JoBear Loc: Pacific Northwest

Would appreciate feedback on these photos and which you feel might have more impact, with sky or without? I also have a shot with sky at top and then reflected in water - so blue above and below.
Shot at 1/400 sec, 80mm, f20, ISO 200.
Thanks

No Sky

Macronaut Loc: Redondo Beach,Ca.

Can you download again with the "store original" box checked so we can get a better look?

Erv Loc: Medina Ohio

Hi John. Pretty hard to tell with the small picture. If you can post it again and hit store original or down load we will be able to make it bigger.
Erv

minniev Loc: MIssissippi

Welcome to the Critique section! The photo looks interesting and dramatic, with all that cloudy business floating over the water threatening to envelop the tiny boathouse. You'll get more comments if you go back and upload the original, though. It is very hard to see this little version. Just click the box beside the one where you uploaded this one, where it says "store original"

I have found that if I use a jpeg with 1200 pixels on the longest side, it gives enough size and detail for people to give me in depth feedback, but it doesn't take long to upload and it isn't big enough for anyone to want to "steal" (though I'd probably be honored if anyone wanted to "steal" one of mine!)

JoBear Loc: Pacific Northwest

Thanks Bill, Erv and Minniev, new to this and will upload as suggested...