do of selling themselves by exceeding customer expectations, and how happy their clients are when it's over. Often clients will "overlook" flaws in the images. This is how shooters that produce mediocre images can be successful. One thing is certain, average photographers can make money, and great photographers are not always successful, and that is usually because they often believe their work is so great that it will sell itself. Well, it doesn't in many cases. The photographer has to be skillful at people skills, revealing the customer's expectations and convincing the prospects that they will get the best experience when they select him/her for the job. In NY, we call that "schmoozing." After all, there are many good photographers out there, especially young ones with lots of energy and newly acquired and solid photographic skills. But most lack the business acumen that can only be learned by years of experience selling services. Sad to say, but images have become a commodity, and often, the only thing separating the guys and gals earning a living at this is their ability to market and sell themselves - not making amazing pictures.
The minute the photographer's sales presentation turns away from the client's desires and becomes focused on the photographer's talent, the client will sense trouble ahead and will pass at the "opportunity" to have such a photographer shoot their event. Lawyers and Doctors may be able to get away with stuff like this - but not photographers.
So based on what I have seen over the past 50 yrs, having a "salable" product is not a prerequisite to being successful if your definition of sale-ability is nice prints - though I will agree that it doesn't hurt to have good pictures if everything else is in place.