Ugly Hedgehog - Photography Forum
Home Active Topics Newest Pictures Search Login Register
Photo Analysis
Depth Perception
Jun 21, 2017 08:41:35   #
melueth Loc: Central Florida
 
Hey all - just came back from a neat trip to the Berkshires to try my hand at some waterfall photography. I learned a great deal, but am still a little baffled by this geological dilemma. The rock face that obscures a part of the waterfall below is a pretty fair distance from the actual falling water, but it doesn't look that way in any of my shots. The shots look very 2 dimensional, and i'm wondering if there's a way to either take the shot so that the distance between the 2 objects is more apparent, or post process it to bring that feature out. I took this one without a tripod, unfortunately; i just wasn't prepared when i set out, but found myself there and had to at least try a shot! Shot in RAW, ISO 250; 33mm; f10; 1/30. Any ideas?

Marylea

Race Brook Upper Falls
Race Brook Upper Falls...
(Download)

Reply
Jun 21, 2017 09:00:21   #
SonyA580 Loc: FL in the winter & MN in the summer
 
I would try some contrast adjustments to separate the rock from the water. I increased the darker levels in Photoshop and it made a big difference. You could also do the same thing on the RAW file. Nice shot!

Reply
Jun 22, 2017 06:39:25   #
fuminous Loc: Luling, LA... for now...
 
Yes, SonyA580 is right; tonal value changes might provide the aerial perspective you're wanting.

Darker, sharper, more contrast in foreground (elements advance), lighter, less contrast in background (elements recede).

Reply
 
 
Jun 22, 2017 08:56:33   #
melueth Loc: Central Florida
 
Thanks very much! I'd done some of that, but not outside of Lightroom.

ML

Reply
Jul 13, 2017 21:17:01   #
Charmdragon Loc: Plymouth, Massachusetts
 
Without seeing the whole scene with at least a 180-degree perspective, I believe what you are looking for is the 'perception' of depth. One way is to change your f-stop to make the rockface appear out of focus. That brings the focus of your subject (the waterfall) into stronger focus (the difference is creating a separation in the viewer's eye). You may have to zoom in or get physically closer (I can't tell from your image if that is possible). Another option may be to darken the rockface as though it is shade which will also highlight your subject with separation. An interesting tip I was given about waterfalls is that the water does travel the exact same path every moment. So once you have the focus and composition you want...take about five extra shots a few seconds apart. When you review them for processing, you will likely find a favored path from one image over all the others that enhances the presentation of the waterfall.

Reply
Jul 14, 2017 06:59:14   #
melueth Loc: Central Florida
 
Charmdragon wrote:
Without seeing the whole scene with at least a 180-degree perspective, I believe what you are looking for is the 'perception' of depth. One way is to change your f-stop to make the rockface appear out of focus. That brings the focus of your subject (the waterfall) into stronger focus (the difference is creating a separation in the viewer's eye). You may have to zoom in or get physically closer (I can't tell from your image if that is possible). Another option may be to darken the rockface as though it is shade which will also highlight your subject with separation. An interesting tip I was given about waterfalls is that the water does travel the exact same path every moment. So once you have the focus and composition you want...take about five extra shots a few seconds apart. When you review them for processing, you will likely find a favored path from one image over all the others that enhances the presentation of the waterfall.
Without seeing the whole scene with at least a 180... (show quote)


Great tips - thanks very much! It was a rugged climb to get to this waterfall, and this was as close as i could get, but i'm going back next June and will be better prepared! Thanks again.

ML

Reply
Jul 16, 2017 18:04:25   #
SoHillGuy Loc: Washington
 
The use of a wider angle lens would have shown more separation. If you concentrate on the lower portion of your photo you will see the separation from the upper portion. It just not that obvious due to the angle of the perspective.

Reply
 
 
Jul 18, 2017 08:12:05   #
rpavich Loc: West Virginia
 
melueth wrote:
Hey all - just came back from a neat trip to the Berkshires to try my hand at some waterfall photography. I learned a great deal, but am still a little baffled by this geological dilemma. The rock face that obscures a part of the waterfall below is a pretty fair distance from the actual falling water, but it doesn't look that way in any of my shots. The shots look very 2 dimensional, and i'm wondering if there's a way to either take the shot so that the distance between the 2 objects is more apparent, or post process it to bring that feature out. I took this one without a tripod, unfortunately; i just wasn't prepared when i set out, but found myself there and had to at least try a shot! Shot in RAW, ISO 250; 33mm; f10; 1/30. Any ideas?

Marylea
Hey all - just came back from a neat trip to the B... (show quote)


Yes, there is a way; get closer and use a wider lens. Longer lenses at farther distances tend to mash the "near / far" distinction between objects whereas wide lenses tend to accentuate them.

Lens selection is a tool in your arsenal to use to create certain effects like object relationship in a photo.

Reply
Jul 19, 2017 08:45:43   #
melueth Loc: Central Florida
 
Got it on the wider angle lens and proximity. I have another trip to this area planned for next year and will be better prepared for this one! Thanks for your insights and for taking a look!

Marylea

Reply
Jul 25, 2017 09:04:08   #
docdish Loc: Saint Petersburg, FL
 
You have a hyper-focal shot. If you want depth try opening the lens and spot focusing on your main subject. Most "program" settings are trying very hard to get everything in focus. You could use a "softening" tool on the foreground.

Reply
Jul 26, 2017 06:46:15   #
melueth Loc: Central Florida
 
docdish wrote:
You have a hyper-focal shot. If you want depth try opening the lens and spot focusing on your main subject. Most "program" settings are trying very hard to get everything in focus. You could use a "softening" tool on the foreground.


Right - this was taken in aperture priority mode. I get a second chance next June and this will be tried. Thanks for the advice!

ML

Reply
If you want to reply, then register here. Registration is free and your account is created instantly, so you can post right away.
Photo Analysis
UglyHedgehog.com - Forum
Copyright 2011-2024 Ugly Hedgehog, Inc.