Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Main Photography Discussion
Do you trust Amazon reviews?
Page <prev 2 of 8 next> last>>
Sep 14, 2018 06:24:56   #
yssirk123 Loc: New Jersey
 
I use Fakespot.com or Reviewmeta.com to check whether the Amazon reviews are fake - both seem to work well.

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 06:53:08   #
TJBNovember Loc: Long Island, New York
 
GrandmaG wrote:
I need a spare memory card for my Sony a7iii and wanted one large enough for video. Currently, I have a 32 GB Lexar SD II U3 150MB/s. I was considering another Lexar card, but twice the size. EVERY review on EVERY card has a reviewer that says something like, "Don't buy this card" or "It's a fake" or " the card failed in the middle of a shoot". etc. Also, hardly any of them show the back of the card, except for the Transcend card (TS64GSD2U3). Both cards are on the Sony recommended list. What say you?
I need a spare memory card for my Sony a7iii and w... (show quote)


Is it a card sold by Amazon or one of their "Partners", or one of the "not sold or supplied by Amazon", listed sellers? That could be their issue with this particular card. Sometimes looking for the best price can lead you to not the best item. In general if there are sufficient number of reviews yes. With a memory card if there are not many dozens or hundreds of reviews, I'd stay away from that seller or item.

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 07:31:13   #
ggenova64
 
I started out using SanDisk / Lexar and then switched to SanDisk when Lexar was bought by Micron.

Reply
 
 
Sep 14, 2018 07:45:38   #
mgoldfield
 
GrandmaG wrote:
I need a spare memory card for my Sony a7iii and wanted one large enough for video. Currently, I have a 32 GB Lexar SD II U3 150MB/s. I was considering another Lexar card, but twice the size. EVERY review on EVERY card has a reviewer that says something like, "Don't buy this card" or "It's a fake" or " the card failed in the middle of a shoot". etc. Also, hardly any of them show the back of the card, except for the Transcend card (TS64GSD2U3). Both cards are on the Sony recommended list. What say you?
I need a spare memory card for my Sony a7iii and w... (show quote)


There is a solution; here is a very reliable source of information on SD cards:

https://www.cameramemoryspeed.com

M. Goldfield

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 07:49:21   #
f8lee Loc: New Mexico
 
Well, for amusement there is nothing quite like the Amazon reviews on the Sigma 200-500 f2.8 lens - lots of those will make you chuckle

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 07:52:11   #
mizzee Loc: Boston,Ma
 
I trust the reviews on B&H for the most part. I generally look at how many reviews there are and how many in each rating. I also ask. The folks at B&H are wonderful as are the folks at Hunt's, knowledgeable and they won't sell you what you don't need.

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 08:08:36   #
dsmeltz Loc: Philadelphia
 
I do buy from Amazon and occasionally submit a review. But user reviews are too self-selected. For reviews I go to reliable review sites for a given product category.

Reply
 
 
Sep 14, 2018 08:12:57   #
jerryc41 Loc: Catskill Mts of NY
 
GrandmaG wrote:
I need a spare memory card for my Sony a7iii and wanted one large enough for video. Currently, I have a 32 GB Lexar SD II U3 150MB/s. I was considering another Lexar card, but twice the size. EVERY review on EVERY card has a reviewer that says something like, "Don't buy this card" or "It's a fake" or " the card failed in the middle of a shoot". etc. Also, hardly any of them show the back of the card, except for the Transcend card (TS64GSD2U3). Both cards are on the Sony recommended list. What say you?
I need a spare memory card for my Sony a7iii and w... (show quote)


If it's really every review on every card, why take a chance? When I check Amazon reviews, I look at the chart showing the spread of good and bad. If there are a lot of bad reviews, I look elsewhere. Sometimes, I just take a chance. For example, I wanted a string of blinking LEDs. Many reviews said they failed almost immediately. I took a chance and bought a set of four. Two worked, and two didn't, so for the price, I was satisfied with the 50% failure rate.

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 08:18:07   #
Tjohn Loc: Inverness, FL formerly Arivaca, AZ
 
No.

