boydimages wrote:
There are instructions? When I first arrived here I participated in some of the Photo Challenges. It seems you have more patients than I. I soon quit because many of the images did not follow the theme. Some images were questionable if they should have been posted at all. I have not looked at the challenge in quite sometime. That said there were some nice images but the time cost to wade through to find them was too much. I would rather sit on my deck with a cold beer.
I appreciate the candid comments and have to say it's a funny one.
When I started this, I thought it'd be a onetime thing, then maybe two and on it went. It was never meant to run for three years and as such I sort of made up the 'rules' as best I could and have only modified them a little when necessary.
The main points of the challenges, notice I did not say contest, was to teach something and have fun doing it. With that, I try to add hints and tips along with each challenge to give an idea to what it's all about.
Two things I decided way back when, that I'm sure people thought would have helped, was not to add any images to the challenge page as I was sure people would use it as a standard, and not to set the boundaries too tight so as not to allow for artistic expression.
To your point, there are times, when I let an image slide and there are times when someone surprises me and add an image I never thought possible, but still qualifies. For example, if the topic was Sky I would expect skies. Seems simple enough, but inevitably someone comes along and adds an image of a reflection of a sky. It's still a sky, so I allow it.
When in question though, I ask the person if they think it qualifies and why. Most of the time they pull it. And, sadly for reasons of abuse I've had to check the images much more thoroughly than I used to. I never wanted to be judge and jury, but when people pull images off the internet and claim them to be their own, that's too much for me.
I've let the not reading rules part fester for too long now. I get you're new and this is your first 'contest' so you forgot to add a title, but anything else is not going to fly anymore.
Be as artistic within the guidelines as much as you want, I encourage it, but at least read them. That's all I really ask.
All my best, S-