Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Manfrotto pro190 tripod creep
Page 1 of 2 next>
Apr 20, 2019 12:27:32   #
JBGLADSTONE Loc: Oregon
 
Hi All, first time posting and years of reading.

I have noticed my manfrotto tripod creeps at various angles. I locked the various lock down knobs but still movement. Oh I do know if the wife walks across the floor I will have creep/movement.
I mainly noticed this when I zoom in for manual focus in the live view on my Canon 80D. I think I now know why some my photos are soft.
Now I have taken my old Bogen tripod with a 3025 head, cleaned the various arms and adjusted the legs for pinch. No movement but a heavy tripod compared to the Manfrotto.

Help

Reply
Apr 20, 2019 12:45:34   #
MT Shooter Loc: Montana
 
JBGLADSTONE wrote:
Hi All, first time posting and years of reading.

I have noticed my manfrotto tripod creeps at various angles. I locked the various lock down knobs but still movement. Oh I do know if the wife walks across the floor I will have creep/movement.
I mainly noticed this when I zoom in for manual focus in the live view on my Canon 80D. I think I now know why some my photos are soft.
Now I have taken my old Bogen tripod with a 3025 head, cleaned the various arms and adjusted the legs for pinch. No movement but a heavy tripod compared to the Manfrotto.

Help
Hi All, first time posting and years of reading. b... (show quote)


What is creeping? The 190 is a set of legs, are the leg locks loose? Or is your head slipping? What is the head if that is the case?

Reply
Apr 20, 2019 21:02:22   #
kskarma Loc: Topeka, KS
 
While I have a 190, I've never had this problem. In looking at the leg clamps on mine just now, it would seem that tightening the small nut on the back side of the locking lever would increase the clamping force. Those nuts look like 'locking nuts', the kind with nylon inserts, (I think NYLOCK is a trade name for some of these).. usually they need some extra 'oooomph..'technical term', to break them loose as they are meant to not work themselves loose. This does NOT mean that a previous owner?...or time?...has not loosened them. Also...be aware that some manufacturers will put a small drop of Locktite in applications like this, so approach this task with plenty of caution....and NOT a lot of brute force, you sure don't want to break anything in this area...(Although, worst case....Manfrotto DOES have parts for all of their products...!)
I'd recommend that you try to determine which leg...and which tube/lock, is slipping before you take ANY
action. Putting a small mark with a Sharpie on the legs when they are extended would give you some
direction in this.

Post your findings and results, please?

Reply
 
 
Apr 20, 2019 21:33:54   #
JBGLADSTONE Loc: Oregon
 
MT Shooter wrote:
What is creeping? The 190 is a set of legs, are the leg locks loose? Or is your head slipping? What is the head if that is the case?


I am not sure where the creeping coming from. I Really tighten the ball head arm. I checked the legs, however, the legs could be the issue.
One clarifying statement. Is the Live View kinda moves in a upward movement with a slight angle. The next time it will be going down.

I agree I need to investigate but was just wondering if anyone else has had this problem.

Thanks

Reply
Apr 20, 2019 22:18:40   #
kskarma Loc: Topeka, KS
 
A good way to isolate your problem would be to remove the ball head, then extend and tighten the legs with your tripod on a firm surface. If you place your hand on the head, you should NOT be able to wiggle it around...and you SHOULD be able to apply a goodly amount of force in the downward direction without feeling any slippage at all...
If the tripod is rock solid through all of these tests, your problem would logically be in the ball head... It might help us if we knew which ball head you are using...and introducing "Live View" into this does not really help to isolate things. First thing you need to do...is to get your camera/head/tripod to the point where it is solid when taking a conventional photo...then work on getting it steady for a time exposure..

Reply
Apr 20, 2019 22:46:07   #
RWR Loc: La Mesa, CA
 
JBGLADSTONE wrote:
I Really tighten the ball head arm.

Ball head arm??
You should not have to apply excessive pressure anywhere on a tripod or head.

Reply
Apr 21, 2019 00:44:33   #
JBGLADSTONE Loc: Oregon
 
The Manfrotto tripod is MK 190xPro3 with 494 ball head.

Reply
 
 
Apr 21, 2019 06:20:16   #
John Gavin
 
Does the tripod have a center arm that goes up and down? Also it would seem arbitrary where the lens is pointed when just putting a camera on a tripod so maybe position a leg at a target like a tree and then set the camera in live view aimed at the tree and see what happens then repeat for the other two legs. Just my 2 cents.

