EXCELLENT article! Thank you for presenting it;
however, I disagree with your using the qualifier "
All ..." as its discussion and examples employed all pertain to
color IR, i.e. portions of the visible light spectrum are acquired with the near-IR spectrum.
"All" is not just a trivial distinction, since it does not, in my opinion, even indirectly, address the subject of this Topic: Polarizing Filters For
Black & White Infrared Photography
If one can tolerate viewing about two-and-a-half hours of two webinars given by George Wilson, perhaps one can glean some information that leads to a difference. No, I cannot assert that his claim that Singh-Ray's Gold'N'Blue polarizer for B&W IR photography DOES NOT make a difference, since despite my inability to discern
any whatsoever (in the two examples he provided in part 2,) this could be secondary to hardware limitations in his Webinar broadcasts. His quasi-physics explanation did not satisfy me either, as his terminology was clearly "dumbed-down" for what he presumed to be an entirely lay audience.
Here are the URLs and Subjects discussed for each of these webinars:
PART 1:
https://zoom.us/rec/play/uJJ8cbr-qz43T9fBsASDBqAvW9XrKf-s1iceqfEEzEbmASQENlv1b7pGa7F4910kAdFNUU-A_oMXtvfq A review of what is infrared and its origins
The 3 types of infrared capture
Comparison of color vs B&W Infrared photography
Infrared characteristics and how to expose for them
Focusing adjustments, direction of light, digital noise and exposure starting points
Important accessories
PART 2:
https://us02web.zoom.us/rec/play/tMV5ce-vrG43SYWSuQSDC_R8W9XoLvms2igY-PZZxUmwB3VVZgCkYrpHMetkRmP_oRBb1abLXE5dr62R?continueMode=true&_x_zm_rtaid=gUe6uz7iSj2FJ-A6wgqm6Q.1588122123951.15cbfa0e32e67124c788a20d6244f040&_x_zm_rhtaid=520 Camera conversions – pros/cons
Resin vs glass filters
How IR "reacts" with filters
Step-Up rings
Mor-Slo, Vari ND, Vari NDuo
Using an 830mm I-Ray as a 2-stop ND
Contrast w/ Gold Blue Polarizer
Softening the image w/ Soft Ray
Other useful filters
Despite my skepticism as to portions of these two webinars, I hope they can help someone, albeit belatedly.
lev29