Comparing 3 Apparently Identical Tilt-Shift Lenses: Can anyone identify whether the following f/3.5 24mm tilt-shift lenses are in any way different?

DWU2 Loc: Phoenix Arizona area

Can anyone identify whether the following f/3.5 24mm tilt-shift lenses are in any way different?

- Bower SLY24TSC 24mm f/3.5 ($649.99)
- Samyang Tilt-Shift SYTS24-C 24mm f/3.5 ($729)
- Rokinon TSL24M-C 24mm f/3.5 ($799)

They appear to be of identical appearance. Do they differ regarding glass quality, warranty, or in other ways? Or, are they just 3 different labels of the same lens?

DWU2 Loc: Phoenix Arizona area

DWU2 wrote:

Can anyone identify whether the following f/3.5 24mm tilt-shift lenses are in any way different?

- Bower SLY24TSC 24mm f/3.5 ($649.99)
- Samyang Tilt-Shift SYTS24-C 24mm f/3.5 ($729)
- Rokinon TSL24M-C 24mm f/3.5 ($799)

They appear to be of identical appearance. Do they differ regarding glass quality, warranty, or in other ways? Or, are they just 3 different labels of the same lens?

Oh, by they way, here are links to them on Amazon:

Bower: https://www.amazon.com/Bower-SLY24TSC-24mm-Tilt-Shift-Canon/dp/B00DJ324T0/ref=sr_1_38?dchild=1&keywords=tilt-shift+lens+for+canon&qid=1611683913&sr=8-38

Samyang: https://www.amazon.com/Samyang-Tilt-Shift-SYTS24-C-Shift-Canon/dp/B00CMB87IC/ref=sr_1_4?dchild=1&keywords=tilt-shift+lens+for+canon&qid=1611683913&sr=8-4

Rokinon: https://www.amazon.com/Rokinon-TSL24M-C-Shift-Fixed-Canon/dp/B00BPOF0C8/ref=sr_1_7?dchild=1&keywords=tilt-shift+lens+for+canon&qid=1611683913&sr=8-7

Ourspolair

I believe that they are just re-badged versions of the same lens.

DWU2 Loc: Phoenix Arizona area

Ourspolair wrote:

I believe that they are just re-badged versions of the same lens.

That's my take, too, but maybe I'm missing some key point.

PixelStan77 Loc: Vermont/Chicago

Ourspolair wrote:

I believe that they are just re-badged versions of the same lens.

I believe you are correct from my understanding.

Pablo8 Loc: Nottingham UK.

DWU2 wrote:

Can anyone identify whether the following f/3.5 24mm tilt-shift lenses are in any way different?

- Bower SLY24TSC 24mm f/3.5 ($649.99)
- Samyang Tilt-Shift SYTS24-C 24mm f/3.5 ($729)
- Rokinon TSL24M-C 24mm f/3.5 ($799)

They appear to be of identical appearance. Do they differ regarding glass quality, warranty, or in other ways? Or, are they just 3 different labels of the same lens?

I would say that the Rokinon is the better (Best) lens, as it costs more than the others.!! s that lateral thinking??

kymarto Loc: Portland OR and Milan Italy

They are identical except for the branding.