Reply
Apr 21, 2019 06:25:01   #
queencitysanta Loc: Charlotte, North Carolina
 
Look at the nest 468? from Carter's Canera Cottage Web Store
My Cart: 0 items
All Products / Nest NT-648H Ball Head
SALE
Share

Nest NT-648H Ball Head
$129.95 $169.95

An oil-less ball head with 55# capacity featuring an ARCA "slide-in", high security type Quick Release system that is now fully Arca-Swiss compatible. (The adjustable jaw opens wide enough for ARCA plate "drop-in" installation as well as the Nest "slide-in" plates.) Full ball release with one lever featuring front and back grooving for 180 degree articulation, as well as adjustable friction control.

This head also offers separate base panning control so you are able to pan the head without releasing the ball.

An amazing price for a ball head of this capacity and value!

FREE SHIPPING IF PURCHASED WITH A TRIPOD!

Add to Cart
WHEN IN DOUBT, SHOOT IT AGAIN!!!

Reply
Apr 21, 2019 06:52:56   #
jerryc41 Loc: Catskill Mts of NY
 
JBGLADSTONE wrote:
Oh I do know if the wife walks across the floor I will have creep/movement.


If the tripod is following your wife, "creep" is definitely the right term.

You mean the head is letting the camera droop a bit, right? That's not an uncommon problem.

Very good article linked below. It seems that your problem can be solved easily - with money!

http://www.dslrbodies.com/accessories/camera-accessories/tripod-101.html

Reply
Apr 21, 2019 07:25:06   #
Architect1776 Loc: In my mind
 
JBGLADSTONE wrote:
Hi All, first time posting and years of reading.

I have noticed my manfrotto tripod creeps at various angles. I locked the various lock down knobs but still movement. Oh I do know if the wife walks across the floor I will have creep/movement.
I mainly noticed this when I zoom in for manual focus in the live view on my Canon 80D. I think I now know why some my photos are soft.
Now I have taken my old Bogen tripod with a 3025 head, cleaned the various arms and adjusted the legs for pinch. No movement but a heavy tripod compared to the Manfrotto.

Help
Hi All, first time posting and years of reading. b... (show quote)


I have the 190 and never any "Creep".
I use a 7D and a 100-400mm MII on it all the time, also many times with a bellows and 7D with a lens.
The bellows combo is quite heavy and I extend the center column and turn it sideways for closeups and no "Creep".


(Download)

Reply
 
 
Apr 21, 2019 10:41:25   #
BartHx
 
JBGLADSTONE wrote:
The Manfrotto tripod is MK 190xPro3 with 494 ball head.


I purchased that exact model Manfrotto tripod, but with a different head. It came with a tool specifically to adjust the tension in the leg clamps. If the problem turns out to be slippage in the legs and you no longer have that tool, I expect you can easily get a replacement from Manfrotto. Since it is simply a Torx drive, you should also be able to get one from your local hardware store. My guess is that Manfrotto expects that the tension might periodically need to be adjusted or they would not supply the tool with the tripod.

Reply
Apr 21, 2019 13:27:20   #
JBGLADSTONE Loc: Oregon
 
Thanks everyone.
I will follow all ideas and solutions
Happy Easter

Reply
Apr 21, 2019 14:32:58   #
RRS Loc: Not sure
 
JBGLADSTONE wrote:
Hi All, first time posting and years of reading.

I have noticed my manfrotto tripod creeps at various angles. I locked the various lock down knobs but still movement. Oh I do know if the wife walks across the floor I will have creep/movement.
I mainly noticed this when I zoom in for manual focus in the live view on my Canon 80D. I think I now know why some my photos are soft.
Now I have taken my old Bogen tripod with a 3025 head, cleaned the various arms and adjusted the legs for pinch. No movement but a heavy tripod compared to the Manfrotto.

Help
Hi All, first time posting and years of reading. b... (show quote)


Do you have your tripod set up on a floor with a carpet? Are you talking creep or just movement while looking at the screen while in live view. What kind of clamp are you using on the ball head and do you have an "L" clamp on the camera. If you have a second camera maybe you could send a picture of how you are setting up. Good luck.

Reply
Apr 21, 2019 14:35:14   #
RRS Loc: Not sure
 
Architect1776 wrote:
I have the 190 and never any "Creep".
I use a 7D and a 100-400mm MII on it all the time, also many times with a bellows and 7D with a lens.
The bellows combo is quite heavy and I extend the center column and turn it sideways for closeups and no "Creep".


Nice set up!

Reply
Page 1 of 2 next>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.