PP editing feedback
Jan 27, 2012 21:55:15 #
I know the branch growing out of the ear has to go, but what I want feedback on was the branches that frame the cats face. Part of me like them because the give it a 3D appearance. Part of me doesn't like them because they're distracting.
Jan 27, 2012 22:01:16 #
jkm757 wrote:
I know the branch growing out of the ear has to go, but what I want feedback on was the branches that frame the cats face. Part of me like them because the give it a 3D appearance. Part of me doesn't like them because their distracting.
Try keeping the bigger triangle branches that frame the face and get rid of the smaller ones inside. Make a copy first. It is an experiment.
Jan 27, 2012 22:03:11 #
jkm757 wrote:
I know the branch growing out of the ear has to go, but what I want feedback on was the branches that frame the cats face. Part of me like them because the give it a 3D appearance. Part of me doesn't like them because their distracting.
Here's my politically correct answer...Do one of each! :-) I'm like you I sorta like the idea either way. I'm no help huh? Good shot!
Jan 27, 2012 22:10:40 #
jkm757 wrote:
I know the branch growing out of the ear has to go, but what I want feedback on was the branches that frame the cats face. Part of me like them because the give it a 3D appearance. Part of me doesn't like them because their distracting.
I think I like them. It gives the feeling of stealth.
Jan 27, 2012 22:19:44 #
Jambulee wrote:
Try keeping the bigger triangle branches that frame the face and get rid of the smaller ones inside. Make a copy first. It is an experiment.
jkm757 wrote:
I know the branch growing out of the ear has to go, but what I want feedback on was the branches that frame the cats face. Part of me like them because the give it a 3D appearance. Part of me doesn't like them because their distracting.
Try keeping the bigger triangle branches that frame the face and get rid of the smaller ones inside. Make a copy first. It is an experiment.
I figured the smaller branches would go along with the one growing out of the ear. I shoot RAW so a copy isn't an issue. Thanks for the feedback.
Jan 27, 2012 22:24:29 #
johnnyg67 wrote:
Here's my politically correct answer...Do one of each! :-) I'm like you I sorta like the idea either way. I'm no help huh? Good shot!
jkm757 wrote:
I know the branch growing out of the ear has to go, but what I want feedback on was the branches that frame the cats face. Part of me like them because the give it a 3D appearance. Part of me doesn't like them because their distracting.
Here's my politically correct answer...Do one of each! :-) I'm like you I sorta like the idea either way. I'm no help huh? Good shot!
That's a good straddle the fence answer. Have you ever thought about a career in politics? :) Thanks for the feedback.
Jan 27, 2012 22:30:20 #
Country's Mama wrote:
I think I like them. It gives the feeling of stealth.
jkm757 wrote:
I know the branch growing out of the ear has to go, but what I want feedback on was the branches that frame the cats face. Part of me like them because the give it a 3D appearance. Part of me doesn't like them because their distracting.
I think I like them. It gives the feeling of stealth.
Thanks Country's Mama.
Jan 27, 2012 22:54:51 #
This pic draws my attention to the cats eyes and I really don't notice the branches.
Jan 27, 2012 23:15:54 #
flytyer57 wrote:
This pic draws my attention to the cats eyes and I really don't notice the branches.
Thanks for the feedback flytyer57.
Jan 27, 2012 23:25:54 #
jkm757 wrote:
I know the branch growing out of the ear has to go, but what I want feedback on was the branches that frame the cats face. Part of me like them because the give it a 3D appearance. Part of me doesn't like them because they're distracting.
I love it just how it is .... nothing is going to distract you from that face. Great photo.
Jan 28, 2012 00:16:49 #
photogrl57 wrote:
I love it just how it is .... nothing is going to distract you from that face. Great photo.
jkm757 wrote:
I know the branch growing out of the ear has to go, but what I want feedback on was the branches that frame the cats face. Part of me like them because the give it a 3D appearance. Part of me doesn't like them because they're distracting.
I love it just how it is .... nothing is going to distract you from that face. Great photo.
Thanks for the input photogirl57
Jan 28, 2012 00:32:40 #
jkm757 wrote:
I know the branch growing out of the ear has to go, but what I want feedback on was the branches that frame the cats face. Part of me like them because the give it a 3D appearance. Part of me doesn't like them because they're distracting.
I hope you don't mind but I did a fast PP on your photo.. cloned out the branches across the body, filled out the light reflection in eye, brought up the contrast on the overall body and darkened the branches. Not flawless, but what my suggestions would be....
Edited
Original
Jan 28, 2012 00:39:58 #
jkm757 wrote:
quote=johnnyg67 quote=jkm757 I know the branch g... (show quote)
lol :lol: Nope never thought about politics. I'd probably wind up in jail :thumbdown:
Jan 28, 2012 00:57:25 #
johnnyg67 wrote:
quote=jkm757 quote=johnnyg67 quote=jkm757 I kno... (show quote)
A politician in jail? I thought they were above the law? :-o
Jan 28, 2012 09:55:16 #
Elle wrote:
quote=jkm757 I know the branch growing out of the... (show quote)
While the edit is good, you now have lost the feel of him slinking through the underbrush.
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.