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 08:19:07   #
Country Boy Loc: Beckley, WV
 
In general I do trust Amazon reviews but where there are multiple brands and the reviewer only purchased one brand and that is all they can speak to their recommendations are questionable. You need to read the comments to get an idea of the expectations of the reviewer. As said before, some people give negative comments on something the item is not designed to perform.

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 08:22:23   #
Stephan G
 
GrandmaG wrote:
I need a spare memory card for my Sony a7iii and wanted one large enough for video. Currently, I have a 32 GB Lexar SD II U3 150MB/s. I was considering another Lexar card, but twice the size. EVERY review on EVERY card has a reviewer that says something like, "Don't buy this card" or "It's a fake" or " the card failed in the middle of a shoot". etc. Also, hardly any of them show the back of the card, except for the Transcend card (TS64GSD2U3). Both cards are on the Sony recommended list. What say you?
I need a spare memory card for my Sony a7iii and w... (show quote)


I do not trust any reviews on any store guides, good or bad. Overall, they are insufficient and deficient. I used to go to tech magazines to get an idea for what I need to look. But these sources are drying up. Now, I can't even touch the product at the store to at least read the cards.

I agree that you will have to contact some one who has proven reliable.

Reply
 
 
Sep 14, 2018 08:28:31   #
Strofam
 
I am finding the Amazon ratings more and more are a factor of cost instead of quality/functionality. If an item is cheap it gets better reviews than a more costly one. Although cost is a concern, I am first interested in functionality. After I find the item that does what I want it to, then I start shopping for price. The average reviews don't always support this and sometimes not at all. You need to read them carefully.

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 08:29:23   #
gwilliams6
 
zug55 wrote:
I think that Amazon reviews are helpful if you learn how to read them. There are several ways you can make them work for you.

First, the numbers game. If there are fewer than ten reviews, the average rating means little. If you have 100+ reviews there are enough reviews to neutralize the paid enthusiasts and professional trolls. (Perhaps this is an oxymoron?) Also look at the distribution. If there is a broad consensus with just a few outliers ignore those. (I hate sliced bread.)

Look out for folks who don't get the full picture and go off on a tangent. There are lots of folks who give one star to outstanding products just because they are really unhappy with one minor aspect. For instance, there are folks who gave the Sony A7 III a one-star rating because it does not come with an external battery charger. Okay, it annoyed me too, but it is minor nuisance rather than a major product flaw.

Then there are the short, non-specific reviews. "This lens sucks." "The box arrived damaged." "Don't buy this card." "Awesome product." Unless a justification is offered just ignore. There is a good chance that these reviewers are posting for reasons other than providing a service to potential future users--you.

Then there are folks who give overly enthusiastic reviews. People buy a camera and then become unable so see its shortcomings, as if this would be an admission of a clouded judgement or of a bad investment (which sometimes this is). So they write enthusiastic reviews because they want to emotionally protect their investment. We see a version of this on UHH from the mirrorless haters. They declare mirrorless a passing fad while holding on to their DSLR tanks as if it was a sinking ship. (Well, it is. I just had to say this to make my point.)

So what should you read? Look for reviews that offer specific details for why or why not they like a product. Look for differentiated arguments--folks who talk about the good and the bad. Look for reviews who address the core functioning of a product, not just the color of the box. Look for people who take time to explain things in language you can understand.
I think that Amazon reviews are helpful if you lea... (show quote)


Excellent post zug55. As one longtime Amazon customer who has personally written many honest reviews for products I have bought over the years, your advice is sound. As a Sony A7III and A7RIII owner and longtime pro shooter, I use Lexar Professional 128GB, Sony 128 GB, and Sandisk 128 and 64 GB cards, both UHS-1 (150 mbps write speed) and UHS-II cards (300 mbps write speed) . I buy from Amazon, B&H and Adorama. Never had an issues with SD cards bought from these three retailers. Thanks

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 08:30:21   #
Nikon1201
 
I buy directly from Sandisk

Reply
Sep 14, 2018 08:31:14   #
GrandmaG Loc: Flat Rock, MI
 
pentaxion wrote:
Not if you turn it over.


Oh sure...that makes sense...hold the camera upside down...lol

It just feels backward. Every other camera I have owned, the main card was on top. This is not a complaint, mind you.

Reply
Page <prev 2 of 8 next> last>>
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Main Photography Discussion
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.