Which flash to buy?
Apr 20, 2019 12:16:44 #
Stupidly, I left my Nikon SB-910 flash unit in a rental car and didn’t realize it until I returned the car and flew a thousand miles away. So my question for this wonderfully experienced group is: Which flash would you recommend I purchase for its replacement? I am not a pro, but shoot with a Nikon D750 body and the Nikon 24-120mm VR, Nikon 24-70mm f2.8 non-VR and the newest Nikon 70-200mm f2.8 VR lenses. I do not use multiple flash setups (yet). I am mostly a “Nikon” guy, but am open to other quality brands. I have been happy with the SB 910 and could replace it with a used one, but don’t know what I would be giving up by sticking with the “old” technology. What do you recommend?
Apr 20, 2019 12:31:25 #
If you want the best flash - fully front/rear sync, TTL and HSS compatible look at the Metz line. They are a little cheaper than Nikon for the same guide number, superior quality compared to Nikon (by a good deal) and fully compatible. I have the Metz AF 64 which is their top model, Very nice unit that I prefer over the Nikon Speedlights. Metz has been making flash'es for much longer than Nikon and is the gold standard - and one of the only commpanies that do not manufacture in China - their products are manufactured in Germany with all the advantages that entails.
Another brand to look at is Profoto - also very good units but more expensive than Metz and Nikon. From what you write, I would not go with Profoto.
Another brand to look at is Profoto - also very good units but more expensive than Metz and Nikon. From what you write, I would not go with Profoto.
Apr 20, 2019 12:51:57 #
I use Yongnuo, they make flashes designed just for Canon or Nikon and others - in fact they seem to be clones of those brands flashes.
https://yongnuousa.net/ this is one of the largest importer, they are also on Ebay and Amazon
go to their homepage and under "shop" click on Nikon Compatible Items - they even make lenses for Nikon. Their top end flash for Nikon has a guide number of 60 and does high speed sync. etc, plus has an LED for short range video or constant lighting
Their yn568ex seems to be their match for the SB-910 but they now have newer more advanced models that work with Nikon.
One reviewer said that they are inexpensive enough you can replace them for less than repair prices for the OEM brand flashes.
https://yongnuousa.net/ this is one of the largest importer, they are also on Ebay and Amazon
go to their homepage and under "shop" click on Nikon Compatible Items - they even make lenses for Nikon. Their top end flash for Nikon has a guide number of 60 and does high speed sync. etc, plus has an LED for short range video or constant lighting
Their yn568ex seems to be their match for the SB-910 but they now have newer more advanced models that work with Nikon.
One reviewer said that they are inexpensive enough you can replace them for less than repair prices for the OEM brand flashes.
Apr 20, 2019 13:42:06 #
romanmel7 wrote:
Stupidly, I left my Nikon SB-910 flash unit in a r... (show quote)
Did you try calling the rental car company to see if your flash was turned in? There are some surprisingly honest people in the world. Otherwise, stick with the SB-910 model you already know how to use and whose results you like.
Apr 20, 2019 17:03:37 #
rjaywallace wrote:
Did you try calling the rental car company to see if your flash was turned in? There are some surprisingly honest people in the world. Otherwise, stick with the SB-910 model you already know how to use and whose results you like.
I agree with Ralph. Your flash may be in their lost and found. I would stick with what you had and know how to use it.
Apr 20, 2019 17:03:38 #
romanmel7 wrote:
Stupidly, I left my Nikon SB-910 flash unit in a r... (show quote)
I don't think you gain much if you were to buy the newer SB-5000. So another SB-910 is a good choice in my opinion. Did you contact the rental car company and see if they found your flash?
Apr 20, 2019 18:34:26 #
Thanks, folks. I did contact the rental company and there was an “electronic item and case” reported found and tagged. Unfortunately, I can’t contact anyone at the airport office until Monday morning, so I’m not quite sure if I’m in luck or not. Have to admit that a bit of a GAS attack just may be in play here too, so in case I need a new flash, I am asking those in the know, how to best spend my money.
Apr 20, 2019 19:19:09 #
romanmel7 wrote:
Thanks, folks. I did contact the rental company and there was an “electronic item and case” reported found and tagged. Unfortunately, I can’t contact anyone at the airport office until Monday morning, so I’m not quite sure if I’m in luck or not. Have to admit that a bit of a GAS attack just may be in play here too, so in case I need a new flash, I am asking those in the know, how to best spend my money.
Be patient and let the GAS attack pass.
Apr 20, 2019 21:34:42 #
[quote=romanmel7]Thanks, folks. I did contact the rental company and there was an “electronic item and case” reported found and tagged. Unfortunately, I can’t contact anyone at the airport office until Monday morning, so I’m not quite sure if I’m in luck or not. Have to admit that a bit of a GAS attack just may be in play here too, so in case I need a new flash, I am asking those in the know, how to best spend my money.[/quote
The finance gurus say that for most small items cash is best. That way you really feel the money going. Plastic is just numbers.
I just couldn't resist that.
My second choice is send the money to me and I will spend it for you. Oh, that is so bad, I need a time out.
The finance gurus say that for most small items cash is best. That way you really feel the money going. Plastic is just numbers. I just couldn't resist that.
My second choice is send the money to me and I will spend it for you. Oh, that is so bad, I need a time out.
Apr 20, 2019 23:28:13 #
romanmel7 wrote:
If you really liked the 910, then I do not see a reason not to replace it with the same unit, unless you want to go with the 5000 series to go radio controlled! The 910 is an awesome flash!Stupidly, I left my Nikon SB-910 flash unit in a r... (show quote)
Apr 20, 2019 23:43:14 #
speters wrote:
If you really liked the 910, then I do not see a reason not to replace it with the same unit, unless you want to go with the 5000 series to go radio controlled! The 910 is an awesome flash!
Thanks, all. Seems like technology hasn’t really improved much upon what I had. Radio control would be nice, if I ever decide to up my flash techniques, and a little less weight and bulk would be nice too, but for now, hopefully my flash gets returned or I will simply replace it with a used one (KEH seemed to have an assortment available for fair prices).
Apr 21, 2019 00:51:34 #
"...Radio control would be nice..." romanmel7 I use a Phottix Odin transmitter and receivers with my SB910s... This takes my illumination scenarios entirely to the next level... I regularly shoot at 1/2000 especially with a cluster of flashes... these work with the SB700 and many of the SB910 clones... their range is further than you'll ever likely be shooting... Hope this helps or is at least food for thought
And your lost SB910 is in my thoughts and prayers romanmel7... Yes there are so many honest and thoughtful folks thus I trust and hope for a wonderful outcome here... all the best on your journey...
And your lost SB910 is in my thoughts and prayers romanmel7... Yes there are so many honest and thoughtful folks thus I trust and hope for a wonderful outcome here... all the best on your journey...
Apr 21, 2019 06:58:26 #
rjaywallace wrote:
Did you try calling the rental car company to see if your flash was turned in? There are some surprisingly honest people in the world. Otherwise, stick with the SB-910 model you already know how to use and whose results you like.
I totally agree. I loved the sb910 when I had Nikon. And heartily agree that there are still some honest people out there. The key is to CALL them and try to get directly to the management of the location where you rented.
Apr 21, 2019 07:08:02 #
Apr 21, 2019 07:29:14 #
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.