Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
100 % crop
Page <prev 2 of 2
Feb 7, 2019 09:54:25   #
burkphoto Loc: High Point, NC
 
chrisg-optical wrote:
As in the definition in the first link it is confusing (incomplete)...1:1 pixel mapping is would be clearer. Just cropping an image doesn't make it 100% 1:1 pixel mapping.


The 'crop' term refers to the fact that at 100% "pixel for pixel" view of most high resolution images, the image must be cropped to be displayed on the monitor.

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 10:00:48   #
Longshadow Loc: Audubon, PA, United States
 
tomad wrote:
I've never liked that terminology. 100% of anything is all of it. In my thinking if I crop a photo 100%, it's gone!



Reply
Feb 7, 2019 14:06:24   #
Kozan Loc: Trenton Tennessee
 
mtcoothaman wrote:
I have seen reference to "100 % crop " in various posts from time to time. To me that means 100% removal(!) of the photo but I am sure it does not. Can anyone please explain? Thanks


If you take a picture then display it on your camera's monitor, then push the + button repeatedly until you get the smallest little square that shows the cropped image, that's a 100% crop.

On my Nikon D850, I have set the middle button on the multi-selector to zoom in either 100% or 200%.
I'm pretty sure that is what 100% crop is referring to.

Reply
 
 
Feb 7, 2019 14:35:37   #
BebuLamar
 
burkphoto wrote:
The 'crop' term refers to the fact that at 100% "pixel for pixel" view of most high resolution images, the image must be cropped to be displayed on the monitor.


Yes Burk! The term isn't correct but I am seriously wonder if anyone actually doesn't understand what it meant? If all of us do know what it meant than does it really matter if the term is used incorrectly?

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 15:13:12   #
User ID
 
burkphoto wrote:


The 'crop' term refers to the fact that at 100%
"pixel for pixel" view of most high resolution
images, the image must be cropped to be
displayed on the monitor.


Gotta agree with Burk about that. The OP asks
NOT for all the rhetorical arguments that have
ensued, which all seek to show who, if anyone,
knows the "true meaning" of "100% crop".

The OP clearly asks *what people mean* by
100% crop, per the people who say it ... NOT
per "the authorities".

Sooooo ... for the OP, expanding just a bit on
Burk's wording:

Since it's not practical [nor permitted ?] to
post a finished edited file at its full resolution
cuz it may well be 4000x6000 or even 7000x
11,000 pixels. FULL resolution equals 100%
resolution ... it's conversational English, not
necessarily technically rhetorically perfectly
accurate English.

OK, so that covers the meaning of "100%."

The word "crop", in such usage, means "a
small segment cropped out of the full rez
image file" ... so as to be postable without
overloading bandwidth [or breaking rules ?].

Thus the posting of a "100% crop" shows
the quality of detail, focus, noise level, etc
of a 5000x7000 pixel image, by posting a
600x900 pixel "crop" from the full image.

The full image, acoarst, must be resized to
about 1800x1200 for posting, so as to not
overload the system with a gigantic file. So
you post the resized image, and a so-called
100% crop, if the discussion is about noise
or detail or something not really visible in
the down-sized 1800x1200 version.

=========================
=========================

All that crappola about pixel-for-pixel on a
monitor is pointless. In a practical sense, it
NEVER happens. All viewers can zoom their
monitors to any magnification. Pixels in the
original file maybe displayed small than, or
larger than, the "monitor pixels". "Monitor
pixels" are like printer dots, no real relation
to pixels in the image file.

=========================

FWIW, there is no such thing as uncropped
images. The world is wide. The lens crops
the world. The sensor crops the lens's view.
And the user is welcome to "join in the fun".

Even if you never use the cropping tool in
your editing app, you're cropping when you
aim and frame in-camera. Some peeps are
verrrry proud of their "perfect" ability to do
exactly that ... but are BS-ing themselves,
which is OK until they harangue the rest of
us to support their pride of self deception.


.

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 15:54:26   #
bwana Loc: Bergen, Alberta, Canada
 
mtcoothaman wrote:
I have seen reference to "100 % crop " in various posts from time to time. To me that means 100% removal(!) of the photo but I am sure it does not. Can anyone please explain? Thanks

The insert in the following image is a 100% crop if you view the download.

The image was shot using a Minolta AF 500mm f/8 reflex lens on a Sony A7R II with LA-EA4 adapter and I wanted to show the full resolution of the combo.

bwa


(Download)

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 17:04:50   #
TheShoe Loc: Lacey, WA
 
Linda From Maine wrote:
VIEW or display at 100% is more commonly (and correctly) used.

aka pixel peeping:
https://helpx.adobe.com/photoshop/using/viewing-images.html#display_images_at_100

.
That makes much more sense than tying it to an aspect ratio. If we accepted the A/R definition then we would not be able to have a coherent discussion unless everybody used the same base. Those who use 4:3 would mean something different than users of 3:2 (which would differ from those who favor 16:9, ...). Talk about ambiguity.

Reply
 
 
Feb 7, 2019 18:29:36   #
CO
 
User ID wrote:

All that crappola about pixel-for-pixel on a
monitor is pointless. In a practical sense, it
NEVER happens. All viewers can zoom their
monitors to any magnification. Pixels in the
original file maybe displayed small than, or
larger than, the "monitor pixels". "Monitor
pixels" are like printer dots, no real relation
to pixels in the image file.


It can happen if the software package has the correct monitor resolution entered. Photoshop calls it Actual Pixels. Other software packages call it 100% view. The software can map one image pixel to one monitor pixel.


(Download)

Reply
Feb 7, 2019 18:51:46   #
User ID
 
CO wrote:

It can happen if the software package
has the correct monitor resolution entered.
Photoshop calls it Actual Pixels. Other
software packages call it 100% view. The
software can map one image pixel to one
monitor pixel.


Yes. "It CAN happen if ..."
And you CAN get hit by a
meteorite, if ...

But, what is POSSIBLE is
NOT what the OP asks to
have clarified. The OP is
asking for clarity and not
for obfuscation.

.

Reply
Feb 8, 2019 06:35:25   #
CO
 
User ID wrote:
Yes. "It CAN happen if ..."
And you CAN get hit by a
meteorite, if ...

But, what is POSSIBLE is
NOT what the OP asks to
have clarified. The OP is
asking for clarity and not
for obfuscation.

.


No obfuscation. As long as the correct monitor screen resolution is entered into the software, the software will accurately zoom to 100% when selecting "Actual Pixels" (Photoshop) or 100% view (other software packages).

Reply
Feb 8, 2019 15:17:10   #
Bobspez Loc: Southern NJ, USA
 
Like others have said it is cropping or zooming into the pic until one pixel of image equals one pixel of monitor. This is also how much you can crop or magnify an image without seeing pixelation of the image on the screen. If you are still confused download and install the free image viewer Hornil Photo Viewer and set the magnification to 100%, or if you are in Photoshop, set the image size to 100% in the lower left corner of the frame.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 2
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.