Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Lens Adapters vs Extension Tubes
Page <prev 2 of 2
Jun 28, 2022 07:29:18   #
Grey Ghost
 
JW from PA wrote:
My question concerns Adapters vs Extension Tubes:
If an extension tube is used to aloud a lenses to focus closer for macro photography, does an adapter have the same effect on the lenses. Example #1: If I were to buy a Sony Full Frame Camera (A7RIII) and use all my Canon EF lenses instead of buying all new Sony lenses, what effect would that have on light entering the camera? F stops, SS, and ISO. Example #2: If I bought a Canon R6 or R5 and used an adapter for my EF lenses, what effect would that have on the light entering the camera? F stops, SS and ISO.

I hope I explained my question so its understandable, if not I am sorry.

Thanks in advance for your replies.

Joe W.
My question concerns Adapters vs Extension Tubes: ... (show quote)


If you are pleased with the result then it probably makes no difference!

Reply
Jun 28, 2022 08:42:12   #
fetzler Loc: North West PA
 
JW from PA wrote:
My question concerns Adapters vs Extension Tubes:
If an extension tube is used to aloud a lenses to focus closer for macro photography, does an adapter have the same effect on the lenses. Example #1: If I were to buy a Sony Full Frame Camera (A7RIII) and use all my Canon EF lenses instead of buying all new Sony lenses, what effect would that have on light entering the camera? F stops, SS, and ISO. Example #2: If I bought a Canon R6 or R5 and used an adapter for my EF lenses, what effect would that have on the light entering the camera? F stops, SS and ISO.

I hope I explained my question so its understandable, if not I am sorry.

Thanks in advance for your replies.

Joe W.
My question concerns Adapters vs Extension Tubes: ... (show quote)


Extension tubes and adapters are two different things and serve different purposes.

1. An lens mount adapter allows one to mount a lens for Camera manufacturer A onto a camera body made by manufacturer B. This is easy to do for mounting DSLR lenses onto mirrorless camera bodies as the mount to sensor distance is greater for a DSLR camera. Generally adapters allow the DSLR lens to be used manually but there are a few exceptions. An adapter for Nikon DSLR to Nikon mirrorless usually retains all lens functions. Most often the adapted lens will focus at infinity.

2. Extension tubes extend the lens further from the sensor in order to increase image magnification for macro work. Extension tubes have the same type of mount on both ends. Extension tubes can be manual or automatic.
The latter allow for the retention of all lens functions. It will not be possible to focus at infinity with extension tubes attached.

3. Extension tubes reduce the effective aperture. Adapters do not change the effective effective aperture. If you have a speed booster in the adapter then the Image circle diameter is reduced and the effective aperture is increased.

Reply
Jun 28, 2022 10:20:26   #
olemikey Loc: 6 mile creek, Spacecoast Florida
 
JW from PA wrote:
My question concerns Adapters vs Extension Tubes:
If an extension tube is used to aloud a lenses to focus closer for macro photography, does an adapter have the same effect on the lenses. Example #1: If I were to buy a Sony Full Frame Camera (A7RIII) and use all my Canon EF lenses instead of buying all new Sony lenses, what effect would that have on light entering the camera? F stops, SS, and ISO. Example #2: If I bought a Canon R6 or R5 and used an adapter for my EF lenses, what effect would that have on the light entering the camera? F stops, SS and ISO.

I hope I explained my question so its understandable, if not I am sorry.

Thanks in advance for your replies.

Joe W.
My question concerns Adapters vs Extension Tubes: ... (show quote)


I use both.... I've found extension tubes paired with large/long lens to be excellent when shooting from relatively close (from a blind) for small birds, and for macro of course... I use adapters to mate a number of different lenses (brands/types) to Sony/Nikon/Canon bodies. Some are better than others....I want AF, VR and aperture control in any I use, which is limiting... full manual adapters are ok in a pinch.

Reply
 
 
Jun 28, 2022 20:01:58   #
Dennis833 Loc: Australia
 
I have two cheap Commlite adapters and an EF extension tube. Both work well with EF lenses on my Sony A7R111.
AF is very quick but sometimes I have to pre manual focus my 400mm a bit first. One thing to mention is that EF lenses remain fully open until the exposure. I actually find this useful when shooting two images that are going to be stitched together. I can AF on two different focus points very quickly.

Reply
Mar 27, 2023 10:16:55   #
Architect1776 Loc: In my mind
 
JW from PA wrote:
My question concerns Adapters vs Extension Tubes:
If an extension tube is used to aloud a lenses to focus closer for macro photography, does an adapter have the same effect on the lenses. Example #1: If I were to buy a Sony Full Frame Camera (A7RIII) and use all my Canon EF lenses instead of buying all new Sony lenses, what effect would that have on light entering the camera? F stops, SS, and ISO. Example #2: If I bought a Canon R6 or R5 and used an adapter for my EF lenses, what effect would that have on the light entering the camera? F stops, SS and ISO.

I hope I explained my question so its understandable, if not I am sorry.

Thanks in advance for your replies.

Joe W.
My question concerns Adapters vs Extension Tubes: ... (show quote)


No change at all as the lenses are designed to be a certain distance from the sensor.
Once you exceed the designed distance then there is falloff.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 2
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.