genocolo wrote:
My original post on August 29 unintentionally and unexpectedly started a wide-ranging (15page), sometimes interesting, discussion. It was really meant only as an observation, nothing more.
That discussion confirms what we already knew, that most of us use BOTH mobile phones and dedicated, sophisticated cameras, generically described as “dslrs.” The choice often depends on a variety of factors, some of which are: “which is most readily available when the photo opportunity arises?”, “what is my target today?”, “is this a dedicated photo shoot?”, etc.
While obviously I am not arguing for or against the use of mobile phone cameras, I will say to those of you who dismiss a high quality mobile or cell phone camera as one only for “snapshots,” you should look at the results of the annual Mobile Photography Awards. Talk about “art” and “quality”! Also see Ken Rockwell’s extraordinarily positive review of the IPhone 12 Pro Max.
So, coming full circle and without trying to discover the EXIF data, which, IF ANY, of the four photos in my original post, do you believe were taken with an IPhone 12 Pro Max or with a Canon 80D with an EF 100-400mm f/4-5-6L IS II USM lens? For your convenience, I have attached the four photos again here.
After time for replies, I will post the answer if you are interested.
My original post on August 29 unintentionally and ... (
show quote)
There are a lot of times when a cell phone does equal to a dslr or milc at a low level of functionality that doesn't put much of a demand on the results but one on one there are very few situations where my cell phone camera in my hands will produce an equal to or better shot than a dslr or milc - that's my experience and I use apps that give me more than default control of my cell camera. My biggest disappointment in using my "new" 4k cell camera is when I shot 4k video at a special family occasion and tried to look at it on a 65" 4k tv. That may very well be the ultimate test but if you have done that then you understand where the argument begins to find disfavor with the cell camera. When I go out shooting I don't want to have to wonder at what point my results will start to fall apart. As for your test, I wouldn't wager a cent on my ability to tell which were cell shots but frankly, I probably wouldn't bother to shoot those shots with any kind of camera. While nice enough, they are not within the scope of my interest range.