Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Links and Resources
Photographer Rights vs. Public's Right to Not Be Photographed. Photographers 2, Public 0.
Oct 13, 2014 16:19:54   #
gessman Loc: Colorado
 
In case you missed it, there has just been another court case regarding photographer's rights vs. a right to not be photographed and the photographer, although perhaps despicible, won: http://huff.to/1suqGsf

This article was noted earlier in uhh but along those same lines there was another case that may have not come to everyone's attention. A photographer used his hi-rise condo as a perch to shoot his neighbors inside their condos/apartments and sell the pictures. Another case where the photographer, again, although perhaps despicible, won: http://www.ibtimes.com/arne-svenson-photographer-who-spied-tribeca-neighbors-wins-legal-battle-privacy-court-case-1374381

Reply
Oct 14, 2014 09:15:06   #
Jack47 Loc: Ontario
 
Ah!!! The good old US of A!!!!

Reply
Oct 14, 2014 09:36:47   #
YoungEsqr Loc: Minnesota
 
This reminds me of a case where the judge was ruling on what was "lewd and lascivious". The judge was asked to define lewd and lascivious. He said, "I can't define it. But I know it when I see it."
This area of the law, like so many areas of the law is new and continues to evolve. Photographer's Rights, like Privacy Rights, are not casted in stone and the judge will KNOW WHO'S RIGHTS HAVE BEEN VIOLATED DEPENDING ON THE CIRCUMSTANCES.
I remember years ago when I went to Mexico and went sightseeing at the pyramids outside of Mexico City. A person, and mostly men, could stand at the bottom and look up to see lots of women climbing with skirts and dresses. It was very steep and some were even taking pictures of the women. I didn't witness any police or any arrests, but some men have been hounds since the beginning of time.
I've also been to a nude beach in Maui, where a photographer was taking pictures of unsuspecting women laying down or bending over. He had his expensive camera snatched from him and thrown in the ocean by several men that caught him.
Nude beaches are illegal in Hawaii and this photographer wasn't breaking any law. But you go to a nude beach and start taking pictures of people and see what happens. See if you can cry about your rights versus right to privacy. Let me know what happens. LOL

Reply
 
 
Oct 14, 2014 12:27:07   #
mremery Loc: From Maine, living in Virginia
 
Unfortunately, it seems like there is a separation between legal and moral understanding. While what the "gentleman" was doing was morally wrong, it wasn't illegal.

Reply
Oct 14, 2014 12:38:30   #
Marionsho Loc: Kansas
 
YoungEsqr wrote:
This reminds me of a case where the judge was ruling on what was "lewd and lascivious". The judge was asked to define lewd and lascivious. He said, "I can't define it. But I know it when I see it."
This area of the law, like so many areas of the law is new and continues to evolve. Photographer's Rights, like Privacy Rights, are not casted in stone and the judge will KNOW WHO'S RIGHTS HAVE BEEN VIOLATED DEPENDING ON THE CIRCUMSTANCES.
I remember years ago when I went to Mexico and went sightseeing at the pyramids outside of Mexico City. A person, and mostly men, could stand at the bottom and look up to see lots of women climbing with skirts and dresses. It was very steep and some were even taking pictures of the women. I didn't witness any police or any arrests, but some men have been hounds since the beginning of time.
I've also been to a nude beach in Maui, where a photographer was taking pictures of unsuspecting women laying down or bending over. He had his expensive camera snatched from him and thrown in the ocean by several men that caught him.
Nude beaches are illegal in Hawaii and this photographer wasn't breaking any law. But you go to a nude beach and start taking pictures of people and see what happens. See if you can cry about your rights versus right to privacy. Let me know what happens. LOL
This reminds me of a case where the judge was ruli... (show quote)


Makes me want a set of glasses that, discreetly, records video. :lol:

Reply
Oct 14, 2014 12:44:16   #
YoungEsqr Loc: Minnesota
 
Good luck with that, also. ;)

Reply
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Links and Resources
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.