Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Photo Gallery
Soliciting Opinions
Page <<first <prev 4 of 5 next>
Nov 11, 2018 14:21:06   #
rdrechsler Loc: Channel Islands Harbor, CA
 
NikonGal wrote:
I like the bikes as a graphic, but the jars as a soft color palette. I guess your choice will be what your portfolio needs, to show all your diversity. Good luck. Bev


All except the bicycles were shot during an all-day shoot along old Route 66 in the Victorville and Barstow areas. I wanted to include one of them to add diversity to my portfolio. Thanks for taking the time to comment.

Reply
Nov 11, 2018 14:27:24   #
rdrechsler Loc: Channel Islands Harbor, CA
 
Thanks to all of you for your wise and thoughtful comments. I agree with the majority that “Went Bankrup” is the strongest image to round out my portfolio. I’m going to go with that. The full portfolio isn’t due until December 12, so if I have some photo ops before that I might change my mind, but for now this is my decision.

Reply
Nov 11, 2018 14:40:30   #
Annie-Get-Your-Gun Loc: Byron Center, Mi
 
rdrechsler wrote:
I know there are no shortage of those around here....LOL. Seriously, I'm working on my portfolio for my class final (50% of the grade!) and I've selected 9 of the 10 required photographs. Now I'm down to the last one and I'm having a hard time. Would you kindly take a look and vote for your favorite? Thanks so much for your time.


It was a very long ride gets my vote.

Reply
 
 
Nov 11, 2018 15:26:17   #
wham121736 Loc: Long Island, New York
 
rdrechsler wrote:
I know there are no shortage of those around here....LOL. Seriously, I'm working on my portfolio for my class final (50% of the grade!) and I've selected 9 of the 10 required photographs. Now I'm down to the last one and I'm having a hard time. Would you kindly take a look and vote for your favorite? Thanks so much for your time.


Given that the subject is color and light I'd go with bankrupt. The composition is also a plus.

Reply
Nov 11, 2018 15:46:38   #
fourg1b2006 Loc: Long Island New York
 
I think i'll go with the bikes.

Reply
Nov 11, 2018 17:05:45   #
cambriaman Loc: Central CA Coast
 
Since the topic is color and light I vote for the bikes.
Otherwise, Bankrupt which I feel is too much of one color and not much light.

Reply
Nov 11, 2018 17:58:17   #
davidrb Loc: Half way there on the 45th Parallel
 
rdrechsler wrote:
I know there are no shortage of those around here....LOL. Seriously, I'm working on my portfolio for my class final (50% of the grade!) and I've selected 9 of the 10 required photographs. Now I'm down to the last one and I'm having a hard time. Would you kindly take a look and vote for your favorite? Thanks so much for your time.


"Went Bankrupt" tells the photographer's story very well, too well for many.

Reply
 
 
Nov 11, 2018 20:48:46   #
Brad Craig
 
It was a very long ride, no 5 picture is my favorite.

Reply
Nov 11, 2018 21:52:00   #
Pysanka Artist Loc: Rochester, NY
 
I love Went Bankrup, but I also like Metro Bike for the repetition and clear focus throughout.

Reply
Nov 11, 2018 22:58:26   #
pila
 
Color and light.
Bankrupt, perspective, texture, composition and color are cooking.

Reply
Nov 11, 2018 23:55:11   #
Real Nikon Lover Loc: Simi Valley, CA
 
Largobob wrote:
As an aside, I wonder whether your instructor has or would give you, an operational definition of EXACTLY what is being evaluated for your grade. Images are subjective....as evidenced by the varying opinions given here. I find each of your images pleasing....but for different reasons. If there is no "metric" being applied to evaluate your work....I would suggest this is simply malpractice....as is quite typical amongst University professors. As a professor, I would be much more interested in hosting a round-table open discussion of each image (by each student)....and I would listen more to the quality of critical thinking (articulation, communication, depth/breadth) going on between each participant, than to the quality of the images themselves.

A better learning tool might be to have been given a well-developed rubric....showing the different levels of "goodness" and WHY (clearly defined and with measurable criteria). IMHO, too often an instructor says, "go off and do good things" without ever CLEARLY defining what a good thing looks (acts, smells, tastes, or feels) like. This happens in schools, at all levels, across the country....every single day. That's no way to teach and it certainly is no way to learn!

Only a well-defined standard can be measured. PS: Don't tell your instructor any of this or you will reap the wrath of the "full professor" with tenure.
As an aside, I wonder whether your instructor has ... (show quote)


Largobob I couldn't agree more. Well said. Although some do not like the dragon, I do because of the color pop. However I do like the BANKRUPT photo as well.

Reply
 
 
Nov 12, 2018 00:35:19   #
Mr. Fuzzy
 
I like your perspective in "went bankrup". As for myself, I see that some have made color or lack of comments, I am 90% colorblind so I definitely see things differently than most people. Because of being colorblind I am NOT a fan of the retouching of pictures, I understand why it is done, but I find that the vast majority of retouching ends up looking plastic. So for my eyes, the colors in "went bankrup" are perfect.

Reply
Nov 12, 2018 02:24:41   #
Shootist Loc: Wyoming
 
Curious Curios caught my attention. Although it is not "bright and pretty" like the others, it evokes an image in my mind. A lonely cowpoke settling into a line cabin for the winter and opening this cupboard. I suspect the language that followed would not be appropriate for Sunday School.
rdrechsler wrote:
I know there are no shortage of those around here....LOL. Seriously, I'm working on my portfolio for my class final (50% of the grade!) and I've selected 9 of the 10 required photographs. Now I'm down to the last one and I'm having a hard time. Would you kindly take a look and vote for your favorite? Thanks so much for your time.

Reply
Nov 12, 2018 09:39:27   #
Ed Commons
 
Definitely the bikes

Reply
Nov 12, 2018 10:21:54   #
cheineck Loc: Hobe Sound, FL
 
The bikes or Curious Curios.

Reply
Page <<first <prev 4 of 5 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Photo Gallery
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.