I'd like some feed back on these pictures, please (Page 2): I like 'em all. Pierre Thank you Pierre...

woodsliv Loc: Tehachapi,CA

PierreH wrote:

woodsliv wrote:

I took the 1st one yesterday in the cloud while snowing. I tried to compose it with interest. #2 was just a cool shot of the bridge, #3 was just an inspiring shot to me Please let me know if it can be improved.

I like 'em all.

Pierre

Thank you Pierre

Jimbo9948 Loc: Zephyrhills, Florida

woodsliv wrote:

I took the 1st one yesterday in the cloud while snowing. I tried to compose it with interest. #2 was just a cool shot of the bridge, #3 was just an inspiring shot to me Please let me know if it can be improved.

I like em all. you can hear the quiet of the snow in #1 (if you know what I mean!) :thumbup: :thumbup:

woodsliv Loc: Tehachapi,CA

Cotondog wrote:

Though all are good, my favorite is #1. Really, really nioce. I also like the crop that CajonPhotog did, but it's a great shot without the crop.

Thanks, I do like the crop as well.

woodsliv Loc: Tehachapi,CA

gregoryd45 wrote:

woodsliv wrote:

I took the 1st one yesterday in the cloud while snowing. I tried to compose it with interest. #2 was just a cool shot of the bridge, #3 was just an inspiring shot to me Please let me know if it can be improved.

They are all good woodsliv, but #1 is very very good. Great shot and well done, it's a keeper. I don't think #1 needs any crop at all, it is fantastic as is

Thank you for the kind words

Joe F.N. Loc: Oshawa, Ontario

#1 has it all. Fantastic composition and fabulous IQ. Though it's subjective, CajonPhotog has cropped the very thing that makes your picture (1) so appealing. The tree on the left is a wonderful frame edge for the house. It's now gone, in his crop. #2 and #3 are really nice shots but 1 takes the gold ribbon.

woodsliv Loc: Tehachapi,CA

Jimbo9948 wrote:

woodsliv wrote:

I took the 1st one yesterday in the cloud while snowing. I tried to compose it with interest. #2 was just a cool shot of the bridge, #3 was just an inspiring shot to me Please let me know if it can be improved.

I like em all. you can hear the quiet of the snow in #1 (if you know what I mean!) :thumbup: :thumbup:

Thanks, It was 8:30 in the morning, no one out and just a little wind

woodsliv Loc: Tehachapi,CA

Joe F.N. wrote:

#1 has it all. Fantastic composition and fabulous IQ. Though it's subjective, CajonPhotog has cropped the very thing that makes your picture (1) so appealing. The tree on the left is a wonderful frame edge for the house. It's now gone, in his crop. #2 and #3 are really nice shots but 1 takes the gold ribbon.

Thanks Joe, I think the tree needs to be there as well, the crop is nice, but the tree balanced the shot.

mndschmidt Loc: Tampa, FL

Lovely winter scenes - especially no. 1. I like them as they are!

rlaugh Loc: Michigan & Florida

Your origionals are great...#1 does not need crop at all!!

Treepusher Loc: Kingston, Massachusetts

Pretty much following the crowd--they're all nice, but number one is your winner. Like the atmosphere and composition. Very nicely done.

woodsliv Loc: Tehachapi,CA

woodsliv wrote:

I took the 1st one yesterday in the cloud while snowing. I tried to compose it with interest. #2 was just a cool shot of the bridge, #3 was just an inspiring shot to me Please let me know if it can be improved.

This is the unedited picture, other than changed from RAW to JPG

13.4mb

Joe F.N. Loc: Oshawa, Ontario

We of course can't tell you what to do but I think the majority would agree that you should listen to your wife and have this one printed and framed. It's that good.

sbode

#1 is my favorite. Well done!

CJartist Loc: Ormond Beach

woodsliv wrote:

I took the 1st one yesterday in the cloud while snowing. I tried to compose it with interest. #2 was just a cool shot of the bridge, #3 was just an inspiring shot to me Please let me know if it can be improved.

Love the compensation in all but no 1 is for the wall.

Bmac Loc: Long Island, NY

All three are well done, but number one is exceptional in so many ways, composition, exposure, mood and interest. Bravo. :thumbup: :thumbup: